S.'s profile

S.'s reviews

  5  
S. has 9 reviewsacross 3 different locations, showing 9.
Map view
Seller review
Perfect experience!
about 4 years ago
Perfect experience!

Sold both investment properties in a week for expected price.

Buyer review
Jay Siegall  was outstanding
over 5 years ago
Jay Siegall was outstanding

Jay Siegall was outstanding. He was attentive from the start taking us to properties for two days. He was patient and informative. He was prompt in his responses to our questions. If you are looking for a realtor in South West Florida look no further. Call Jay.

Buyer review
JAY SIEGALL HAS BEEN OUR(MY WIFE & i) REAL ESTATE PERSON SINCE WE
DECIDED TO MOVE FROM HOLLYWOOD
about 6 years ago
JAY SIEGALL HAS BEEN OUR(MY WIFE & i) REAL ESTATE PERSON SINCE WE DECIDED TO MOVE FROM HOLLYWOOD

JAY SIEGALL HAS BEEN OUR(MY WIFE & i) REAL ESTATE PERSON SINCE WE DECIDED TO MOVE FROM HOLLYWOOD, FL TO THE NAPLES-FT MYERS IN 2012 IN ORDER TO BE CLOSER TO OUR DAUGHTER. FIRST JAY FOUND US A RENTAL UNIT, THEN HE FOUND US A CONDO, THEN HE FOUND US A LARGER CONDO AND FINALLY IN A MATTER OF DAYS HE FOUND US A BUYER FOR THE LARGER CONDO AFTER WE MENTIONED TO HIM THAT WE'RE THINKING OF SCALING DOWN. IN ADDITION TO ALL OF THE ABOVE, I'VE ALWAYS FELT VERY COMFORTABLE RECOMMENDING JAY TO FAMILY & FRIENDS AND HE HAS BEEN VERY, VERY SUCCESSFUL IN PROVIDING THE SAME EXPERTISE TO THEM THAT HE HAS TO MY WIFE AND I.

Buyer review
Jay guided us through two transactions within 45 days
almost 9 years ago
Jay guided us through two transactions within 45 days

Jay guided us through two transactions within 45 days. We purchased a new home in June. Jay was a tremendous asset in negotiating the purchase, guiding us through the inspection and needed repairs prior to close. In July Jay was able to assist in selling the previous home. Again with his guidance we were able to complete the transaction with no issues. Both the purchase and sale occurred without us being present. If you are looking for an honest, hard working, and dedicated agent there are none better than Jay.

Buyer review
Jay was our agent when buying a new construction home in Bonita Springs
over 10 years ago
Jay was our agent when buying a new construction home in Bonita Springs

Jay was our agent when buying a new construction home in Bonita Springs. Being out of state Buyers we appreciate Jay’s experience and knowledge of the area. He made the purchase process simple, helped us out throughout the entire process, and was quick to return our calls or answer our questions. He did a superb job negotiating with the builder agent and was a pleasure to work with.

Buyer review
Jay was our agent in buying and selling condos
almost 11 years ago
Jay was our agent in buying and selling condos

Jay was our agent in buying and selling condos. He was very knowledgeable and had excellent relations with other agents. In the buying process which was complex due to liens and a pending foreclosure auction, he got the job done for us. It wasn't easy. Our sale took a while, but we stayed with Jay until it sold. He knows Miromar inside and out and is dedicated to to his clients.

Buyer review
We worked with Jay over the past 3-months to purchase a home in SWF
almost 13 years ago
We worked with Jay over the past 3-months to purchase a home in SWF

We worked with Jay over the past 3-months to purchase a home in SWF. With all sincerity, he is a 5-star real estate agent. You rarely meet a person like Jay who has the highest integrity, honesty and market expertice. He listens to what you are looking for in a home and has the unique ability to guide you in the right direction. Most importantly, Jay is someone you can trust. G & D Rainer

1 - 9 of 9
© 2026 RateMyAgent