Sarah's profile

Sarah's reviews

  5  
Sarah has 21 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Sarah's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, attentive, reliable, clear communication, responsive, supportive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Fantastic to work with!
about 1 month ago
Fantastic to work with!

Sarah was fantastic to work with throughout the process of finding our next investment property. She really understood what we were looking for as we continue to grow our rental portfolio and was always quick to answer questions, provide insight, and help us evaluate opportunities. Her knowledge of the market, attention to detail, and patience made the entire process smooth and stress-free. We truly appreciated having someone we could trust to guide us through every step. Highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking to buy real estate, especially investment properties!

Buyer review
We love Sarah!
about 2 months ago
We love Sarah!

Buying and selling a home is a real rollercoaster, and she helped calm our nerves. She was available whenever we had a random question or just needed to talk things through. Sarah was thoughtful and gave us practical things she did to make our lives easier - like dropping off drinks and snacks during the chaos of the move. She focuses on providing the kind of real help that actually matters when you're moving, rather than just the typical cliche gift. She is genuine, understanding, and truly gets the human side of this process. What made working with her even better was knowing our values align. When you're making one of the biggest financial decisions of your life, it matters who you're putting your trust (and your money) behind. We were so happy to have her in our corner!

Seller review
Consistent Results Over the Years
4 months ago
Consistent Results Over the Years

I’ve been working with Sarah for a few years now, and she has helped me sell several properties. She's reliable, steady, and easy to work with, which goes a long way in this business. Communication is consistent, and she handles the details without creating extra work on my end. While no transaction is ever completely stress-free, I can count on her to stay on top of things and get deals across the finish line.

Buyer review
We highly recommend Sarah!
5 months ago
We highly recommend Sarah!

Sarah was incredible to work with from start to finish. She reached out to us about a home in our preferred neighborhood the day it was listed, scheduled a showing immediately, and helped us secure an accepted offer within 24 hours. We had been searching for a house that truly checked our boxes for quite a while, and her thoughtfulness and attention to what we were looking for made all the difference. Her knowledge of the market and guidance on how to make our offer attractive in a competitive situation were invaluable. We felt supported and confident throughout the process and would highly recommend Sarah to anyone looking for a knowledgeable and proactive realtor.

Buyer review
Top notch!
5 months ago
Top notch!

Sarah was amazing, she paid attention to the small details we were looking for in a house and found just that. Come time to make a deal and close she made that process a breeze!

Buyer review
Best agent I’ve ever worked with
7 months ago
Best agent I’ve ever worked with

From the beginning of my home buying she was excellent and so helpful to work with. She responded to all my phone calls, texts and emails. No request or questions were too small or difficult for her to immediately answer. She is very professional and just great to work with!

Buyer review
Sarah is AMAZING!
9 months ago
Sarah is AMAZING!

Sarah goes above and beyond for her clients. She listens to your needs and conquers them! We will continue to work with Sarah on all of our future projects. Highly recommend her for all of your needs!

Seller review
Stop looking!!!!
9 months ago
Stop looking!!!!

Stop looking for the perfect realtor Sarah is who you are looking for! I could write a book on everything she hits the mark on! My wife is even a bigger fan! Hard working and dialed into the market. She came to us highly recommended and she was more than we expected.

Seller review
Sarah Shaffer is AMAZING!
9 months ago
Sarah Shaffer is AMAZING!

Sarah’s understanding of the current market trends helped guide us on pricing and she sold our house in under 5 days. She responded timely to all of our questions and kept us updated throughout the whole process. We need an errand she had one at our home in a matter of hours. Can’t imagine buying or selling without her. Make the call now.

Seller review
Sarah is AMAZING!
10 months ago
Sarah is AMAZING!

Sarah not only sold our house very quickly but she made the entire process effortless for us! She is truly amazing at what she does and we are forever thankful to her!

Buyer review
Sarah Rocks!
over 3 years ago
Sarah Rocks!

Sarah was a rockstar realtor to work with, and you can trust me on that, I’m in a band! But in all seriousness, she is incredibly knowledgeable and was always a clear concise communicator , which was especially helpful as a first-time home buyer. I really appreciated her patience during house showings – seriously, she must have the patience of a saint. She was always happy to give me the space and freedom to explore and figure out what I truly wanted. The entire process was surprisingly painless, and I have Sarah to thank for that. My favorite part was definitely her endless supply of good humor – whether facing a litany of lizards or basements that were certainly used for human sacrifice, she made the experience enjoyable. I can't recommend Sarah enough to anyone starting their home buying journey. She's truly the best!

Seller review
Amazing Experience
over 3 years ago
Amazing Experience

Sarah was incredible start to finish. She was super knowledgeable as to how to get our house ready for market, had a ton of great recommendations, held our hands when we needed extra support, and is an all-around amazing human. If you need a realtor, look no further! Sarah will have your back and make the experience as easy and painless as possible, with a little fun thrown in.

1 - 12 of 21
© 2026 RateMyAgent