Peggy's profile

Peggy's reviews

  5  
Peggy has 14 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
about 1 month ago
A Go Getter

Peggy is phenomenal. I have purchased three different homes and have sold two using her expertise. She is prompt, professional, and a go getter. She will not stop until the job is done. If she is not available at the time of your call, Grace in her office will keep you in the loop. I'm so thankful for the team I worked with. I would recommend Peggy and her team over anybody in the area.

7 months ago
Very happy

Overall very happy with the results of the sale of my house.

7 months ago
Peggy is fantastic!

We had a criteria we wanted to meet, and she came through! She got us into the new house, sold the old house within 48 hours and also sold my Sons house. Perfect timing, perfect communication. We hope to never move again, but recommend her wholeheartedly.

about 1 year ago
Great experience!

Great experience! Peggy was patient, personable and very accommodating. She worked on our schedule and always made herself available. She communicated often and kept up on everything during the buying process. Would definitely recommend!

over 1 year ago
Peggy is a go getter. She or her assistant, Grace responded quickly to our questions.

Dawn and I were high maintenance buyers. Most of our search was done from our home in Texas. This meant that Peggy and Grace had to constantly follow up on questions on the many properties we were interested in during our four-and-a-half-month search. Many of the questions would not have been necessary if we were seeing the properties in person. Peggy provided pictures or did a virtual tour with us so that we could see more details than were available from the pictures and information that were on the web site (Lakehomes.com). Peggy and Grace were very patient with us and worked as a very effective team. Peggy was always very professional, is highly knowledgeable of the market for both lots and homes around Smith Mountain Lake and communicated constantly by phone, text or email along with Grace. Dawn and I thoroughly enjoyed working with Peggy and Grace and would recommend them to any buyer who is looking for a great team to help them find a property.

over 1 year ago
Peggy Oversteek did an outstanding job selling our SML home

Peggy Overstreet did an outstanding job selling our Smith Mountain Lake home. She saw that our home had more value than other realtors and priced it accordingly. We got more than expected! By posting our photos and announcing "Coming Soon" 21 days in advance of the MLS listing, we had two days of people lined up to see our home. She guided us through the negotiation stage when we had multiple offers and helped us with contractors when we needed some advice on repairs. Peggy is a well-connected, enthusiastic, hard-working realtor who has her client's best interests at heart. We are happy to give her our highest recommendation!

over 1 year ago
Very knowledgeable

Peggy was so great to meet our needs! She answered all of our questions and bothered the other real estate agent enough to get them to hurry up

almost 2 years ago
Professional and energetic!

Peggy will stop at nothing to get you the property you are interested in! She works for you, the buyer, to make it happen! Can’t say enough how pleased we are with her expertise!

about 2 years ago
Great experience

Peggy was great to work with. She looked after our interest with buying our condo. She is knowledgeable with the market and was on our side in trying to get the best deal that we could get. She also has a support team that works with her that will help out with anything if Peggy is busy with other buyers or sellers. She has a great personality and hope to have her has a friend in years to come. We will definitely use her for any other real estate needs that we may have in the future at SML.

about 2 years ago
Peggy Overstreet helped us find what we were looking for!

Peggy did a nice job finding homes for us to see in our price range. She had a good understanding of the market and helped us negotiate a fair price. We are grateful for Peggy’s assistance in purchasing our home on SML.

1 - 12 of 14
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent