Molly Tonero

Molly Tonero

NJ: 8131523
  •   5   (20 reviews)

About Molly

Molly Tonero’s 38-year experience in marketing high-end properties has helped her clients make often difficult decisions that best suit their goals. Building her career on uncompromised integrity and honesty, she has been an active member of the Professional Standards Committee for the North Central Jersey Board of Realtors for several years. Her sensitivity to the need for confidentiality, strong negotiating skills, and an in-depth knowledge of properties both on and nearly-on the market, have made her invaluable to buyers. With her clients as partners in the sales process, she has listed or sold some of the finest residences in New Jersey and offers an impressive list of references. Molly has been a proud part of the Turpin team at the Bernardsville Office since 1998 and consistently in the top three at this company long-respected for its integrity and unflinching demand for the highest caliber agent. 2021 was a high point in her career with more than $26,000,000 in sales volume, and earning an NJ Realtors Circle of Excellence Sales Award. Her daughter Margot “Chris” Mylod has joined her and adds her strong paralegal and real estate sales experience from Upstate New York to the team. Molly has five grown children and step-children, and seven grandchildren of whom she is immensely proud. Having helped design and build three homes, architecture is a passion which has driven her career. She and her husband bred and raised their four Golden Retrievers for nearly 20 glorious years, and then adopted the world’s most stubborn Chesapeake Bay Retriever. With the addition of a Pointer-mix pup, she is a strong supporter of animal rescue groups. Molly feels blessed to have grown up in Montclair, New Jersey. Her summers were spent at the family home in Bolton Landing, Lake George which remains part of her soul. Gardening and boating are passions. Other than five-and-one-half years at Cornell University and time spent in London and Provence, Molly has spent all of her adult years in the New Jersey countryside, which has allowed her to maintain an always optimistic attitude, an unflagging devotion to her real estate clients and a redeeming sense of humor.

Molly's reviews

  5  
Molly has 20 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 6.
Review Molly
Molly's qualities as told by our client reviews: proactive, well-prepared, attentive, supportive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
There is literally no better expert in the luxury NJ real estate market than Molly Tonero.
12 months ago
There is literally no better expert in the luxury NJ real estate market than Molly Tonero.

There is literally no better expert in the luxury NJ real estate market than Molly Tonero. I say this as both a buyer and a seller. Molly is an extreme professional who understands high expectations and not only that but raises the bar. Because of the trust Molly has built over the years with so many of us she knows when ideal homes are about to hit the market and quickly moves on connecting the right buyer to the right seller. I rarely follow anyone's absolute guidance but when it comes to Molly I know if I simply follow her advice everything will happen for the better.

Seller review
Our experience with Molly and Chris from Turpin was wonderful
about 1 year ago
Our experience with Molly and Chris from Turpin was wonderful

Our experience with Molly and Chris from Turpin was wonderful from start to finish. Their knowledge and expertise combined with their seamless communication about listing showing and closing made a typically stressful process much easier to complete! Wonderful professionals.

Seller review
good advise
about 2 years ago
good advise

Careful good advise followup and persistance!

Seller review
Molly Tonero is the ultimate professional.
over 3 years ago
Molly Tonero is the ultimate professional.

Molly Tonero is the ultimate professional. She has a deep understanding of the market and is able to use that knowledge to connect with buyers in a very efficient way. Most importantly she is deeply connected to the process of attaining the best possible outcome for her clients. Molly and her team are willing to roll up their sleeves and do whatever is necessary to help her clients achieve their goals.I can not recommend Molly and her team enough and would gladly work with her again if given the opportunity.

Seller review
Molly Tonero and her daughter Chris Mylod are tremendous assets to Turpin Realty
over 3 years ago
Molly Tonero and her daughter Chris Mylod are tremendous assets to Turpin Realty

I have worked with Molly Tonero on severaloccasions since 2011. Her handling of the sale of "Blairsden" in Peapack/Far Hills was my first introduction to her exceptional skills. I was then fortunate to engage her services for the purchase of my former home in Whitehouse Station and when the recent difficult decision to sell that property arose Molly was as supportive as no other. The recent addition of Molly's daughter Chris Mylod also greatly alleviated any stress in my recent sale and purchase process. I highly recommend Molly and Chris for their incredible patience market knowledge and diplomacy. They never objected to the sometimes overwhelming number of properties I had proposed to purchase until I found the perfect one. There were so many showing and schedule changes that Molly and Chris graciously accommodated and I also felt greatly protected as a seller and buyer due to their incredible combined years of experience and success. Molly's professionalism and caring nature never wavered throughout the time we worked together and I am ever grateful for her insightful and compassionate approach to handling clients so decently. Molly Tonero and her daughter Chris Mylod are tremendous assets to Turpin Realty and I am most fortunate to have been advised and protected by them.

Show all 20 reviews
map

Molly's properties

Molly has 3 properties for sale and sold 1 property in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$4,375,000
46 Sand Spring Road
Morris County NJ 07960
6
8
11
Other
Listing courtesy of Turpin Real Estate, Inc. - Bernardsville
For Sale
$2,399,000
160 South Finley Avenue
Bernards Township NJ 07920
5
7
2
Other
Listing courtesy of Turpin Real Estate, Inc. - Bernardsville
SoldMar 30, 2026
For Sale
$4,500,000
770 Pottersville Road
Morris County NJ 07930
6
10
4
Other
Listing courtesy of Turpin Real Estate, Inc. - Bernardsville
Show all 4 properties

Molly's sold properties

Molly has sold 1 property in the past 12 months, showing 1.

Enter your property details to filter

I'm selling a
bedroom
with
bathrooms in
Property imageAddressBedroomsBathroomsCarparksProperty TypeClosing PriceDate Sold
26 Gleneagles Drive
Morris County NJ 07920
Other$1,600,000Mar 30, 2026

Browse nearby locations

SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent