Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 23 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 months ago
Nicole cares about her customers

We had never sold a property before, so we didn’t know what to expect. Nicole Yeingst was so helpful in selling our home. We had done a few renovations and she made a few suggestions for us to help improve the value of our house. She took care of running the open house for us as well as coordinating with the buyers and their agents to get us the best possible offers. She was willing to come to the house to meet with us on multiple occasions to go over paperwork so that we didn’t have to drive to the real estate office. There was even a point after we were under contract with a buyer that the appraiser wanted us to have something treated in our basement. Nicole recommended a contractor and even set up the appointment time for him to come and complete the work within a week to ensure we stayed on track for our settlement date. She guided us through every step of the process and made everything so smooth and simple. I would definitely recommend her services to anyone looking to buy or sell a property.

over 1 year ago
Top-Notch Realtor

Nicole Yeingst of Keller Williams Keystone Realty is a Top-Notch realtor. We were able to get our house under contract within one weekend. Nicole is responsive, easy to talk with, and has contacts for anything and everything. If you are in need of a realtor, give Nicole a call. You will not be disappointed.

over 1 year ago
Top-Notch Realtor

Nicole Yeingst of Keller Williams Keystone Realty is a top-notch realtor who goes above and beyond to help you find your dream home and or property. It took us over 1 1/2 years to find a specific type of home and property with acreage in Dillsburg and Nicole was patient the entire time. She is very knowledgeable about Dillsburg and surrounding areas. Nicole is responsive, easy to talk with, and has contacts for anything and everything. If you are in need of a realtor, give Nicole a call. You will not be disappointed.

almost 2 years ago
Nicole is a Top Tier Agent

We've conducted several transactions with Nicole, and she always makes us feel valued and supported as clients. Even when we were just in the dreaming phase of our new home, she took us seriously and made the time to visit houses with us. The dream became a reality and we couldn't have done it without Nicole!

about 2 years ago
Above and beyond realtor

Nicole went above and beyond to help me find the perfect house using her professional knowledge and experience. Friendly and answered any questions that I had. A great experience. Always there for me

over 2 years ago
Outstanding, Personal Service Over a Long Time!

Nicole provided invaluable insights and options throughout what became a year + period in getting our house on the market and sold. And through her guidance, we got much more than we originally expected to receive for our house. Keeping the personal touch at the forefront, Nicole visited the house several times throughout the preparation for sale, and was instrumental in us making the right decisions. Can't say enough as to our appreciation of Nicole's fine work!

over 2 years ago
Excellent Realtor!

Nicole was was great at every aspect of her job. She's incredibly knowledgeable of real estate, the market, homeowners insurance, literally every aspect! And if she didn't have an answer, or one she felt sure of, she'd jump through hoops to find us the answer. She was patient with our extremely energetic son who was always along for showings, even played with him to keep him occupied while we did a small repair needed for financing 😊 I was very happy that she was referred to us! Nicole is an impressive real estate agent, don't look for anyone else!

about 3 years ago
Extremely satisfied with Nichol's knowledge, efforts, and professionalism.

Nichole was patient and accommodating in searching for our new home. She provided important and useful input while staying professional. She provided information regarding financing options and assisted us in marketing our existing home. Nichole was responsive and attentive to our needs and requests. She was personable yet professional. Her efforts exceeded our expectations. My wife and I would definitely recommend Nichole.

about 3 years ago
Excellent

Nichole is very professional, capable, and responsive. She is quite knowledgeable about the market and ways of navigating it. She went above, and beyond what we expected from an agent. We definitely recommend her.

about 3 years ago
Wonderful Experience

Nicole was wonderful every step of the way. She walked me through everything. Very kind, caring and professional.

over 3 years ago
Great experience!

This was our first time buying a home and Nicole navigated us through the whole experience amazingly! She was professional and always available to communicate each step. Also very knowledgeable about the current market and the houses themselves. Would highly recommend!

1 - 12 of 23
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent