Sally's profile

Sally's reviews

  5  
Sally has 33 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
about 1 year ago
Sally and Elizabeth know the San Diego market.

Sally and Elizabeth make a great team. They are both are knowledgeable, professional, helpful, and a pleasure to work with. They helped prepare our home for sale, presented it well and got it sold. Selling your home can be stressful and they helped navigate all the way through to the end. Great job👍

over 1 year ago
Our relationship with Sally Schoeffel began in 2013 when we were looking for an investment property

Our relationship with Sally Schoeffel began in 2013 when we were looking for an investment property. She made sure we were looking at areas with growth potential. After 11 years, it was time to sell. We looked at multiple options: go through a mortgage broker for a sale by owner, accept a direct cash offer from a corporate buyer, or what we finally decided, go with a realtor we trusted. There, really, was only one choice: Sally Schoeffel. She is so professional, soft spoken, and insightful. She is also a great listener, and a careful and thoughtful advisor, so she was the natural choice for us. We contacted her on December 31, 2024, and the property closed on February 14, 2025. We had an idea of what we wanted to net from the sale, and Sally recommended a price which felt reasonable. Within a month and a half, she arranged to list the property on the market and present showings. We were in ongoing conversations regarding how we could facilitate her efforts. She made recommendations, and we listened. Our goal, beyond selling, was to have a solid, smooth relationship, and as little wasted energy as possible. Sally made that happen. She is a professional’s professional. We are so happy to have worked with her not once, but twice.Sally, thank you.Melissa McKinstry and Doug Kipperman

over 1 year ago
Sally and Elizabeth are experts in the San Diego real estate market

Sally is an expert in the San Diego real estate market. She held multiple open houses and worked hard to find a buyer for our property. We were pleased with her service and would use her again. Would definitely recommend if you are buying or selling.

almost 3 years ago
Elizabeth and Sally did an outstanding job selling my North Park home

Elizabeth and Sally did an outstanding job selling my North Park home. Before hiring Elizabeth and Sally, I called around to find the top performing agents that focus on selling homes in the North/South Park region, and their names came highly recommended. I interviewed a few different agents, and by a long shot Sally and Elizabeth's knowledge exceeded everyone else's. It was really important for me to choose the right agent, as I was a first time home seller. They made the entire process seamless and were extremely responsive to all of my needs. They truly went above and beyond helping me to organize staging, professional cleaning and window washers. No detail went unnoticed. Additionally, They are very well connected in the community and know lots of the neighbors and happenings! They have a huge sphere of influence. I truly had an absolutely wonderful experience and would use Sally and Elizabeth again. I whole hearty recommend them!

over 4 years ago
Easy to communicate with, straightforward, knowledgeable, helpful, everything you would want

I have primarily worked with Sally both buying and selling for many years and she is great. Easy to communicate with, straight forward, knowledgeable, helpful, everything you would want from an agent. Both Sally and Elizabeth really know how to show a property and have referrals for all the work that needs to be done. No wasted time with Sally and Elizabeth.

over 4 years ago
We feel incredibly fortunate to have her in our network!

We were so fortunate that a local bartender recommended we check out the real estate agency down the street. We had no idea we were about to make a partner for life. Okay, so that sounds like a bit much but here's the deal. Elizabeth is not just a trusted real estate agent, she is also a trusted advisor and consultant on nearly all home related projects we do. Elizabeth has masterfully guided us through our first two home purchases, and has provided referrals and advice on our solar installation, back yard renovation project, rental property, insurance, plumbing, electric, the list goes on and on. To sum it up, Elizabeth is an incredible resource, and not limited to just real estate. My family trusts her as an advisor on many things because she's built, and knows how to leverage, a San Diego based network of professionals for so many things home related. We feel incredibly fortunate to have her in our network!

over 4 years ago
Sally and Elizabeth are truly amazing!

Sally and Elizabeth are truly amazing! They listed our house on 9/22 and closed escrow with an all cash, far over asking, offer on 10/19. It was easy and seamless. They personally primped our house with amazing orchid arrangements, decorative pillows, plants, and rugs. They staged one room in need of attention. They coordinated the photographer who also did the drone work. Everything was extremely professional and was fun. They know how to sell a home! With Sally and Elizabeth, you also get a third Schoeffel - Sarah - who is a social media whiz. Her "coming soon" post the day before the official listing went viral with over 30k views in about two hours. I cannot say enough about how awesome this team was!! Love them!

over 5 years ago
Elizabeth was fantastic throughout the entire process.

Elizabeth was fantastic throughout the entire process. We are demanding, picky folks and Elizabeth was right there for us at every turn. Add to that we were trying to find a home during a pandemic, from the other side of the country, and she still managed to make everything happen and got us into our dream home.

over 6 years ago
First time I've used this extremely professional team!

First time I've used this extremely professional team. It's not possible to say everything that's great about them (and their TEAM behind the scenes) they are really the best! I've never had a better experience in selling or buying a home...I highly recommend them and will only work with them in the future.

about 7 years ago
Where do I begin to recommend Sally and Elizabeth on a job well done and exceeded my expectations.

Where do I begin to recommend Sally and Elizabeth on a job well done and exceeded my expectations. 3 years earlier Sally represented me on a home purchase and I was equally as impressed. Although we had pre-planned the marketing of my home a month earlier with a "live" date in mid January, Sally recommended we go live immediately after the new year and I was under contract a week later with 2 strong offers. If you are looking for a seasoned, savvy professional that goes above and beyond in all aspects of the transaction Sally and Elizabeth are you team to get the job done. As I was relocating back to New England, they orchestrated the sell of my furniture to clients of theirs and made sure everything got done impeccably. This team will delight you and get you the results you intended. Kudos to you both and I will treasure our friendship built over the last 3 years. Steven B

over 7 years ago
Elizabeth is extremely knowledgeable of the greater San Diego market.

Elizabeth is extremely knowledgeable of the greater San Diego market. She is easy to reach and gets the fast turnaround time of the real estate market. I feel she always has her clients best interest at heart. Also, she is great if any post sale/purchase follow up is required. Highly recommend her!

over 7 years ago
I can't recommend them enough for any real estate need.

We have used this dynamic duo for all our home transactions over the years and have never been disappointed. They are both a please to work with, the right people to have on your side when things get a little tricky, and have a set of resources a mile long that can help get a home ready to sell or a new home ready to live in. I can't recommend them enough for any real estate need.

13 - 24 of 33
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent