Nicole's profile

Nicole's reviews

  5  
Nicole has 27 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Nicole's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, friendly, local expert, responsive.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent communicator who went above and beyond to assist us with selling our home.
8 days ago
Excellent communicator who went above and beyond to assist us with selling our home.

NIcki is especially professional in that she she is very knowledgeable about how to negotiate the selling of your home and is creative with marketing by using social media and/or in person via open houses. Having never sold a home before, Nicki was always kind and patient with any questions we had and thorough with her answers. She was always prompt to return a call if she had been unavailable at the time. Overall, we were pleased and appreciative of all Nicki did to assist us with selling our home.

Seller review
The best guidance when we needed it the most!
5 months ago
The best guidance when we needed it the most!

This summer we decided it was time for our family to make a big change, and everyday I am so grateful it was Nicki who answered my Zillow request to view the home I am now writing this from! She immediately responded, was quick to schedule a tour plus a few other homes. When we decided to put an offer on our new home we still had to get our previous home ready to sell; our initial offer wasn't accepted, so we got our house ready to list in hopes we could get it under contract quickly. First, we tried selling it on our own, and even though we had not listed it with Nicki, she was still intentional to check in regularly to see how the FSBO was going. After a few weeks (and tears...) of showing our house with no luck, we decided to list our home with Nicki, and it was the best decision we made. By listing with her we were able to negotiate a new offer on our new home, have our previous home under contract within the set closing window, negotiate a 2 week closing on our previous home, manage home inspections and lender requirements - and she handled every text, email and phone call for both properties. Her help/knowledge with negotiating offers was probably the most eye-opening and valuable piece for us - we would have left money on the table and possibly lost out on our current home without her guidance. I can't put a price on the amount of stress she off-loaded for us during an already difficult season; her personal and professional knowledge she shared with me was invaluable. She truly was an answer to prayer. I can't say enough great things about Nicki and I can't wait to recommend her to everyone I know looking to buy or sell!

Seller review
Friendly and Knowledgeable
5 months ago
Friendly and Knowledgeable

Nicki was great to work with and made our selling experience go smooth and quick. We very much recommend her as an agent for buying or selling.

Buyer review
She is awesome. She went above all my needs
9 months ago
She is awesome. She went above all my needs

This house hunting period was so try working around so many obstacles trying to get first one place then another.. There were some hurdles I didn't think I would get over. But Nicki got me there. She was so understanding and she help me see all the problems and helped me understand them and get them fixed. She was there for all my questions and solved them in a timely manner. Her knowledge of what the loan people needed from me was awesome. We teamed up and got it done. Thank you Nicki

Seller review
Simply the best!
10 months ago
Simply the best!

Have bought and sold houses with Nicki and I would recommend her to anyone. We actually wouldn't work with anyone else. She is always accessible, knows the area's inventory, can get contractors do actually do work in a timely fashion, and doesn't blow smoke about property values. Maybe most importantly, she presents you with information in non-pushy way so the client can make decisions without unneeded pressure. When it comes time to buy/sell again...she will be our first call.

Buyer review
A Seamless and Truly Exceptional Home Buying Journey with Nicki: A Realtor Who Goes Above and Beyond
about 1 year ago
A Seamless and Truly Exceptional Home Buying Journey with Nicki: A Realtor Who Goes Above and Beyond

An Unforgettable Home Buying Experience with Nicki Keuneke Working with Nicki was nothing short of extraordinary. From the very first conversation to the final closing and beyond, Nicki demonstrated a level of professionalism, care, and commitment that far exceeded our expectations. Buying a home can be an overwhelming process, but Nicki made it feel smooth, manageable, and even enjoyable. What truly set Nicki apart was her ability to truly listen. She didn’t just ask what we were looking for in a home—she took the time to understand our lifestyle, priorities, and long-term goals. Her questions were thoughtful, and her advice was always rooted in our best interest. We felt seen and heard from day one, which built a foundation of trust that never wavered. Nicki’s deep knowledge of the local market was invaluable. She had an instinct for which homes and neighborhoods would suit our needs, and her insights helped us make confident decisions. When we had questions, she had clear, helpful answers. When we needed guidance, she offered it with grace and clarity. When it came time to negotiate, Nicki was an incredible advocate. She navigated every detail with precision and kept the entire process moving forward efficiently. Thanks to her hard work, we were able to secure a home we absolutely love, without unnecessary stress or delays. She even went the extra mile after closing, checking in on us, and offering helpful referrals. Nicki isn’t just a skilled real estate professional—she’s a genuine, kind-hearted person who truly cares about her clients. She turned what could have been a stressful life change into a positive, memorable experience. We are incredibly grateful for her dedication, and we can confidently say we wouldn’t be where we are without her. If you're looking for a realtor who will not only deliver results but treat your journey with the care it deserves, Nicki is the one. She made our dream a reality—and for that, we can’t thank her enough.

Buyer review
Amazing!!!
about 1 year ago
Amazing!!!

Talk about the level of communication! Nicole always got back with me in very timely manner, made sure I understood what was happening during the buying process and did her best to answer my questions!! I will definitely work with her again in the future and I highly recommend you contact Nicole as well for your buying or selling experience!! For being a first time buyer, she made this experience, an amazing one.

Seller review
We Couldn’t Have Asked for a Better Realtor!
about 1 year ago
We Couldn’t Have Asked for a Better Realtor!

Working with Nicki was an absolute pleasure! She made both selling our home and buying a new one such a smooth and stress-free experience. From day one, she was incredibly organized, proactive, and always a step ahead. Every time we thought to reach out about something, she had already taken care of it—making the entire process effortless for us. Nicki’s knowledge of the market, sharp attention to detail, and professionalism truly set her apart. She guided us through every step with confidence and care, whether it was preparing our home for sale, negotiating the best deal, or handling all the paperwork seamlessly. We always felt like we were in the best hands. If you're looking for a realtor who genuinely cares, takes the stress out of the process, and goes above and beyond for her clients, Nicki is the one! We couldn’t be happier with our experience, and we highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Nicki took care of us!
about 1 year ago
Nicki took care of us!

Cannot recommend Nicki highly enough! She took the time to get to know our goals and what was important to us, so that she could send us options as soon as possible for us to look at. She took care of everything we needed from the day we met her through getting the keys. She worked around our tough schedules and coordinated everything for us. The whole time she carefully explained everything so we weren’t lost. Finally, she was awesome to have around! We are so so grateful to have had her. She helped us find and buy the perfect home and we never had to sweat the small details along the way.

Seller review
 Findlay All-Star Real Estate Agent!
about 1 year ago
Findlay All-Star Real Estate Agent!

Nikki Keuneke is a delight to work with! Knowledgeable about the market. Great Communication skills. Excellent negotiator. Diplomatic. Savvy. Skilled at business side of Real Estate! Nikki did a remarkable job marketing our property. She got us a full price cash offer for our house! Whether you're buying or selling, I can't imagine anyone better to work with than Nicole Keuneke! She is honest, thoughtful, displays high integrity and is just a kind person. We are grateful for the wonderful job she did for our family. Our buyer was happy too. Nikki handled both sides of the transaction!

Seller review
Attentive & Dedicated
about 1 year ago
Attentive & Dedicated

Saying Nicole is amazing to work with is an understatement. Very knowledgeable in the real estate market, personable, quick to respond to personal communication; additionally she takes the time to answer questions and provide necessary guidance for her clients to make decisions. Nicki was recommended to me by Brittany Jackson and I instantly felt comfortable with her handling the details to sell my home of 20 years. She exceeded my expectations, I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. I am happy to now call her a friend.

Buyer review
Awesome Experience!
over 1 year ago
Awesome Experience!

Nicki was very professional. We threw a lot at her and she never seemed upset or bothered by anything. 10/10 would recommend her to anyone looking for a home!

1 - 12 of 27
© 2026 RateMyAgent