Nancy's profile

Nancy's reviews

  5  
Nancy has 9 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 9.
almost 5 years ago
Selling our family home with Nancy Catalano

My dad had passed leaving my sister and I the sad task of selling our family home. We spoke to quite a few realtors, and they all were pushy and looking for a quick sale. When we met Nancy, we both knew immediately that she was the one that would help us through this process. Nancy understood that this was our childhood home with neighbors on the block that were like family to us. We had some cleaning out to do and some prep work, but we never felt pressured to rush this process. Nancy listened and advised us on what potential buyers looked for when we were prepping the house for sale, and once we were ready, she immediately got to work on staging and listing our home. We loved the fact that she insisted on being at every showing (no lock box) and her communication skills were top-notch. The home sold in less than a month! From beginning to end, the entire process of selling our dad's home went without a hitch. I highly recommend Nancy Catalano for all your home buying and selling needs.

almost 5 years ago
Nancy Catalano is Great

We had spent over a year looking to buy a house before selling our house. It was getting very frustrating until we met Nancy who was showing a house that our Realtor brought us to see. We noticed right away that she was more concerned about our needs rather than selling the house we came to see that was not the right fit. From that day on we switched to using Nancy and in no time she found us the perfect place. Helped us in the negotiation process and brough our attention to many hidden details. The next phase was the scary one we just put pen to paper buying the new home and we were so worried that we were not going to sell our old home fast enough. Nancy spent so much time in staging our home covering every detail down to the place settings on the table and throw pillows. Still worried we were but Nancy seemed very sure that it would be fine. Nancy spent a lot of resourses, time and effort to be sure to attract potential buyers for the first open house. She did so well that the first person that walked in put an offer in followed by 5 more offers in just 3 days. Amazed and shocked we were that is all went so smooth and fast. The year of searching for a house leading up to the time before we met Nancy was very stressful. Once she took over it became a pleasant and fun thing to search for a new home. And this is how it should be. I hope future buyers don't miss out on the fun and excitement of home buying because it is something you only get to do a couple of times in life so be sure that the person or people helping and guiding you are great ones, and no doubt Nancy Catalano is a great one.

almost 6 years ago
Helpful, Informative and Not Pushy

Nancy was the perfect real estate agent, and as we were first time home buyers, helped us so much during the process. Her knowledge and guidance was invaluable, and gave us the tools we needed to make our own decisions, all without influencing how we felt about certain properties at any time. Although I'm sure we weren't her only clients, the time she took to educate us, guide us, and be so responsive to ours needs made us feel as though we were. I would highly recommend Nancy for all of your real estate needs, and we will definitely be using her again in the future when looking to upsize.

almost 7 years ago
First Time Buyer

My husband and I purchased our first home with Nancy in June of this year. She spent over 2 years showing us houses and she never gave up on us until we found our perfect first home. Nancy was a pleasure to work with. She is very honest and hardworking and looks out for her clients. We are extremely happy she was our agent and we have also gained a great friend.

about 8 years ago
Nancy rose to the challenge

Our home requirements were quite specific, but Nancy rose to the challenge. She is polite, professional and very knowledgeable about various town amenities. Besides showing us dozens of homes, Nancy took us to town parks, beaches, golf courses, places of worship, and even a spot to buy freshly laid eggs! She will not just find you a house; she will find you a home. You will not be disappointed working with Nancy. Nancy found our unicorn! She found us a solid home in a great neighborhood with wonderful neighbors that met all our requirements. Thank you, Nancy.

about 8 years ago
The Best Experience

One of the best experience. She was always on my side and went out of her way to get my offer in in timely manner. We went back a few time and she was always there calling, texting and emailing me all information needed. I recommend her without reservation. Keep up the great work.

over 10 years ago
Nancy is the Best Realtor

Nancy A. Catalano is the best realtor you'll ever get the chance to work with. She is attentive, caring and will keep fighting for what you want as a client. I have never met someone as caring and dedicated as her; She loves her career choice and it shows. She will always be available to assist you and answer any questions you may have. I speak from experience and she's the best!!! She has shown me various homes in glen cove and Bayville.

over 11 years ago
Nancy is very Engaging

I met Nancy while seeing a house I saw online that I was interested in and subsequently she showed me houses that fit what I was seeking. She is very engaging and knows how to cater to one's needs.

1 - 9 of 9
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent