Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  4.9  
Nicole has 12 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
over 1 year ago
Nicole Shettleroe is an amazing realtor!

I can't say enough wonderful things about Nicole. We weren't sure we were ready to move yet, because we hadn't found a house we loved. Nicole not only found us our dream home but was able to get our offer accepted even though we hadn't even listed our house for sale yet!! She managed to make what could have been a rather stressful transaction based on contingencies go so incredibly smoothly!! She kept the lines of communication open and flowing between ourselves and the selling agent as well as the agent who was selling our home at the time. She made sure all the I's were dotted and T's were crossed. We couldn't make our inspection on the home and she was there every step of the way taking notes and keeping us informed. We always felt that she kept our best interest as top of priority. Even after we closed and had a question or two about the house or something in it, she always reached out to the other realtor to have pur questions answered. She went above and beyond for my family amd we are so thankful!! We now have our forever home and are so happy and we have Nicole to thank for that! I would 100% recommend her services over and over again.

almost 3 years ago
Best Realtor A+

We recently had the pleasure of working with Nicole as our real estate agent, and I cannot emphasize enough how impressed we were with her exceptional professionalism and dedication to ensuring a positive and successful transaction. From start to finish, Nicole's customer-focused approach, collaborative nature, and commitment to the best interest of all parties involved truly set her apart. Nicole consistently prioritized our satisfaction throughout the entire process, making us feel valued and understood as a client. She facilitated clear and open lines of communication, ensuring that all parties were on the same page and working towards a shared goal. Nicole consistently acted with integrity and transparency, ensuring that each party felt heard, respected, and well-informed throughout the entire process. Her commitment to fairness and ethical practices truly shone through, establishing a foundation of trust and reliability that is often hard to find in the real estate industry.

almost 3 years ago
5 out of 5

Thanks to Nicole's dedication and expertise, my real estate experience was nothing short of exceptional. Her customer-focused approach, collaborative nature, and commitment to the best interest of all parties involved resulted in a smooth and successful transaction. I can confidently say that Nicole is a consummate professional who truly cares about her clients' satisfaction and strives to achieve the best outcomes for everyone involved. If you are in need of a real estate agent who will prioritize your needs, foster collaboration, and ensure the best interest of all parties, I wholeheartedly recommend working with Nicole. Her exceptional skills, dedication, and commitment to excellence make her an invaluable asset in the real estate industry.

over 3 years ago
Nicole is a great asset when selling your home.

From the first time we reached out to Nicole she answered immediately and from there on out she was very responsive. She was a true professional. During the entire process of selling our home we always felt like she had our best interest in mind. She was very informative and answered our many questions. We highly recommend her to all of our family and friends.

over 3 years ago
Nicole's review

Working with Nicole was so easy. She's very knowledgeable and in control. She would guide me without pushing and let me know the pros and cons before I made a decision. Also always willing to help.

about 4 years ago
"Nicole truly had our best interest at heart

"Nicole truly had our best interest at heart. She listened to our expectations, and shared her experiences to create a marketing platform that sold our house in just one weekend. She was present and available anytime we needed her and told us when she was not available because of personal commitments. She is such a pleasant person and truly becomes your friend through the experience. Nicole is a breath of fresh air. There is no “double-speak,” she keeps you informed and does not give false hope, she just speaks the truth, which is what sellers and buyers want to hear. I would never use another agent in Temecula again. Nicole is the only agent we trust and would highly recommend to anyone buying or selling in the Temecula area."

about 4 years ago
The room mom of real estate

You know “the mom” who takes care of everything in your kids classroom, makes everything fun and has it all together. That’s Nicole! She was kind, detailed-oriented, and never dropped the ball. She held our hand through the entire process with professionalism and clearly defined the next steps when we hit a milestone. After all, it had been twenty years since we sold our last house, so we appreciated her experience and follow-through. On top of all that, our home sold over asking price!

over 4 years ago
"I met Nicole Shettleroe while viewing another property she had listed

"I met Nicole Shettleroe while viewing another property she had listed. While that property was not what i wanted, i liked her approach, energy and local knowledge and she agreed to help me with my home search. Nicole was fantastic and worked very hard to make sure we had a successful purchasing outcome. She is very knowledgable, responsive and super helpful. I would not hesitate to use Nicole again for my real estate needs."

over 4 years ago
"Nicole was amazing from the beginning! She was super helpful in assisting us with our many questio

"Nicole was amazing from the beginning! She was super helpful in assisting us with our many questions and concerns. Nicole’s marketing plan was flawless! She achieved multiple offers and sold our home well over asking price. We are so grateful to her for her attention to detail and excellent coordination between us and buyers. Nicole is very positive, professional, polite, friendly, trustworthy and knowledgeable. She made the process rather painless. If you are looking to purchase or sell a property we highly recommend Nicole Shettleroe."

over 4 years ago
Nicole was amazing from the beginning!

She was super helpful in assisting us with our many questions and concerns. Nicole’s marketing plan was flawless! She achieved multiple offers and sold our home well over asking price. We are so grateful to her for her attention to detail and excellent coordination between us and buyers. Nicole is very positive, professional, polite, friendly, trustworthy and knowledgeable. She made the process rather painless. If you are looking to purchase or sell a property we highly recommend Nicole Shettleroe.

over 4 years ago
Nicole was prepared, had a great understanding of the area and professional.

Nicole was an amazing agent. She knew that we were original owners of the home, raised our family here and how much our home meant to us. She was extremely prepared, on time and paid attention to detail. Our home photos were beautiful. Everything during the entire process was smooth. We can't thank her enough for all she did to sell our home!

over 5 years ago
"Nicole was fantastic! It is a tough market and she powered through

Nicole was fantastic! It is a tough market and she powered through. She was so positive and kept us going even when we were feeling a little defeated. It was our first homebuying experience, so we had many questions about the process and expectations. Nicole was great in walking us through, even the most mundane tasks to ensure we understood what each step was and why it was happening. We appreciate her patience and willingness to educate us. We will definitely work with Nicole again in the future.

1 - 12 of 12
© 2026 RateMyAgent