Penny's profile

Penny's reviews

  4.9  
Penny has 30 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Penny's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, responsive, attentive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Awesome agent
21 days ago
Awesome agent

Penny was an amazing advisor, agent and friend. She was was completely knowledgeable, friendly and communicated constantly. I would recommend her to anyone.

Buyer review
Excellent real estate agent!
about 2 months ago
Excellent real estate agent!

Very easy to work with .. always there day or night any time I needed help. Highly recommend!

Seller review
Wonderful experience
5 months ago
Wonderful experience

We owned a beautiful, unique house in Henrietta. When my husband was transferred to Ohio in January, 2024, he moved. The family & I stayed until school was out in June. (Go Bearcats!) We listed the house and moved the family that summer. We originally listed with an agent from Wichita Falls. They advertised near & far. But, they we're off on the listing price. It never sold. After my first agents' term ran out, we decided to hire someone local. I knew a little about Penny. She & I had attended a quilting weekend camp together a few years ago. She had invited me to her church when we were new in Henrietta. So, when I decided to go local, I only thought of her. Penny jumped in from the word, "go". She gave us a realistic expectation of what this house, in this market, should sell for. She was right. After waiting a year & a half. Penny took our house & sold it. She was extremely easy to work with. A very down to earth, Clay County, kind of lady. She knows her stuff. She sold our home, and relieved us the financial pressure of paying for two homes for over a year & a half. In this holiday season, I'm grateful!

Buyer review
Great Experience!
5 months ago
Great Experience!

Penny was great to work with. She was patient, knowledgeable, and answered all of our questions.

Seller review
Excellent realtor
6 months ago
Excellent realtor

A great realtor to list with.

Buyer review
Long Distance Purchase
8 months ago
Long Distance Purchase

We bought a house, practically sight unseen and out of town. Penny was very accommodating and helpful during the whole process. Communication was never an issue. I would definitely recommend her.

Seller review
Penny is an awesome realtor agent
8 months ago
Penny is an awesome realtor agent

Penny is a Rock star to work with! This was our 2nd home to sell with Penny and she has always gone out of her way to help us in every way. I would recommend her to anyone. Not only is she a great realtor, I also consider her my friend. Thanks again friend for all you help, Marchuetta

Seller review
Fantastic
12 months ago
Fantastic

Penny kept on top of everything even though the housing market was real slow. She worked diligently to get our house sold.

Seller review
A true partner in the home selling experience
about 1 year ago
A true partner in the home selling experience

Penny Riordan is a true partner in the home selling and buying process. Penny takes the time to go over the pros and cons with listings and budgets while maintaining a consistent level of communication. We have been partnering with Penny for well over 10 years and cannot say enough about her availability and partnership for our family.

1 - 12 of 30
© 2026 RateMyAgent