Nancy Newman May

Nancy Newman May

  •   5   (7 reviews)

Nancy's sales performance at a glance

See how Nancy has performed in the last 12 months on RateMyAgent*

0
Reviews
2
Properties for sale
0
Sold properties
$0
Total sales value

*Includes all properties sold (last 12 months) where the agent was a part of the transaction and published on ratemyagent.com. It may not be complete and can exclude off-market, private sales and undisclosed pricing and sold dates. Contact agent for full sales history.

About Nancy

Real Estate investing started as a hobby and transitioned into a successful profession! I started investing in real estate about 25 years ago. Through the years the market has gone up and down, and yet my real estate investments have always profited. As a Real Estate professional, I truly want to help others. Let me help you get the most value from your real estate, whether you are buying or selling, residential or commercial. I believe in honesty, integrity and good ole’ fashioned customer service. Your interests will be heard, and your transaction will receive the attention to detail it deserves. I love what I do and am a consistent multi-million-dollar producer in Central Florida. I strongly believe in “giving back” and have a heart for hungry children both locally and around the world. My husband and I started a non-profit called: A Heart Like His Foundation, Inc. in which we currently feed 120+ at risk children every weekend. At least 10% of my real estate commissions are donated toward this feeding program. Helping others with their real estate needs – actually, allows me to feed more children!

Nancy's reviews

  5  
Nancy has 7 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 6.
Review Nancy
Nancy's qualities as told by our client reviews: responsive.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Nancy helped me to purchase a lot and also helped us to find a rental property, in an unknown neighb
over 5 years ago
Nancy helped me to purchase a lot and also helped us to find a rental property, in an unknown neighb

Nancy helped me to purchase a lot and also helped us to find a rental property, in an unknown neighborhood to us. In all instances that she was of assistance, she was professional and patient. She listened to what we wanted and was very much able to get us exactly what was needed. Midway through our looking for the rental property our needs/desires changed and she was not frustrated by that and was able to pick the correct property almost on the first go.

Seller review
We have dealt with several realtors through the years
over 5 years ago
We have dealt with several realtors through the years

We have dealt with several realtors through the years. Nancy May is the absolute best. She is very professional and easy to wok with. She goes above and beyond to assist her clients. She sold 2 houses for us in a very short period of time. We are very impressed with her knowledge and expertise in handling our real estate transactions. We will be listing with her again in the near future. Christine & Mike Starcher

Seller review
Nancy was very proffesional and responsive to any and all of our questions during the sale of our Se
over 5 years ago
Nancy was very proffesional and responsive to any and all of our questions during the sale of our Se

Nancy was very proffesional and responsive to any and all of our questions during the sale of our Sebring home. She went the "extra mile" for us and made helpful and appreciated suggestions. Our new home was in Indiana and Nancy went out of her way to coordinate not only the sale, but also contributed in making the out of state purchase process go smoothly. We would highly recommend Nancy for any and all of you real estate needs (residential or commercial).

Buyer review
We contacted Nancy May on line
over 5 years ago
We contacted Nancy May on line

We contacted Nancy May on line. She quickly responded and began to gather information on our list of "wants" for our 2nd home. She assisted/directed us all the way through the process, even through this Covid pandemic. We planned our visit to Florida and Nancy May took the entire day for us. She showed us 9 properties ! She allowed us time at each property to make a decision, never rushing us. We fell in love with a home and we are enjoying our Florida winter home instead of being cold in Ohio. To further complicate things , We had surgery scheduled but Nancy was able to help us close long distance from Ohio. She worked so hard for us from the initial contact to holding our keys until we could make it down to Florida after Christmas! She is professional, personable, kind, and an excellent communicator. She is the best realtor we have ever worked with. We can't praise her enough!

Seller review
Nancy is clearly a capable real estate agent as she sold our house
almost 7 years ago
Nancy is clearly a capable real estate agent as she sold our house

Nancy is clearly a capable real estate agent as she sold our house. She kept us up to date on developments and put a lot of effort into advertising and showing the house. She is honest in her dealings and a pleasure to work with.We highly recommend her.

Show all 7 reviews
map

Nancy's properties

Nancy has 2 properties for sale, showing 2, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$10,000
1078 Crescent Court
Highlands County FL 33875
Land
Listing courtesy of ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
For Sale
$17,000
338 Hallmark Avenue
Highlands County FL 33852
Land
Listing courtesy of ADVANTAGE REALTY 1
Show all 2 properties
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent