Neil's profile

Neil's reviews

  5  
Neil has 50 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Neil's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
We recently had the pleasure of working with Neil as our buyer’s agent, and we couldn’t be more sati
about 2 years ago
We recently had the pleasure of working with Neil as our buyer’s agent, and we couldn’t be more sati

We recently had the pleasure of working with Neil as our buyer’s agent, and we couldn’t be more satisfied with the experience. Neil and his team were fantastic! Neil's deep insight into the local market in the greater Columbus, Ohio area was invaluable. He came highly recommended with great references, and he certainly lived up to his reputation. He made the entire process smooth and stress-free for us. From the get-go, Neil was friendly, approachable, transparent, and incredibly easy to work with. He took the time to understand our needs & preferences, even as we were actively figuring them out during our search for a home. I've worked with two other realtors before in other states, and I must commend Neil for his exceptional attention to detail during the home search and under-contract phases. If we ever find ourselves buying or selling a home in this area again, or if we need to recommend a realtor to friends or family, Neil will be our first choice without hesitation. Neil and the Mathias team were 10/10.

Buyer review
Neil Mathias and his team recently helped me purchase another investment property
over 2 years ago
Neil Mathias and his team recently helped me purchase another investment property

Neil Mathias and his team recently helped me purchase another investment property. His market knowledge and negotiating skills helped us get a great value and close the deal in less than 1 week, while beating out another offer. I have worked with many realtors over the years. Neil is hands down one of the best in the greater Columbus area. He is a fantastic communicator and you can tell he truly cares about his clients and their investments. Thank you Neil for an easy professional transaction! Proud to have you on our side of the table!

Buyer review
Neil and his team were great to work with
over 2 years ago
Neil and his team were great to work with

Neil and his team were great to work with. He always follows up and responds quickly. They did a great job helping us find our new home in Ohio.

Seller review
Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard
over 2 years ago
Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard

Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard. The decision to use the Mathias team to sell our home was the best decision we made. Neal and his entire team treated us like family as we journeyed through the entire process. I would highly recommend using this no pressure, highly professional team for your house hunting or selling experience. They will not disappoint. Lonnie & Lynne McLaughlin

Seller review
Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard
over 2 years ago
Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard

Our decision to leave the home we have loved so much was hard. The decision to use the Mathias team to sell our home was the best decision we made. Neil and his entire team treated us like family as we journeyed through the entire process. I would highly recommend using this no pressure, highly professional team for your house hunting or selling experience. They will not disappoint.

Buyer review
When we started our recent home search, our first call was to Neil because of a previous great exper
over 2 years ago
When we started our recent home search, our first call was to Neil because of a previous great exper

When we started our recent home search, our first call was to Neil because of a previous great experience with him and his team. After considering some existing properties, we decided on a semi-custom new build. Neil has been a fantastic resource with every step of the process including contract negotiations, suggestions on floor plan modifications, deciding which features make the most sense for my family's needs, and cost/benefit of various upgrades. Neil's years of experience and knowledge of the local market made him a valuable resource to have on our side. Highly recommend Neil Mathias, whether you are buying or selling.

Buyer review
Neil Mathias was instrumental in helping us (Patrick & Cindy Homoelle) better understand the multipl
over 2 years ago
Neil Mathias was instrumental in helping us (Patrick & Cindy Homoelle) better understand the multipl

Neil Mathias was instrumental in helping us (Patrick & Cindy Homoelle) better understand the multiple steps of the new build process including; contract budget, design, pricing , and most importantly - suggesting architectural changes to the standard floor plan based on his experiences with other new builds and our particular needs. We could not have been more pleased with Neil’s advice & counsel during the 3Pillar new build experience. Patrick & Cindy Homoelle

Buyer review
Neil was with us every step of the way
almost 3 years ago
Neil was with us every step of the way

Neil was with us every step of the way. Always available and able to answer any questions about the building process and even layout and design. We knew we were well taken care of with Neil and his team!

Buyer review
My wife and I cannot begin to thank Neil and his fantastic team enough for the diligence, profession
almost 3 years ago
My wife and I cannot begin to thank Neil and his fantastic team enough for the diligence, profession

My wife and I cannot begin to thank Neil and his fantastic team enough for the diligence, professionalism, and expertise they displayed when helping us finally find the first home that we always dreamed of. We were in the market for a home for over two years when we contacted Neil, and making that connection proved to be one of the most important decisions we made in the process. Neil quickly and thoughtfully navigated a turbulent market to locate an off-market listing that was perfect for us. It was evident from the beginning that Neil and his team have a passion for what they do - they are true professionals in every sense of the word and I recommend Neil and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. Many thanks to Neil and to The Mathias Team!

Seller review
Neil thank you and your team for being so helpful and supportive for selling and buying my home...
almost 3 years ago
Neil thank you and your team for being so helpful and supportive for selling and buying my home...

Neil thank you and your team for being so helpful and supportive for selling and buying my home in less than one month you are amazing. Thanks for being so patient with us to answer all questions and keep us updated. Your wonderful team specially Kelsea she is great and she has been very helpful and supportive thank you all so much. Sakineh Shamsali

25 - 36 of 50
© 2026 RateMyAgent