Neil's profile

Neil's reviews

  5  
Neil has 40 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
My wife and I cannot begin to thank Neil and his fantastic team enough for the diligence, profession
over 2 years ago
My wife and I cannot begin to thank Neil and his fantastic team enough for the diligence, profession

My wife and I cannot begin to thank Neil and his fantastic team enough for the diligence, professionalism, and expertise they displayed when helping us finally find the first home that we always dreamed of. We were in the market for a home for over two years when we contacted Neil, and making that connection proved to be one of the most important decisions we made in the process. Neil quickly and thoughtfully navigated a turbulent market to locate an off-market listing that was perfect for us. It was evident from the beginning that Neil and his team have a passion for what they do - they are true professionals in every sense of the word and I recommend Neil and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Many thanks to Neil and to The Mathias Team!

Seller review
Neil thank you and your team for being so helpful and supportive for selling and buying my home...
over 2 years ago
Neil thank you and your team for being so helpful and supportive for selling and buying my home...

Neil thank you and your team for being so helpful and supportive for selling and buying my home in less than one month you are amazing. Thanks for being so patient with us to answer all questions and keep us updated. Your wonderful team specially Kelsea she is great and she has been very helpful and supportive thank you all so much. Sakineh Shamsali

Seller review
I recently had the pleasure of working with Neil and The Mathias Team selling my home in Dublin, Ohi
over 2 years ago
I recently had the pleasure of working with Neil and The Mathias Team selling my home in Dublin, Ohi

I recently had the pleasure of working with Neil and The Mathias Team selling my home in Dublin, Ohio. From start to finish, Neil and his team demonstrated exception professionalism, outstanding communication and went above and beyond to make the process of selling my first home a breeze. Throughout the entire process, Neil kept me well-informed, promptly responding to my questions and providing updates at every crucial stage. This level of responsiveness was truly commendable and contributed significantly to a smooth and stress-free experience. Neil and his team facilitated a remote closing for me. Their expertise in navigating the intricacies of a remote closing process were evident and they ensured that all necessary documents were organized and completed efficiently. Their evaluation of my home was very detailed and recommendations for improvements were fair and honest. Being remote, Neil and his team were able to leverage their connections and go the extra mile to be there in my place for all the inspections and events needed to get my house ready for sale. I wholeheartedly recommend Neil and The Mathias Team to anyone in search of a reliable and trustworthy real estate professional.

Seller review
I am a senior & a widow. My present home has become too much for me to maintain. I just purchased...
about 3 years ago
I am a senior & a widow. My present home has become too much for me to maintain. I just purchased...

I am a senior & a widow. My present home has become too much for me to maintain. I just purchased a smaller condo & the entire process went extremely smoothly. I give all the credit to the Mathias Team of realtors. The Mathias team helped & supported me through the entire process. The home I am selling was photographed beautifully & the brochures & on line video made my condo a show place. I had ten showings in three days & received two offers. The Mathias Team found me a new home & sold my current home. I would highly recommend the Mathias Team to sell or find you the perfect home. They all did an outstanding job understanding my wants & needs & answered every question I had. I am looking forward to the next chapter of my life in my new home.

Seller review
When you hire a realtor to sell you home, the objective is usually the same; sell our home at the pr
over 3 years ago
When you hire a realtor to sell you home, the objective is usually the same; sell our home at the pr

When you hire a realtor to sell you home, the objective is usually the same; sell our home at the price we asked as quickly as possible. But it's never that easy. Decisions have to be made regarding upgrades or changes to the property and the price for the property. Neil came in and made several minor suggestions that would help sell the home. We agreed on the price and on the first day the listing went live, we had a cash offer at the price we asked. Mission accomplished! Neil was a pleasure to work with and kept his finger on the pulse of everything right up to the closing.

Seller review
Neil was recommended to us by close friends and we’re so glad we went with him!
almost 4 years ago
Neil was recommended to us by close friends and we’re so glad we went with him!

Neil was recommended to us by close friends and we’re so glad we went with him! Neil really paid attention to details we wanted and was always very professional. We never felt any pressure with him as he recognized that finding and buying the right home can be a process. He was honest and very straightforward about each home he showed. Neil was also incredibly responsive in this extremely competitive market. The Mathias Team was phenomenal and we can’t thank them enough for helping us find and purchase our dream home!

Buyer review
I was introduced to Neil, of The Mathias Team of Cutler Real Estate, by chance
over 4 years ago
I was introduced to Neil, of The Mathias Team of Cutler Real Estate, by chance

I was introduced to Neil, of The Mathias Team of Cutler Real Estate, by chance. We are first time home buyers, and we were living out of Ohio. I found a home which matched our style, and I immediately reached out and introduced myself to the agent listing. Our encounter there was exactly what my husband and I needed. No pressure, a lot of support, and some hand holding. Neil and his team were absolutely wonderful in helping us make the best choices. He treated us as if we were the only clients he had and immediately we felt at ease. Moving into a state you know nothing about is intimidating enough, but not with the Mathias real estate team. We greatly appreciate such a supportive team, from day one till today.

Buyer review
The next time we buy or sell real estate, Neil will be the first call that we make.
almost 5 years ago
The next time we buy or sell real estate, Neil will be the first call that we make.

My wife and I recently sold our house (as a FSBO) to a family that Neil represented as a buyer's broker. During the entire process from initial inquiry through contracting, inspection, follow up and closing, we found Neal to be a very professional and seasoned real estate broker who was firm, yet fair, in the manner in which he dealt with us. We also found Neil's support team to be resourceful and goal oriented in a manner that ensured us a predictable and smooth closing. The next time we buy or sell real estate, Neil will be the first call that we make.

Seller review
Working with Neil made selling our condo a breeze
almost 5 years ago
Working with Neil made selling our condo a breeze

Working with Neil made selling our condo a breeze. From providing a stager to help us get our home ready for showing to helping us set a listing price Neil was there for the entire process. Any questions we had were quickly answered. In short ,what can be a very difficult experience was stress free thanks to Neil’s knowledge and hard work. We highly recommend Neil Mathias.

Buyer review
My wife and I were first time home buyers, and we probably would not have the beautiful home we live
over 5 years ago
My wife and I were first time home buyers, and we probably would not have the beautiful home we live

My wife and I were first time home buyers, and we probably would not have the beautiful home we live in now without Neil. We started our home search during this extreme seller’s market, but Neil helped us navigate it confidently. He is an out-of-box thinker, and he was able to make our offer stand out when there were 20+ others. What we were most happy with was Neil’s willingness to go above and beyond to build relationships with the sellers’ agents to make sure all their questions about our offers were answered. We would recommend Neil as your buyers agent.

25 - 36 of 40
© 2026 RateMyAgent