Mikayla's profile

Mikayla's reviews

  5  
Mikayla has 20 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Mikayla's qualities as told by our client reviews: great negotiation, dedicated, patient, detail-oriented, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Mikayla did a great job helping us find our home in Greeley
about 2 years ago
Mikayla did a great job helping us find our home in Greeley

Mikayla did a great job helping us find our home in Greeley. We lived out of state at the time so she had to arrange all of our showings virtually. She definitely went above and beyond expectations coordinating and communicating all of the details. I highly recommend Mikayla to anyone shopping for a new home!

Seller review
We used Mikayla's expertise to both sell our home, and purchase a new one
about 2 years ago
We used Mikayla's expertise to both sell our home, and purchase a new one

We used Mikayla's expertise to both sell our home, and purchase a new one. She made the process seamless and walked my husband & I through each step. Long story short, she had our house sold within the afternoon of the first showing! Buying with her was great as well and she provided an inspector we felt really comfortable with. I would trust her with our next move simply because she's a northern Colorado native, knows the area, and knows everything to do to best represent her clients!

Seller review
Awesome service!
about 2 years ago
Awesome service!

Our agent was extremely knowledgeable about the local market and very patient with us as we dealt with unexpected medical issues. Overall we were extremely satisfied with the outcome as our agent went above and beyond to help us complete the transaction under difficult personal circumsrances.

Seller review
Mikayla is wonderful
almost 3 years ago
Mikayla is wonderful

Mikayla was a joy to work with through the entire process. She worked with us to help balance the sale of our home with the purchase of our new home and did so in a manner that was as painless as home buying can be.

Buyer review
Wonderful and painless.
almost 3 years ago
Wonderful and painless.

Mikayla made the home buying process painless and enjoyable she worked with our wants and needs to make sure that we ended up in a home we love.

Buyer review
We'll Mikayla has Done It She Had Sold Me My First Home !!
almost 3 years ago
We'll Mikayla has Done It She Had Sold Me My First Home !!

I’ve talked to Mikayla Culwell multiple times about real estate and the real estate market. She is very knowledgeable, professional and passionate about her Career. Anyone who works with her is lucky to have her on their side. It’s a competitive market and Mikayla knows how to navigate the complexities to her clients advantage. I am Beyond Blessed and fortunate! Thanks Mikayla !!

Seller review
Amazing Realtor and Great Social Media Marketing Skills
almost 3 years ago
Amazing Realtor and Great Social Media Marketing Skills

Mikayla Culwell was amazing to work with! She marketed the home well on social media, had frequent advertising with amazing photos and videos, and communicated quickly and efficiently. She was easily available to talk to about the sale and ask questions to. The home was sold within a short time frame and MIkayla was wonderful in communicating with escrow and the buyer agent to make sure that the sell went through in a timely and efficient manner. I would highly recommend Mikayla and would be glad to work with her again for any of my future real estate needs.

Seller review
Quick & Easy
almost 3 years ago
Quick & Easy

Mikayla had this townhouse sold in a single weekend! With one open house, she was able to generate enough foot traffic & interest, that by Monday, we accepted an offer! She also made the "staging" and photo process easy as well, advising us as to what would look best for potential buyers to picture themselves in it. I'd definitely recommend her services for all of northern Colorado!

Buyer review
Kind Hearted & Determined Realtor
almost 3 years ago
Kind Hearted & Determined Realtor

Having known Mikayla for years, it was a no-brainer to look to her to purchase our home in northern Colorado. She must have put a ton of miles on her car, but she searched such a vast area for my partner and I, who were uncertain of we actually wanted for quite a while. From Firestone and Frederick, up to Milliken and Johnstown, Mikayla helped us in seeing so many options! Not only is she incredibly personable and kind, she's very determined! When I tell you we looked for over a year, it's true! She never doubted we'd find the right place though, and now we couldn't be more lucky to be planting our roots in our new community! In addition to finding us our dream home, she also sold our previous home in a single weekend! One open house with her was all it took! She made the selling process very easy to understand just like she did when we were buying. Either end of the spectrum, she's definitely a realtor we'd recommend! For the sake of her car's mileage, I hope your search area isn't as large as ours was, but it was so worth it!

Buyer review
Mikayla is an expert matchmaker!
about 3 years ago
Mikayla is an expert matchmaker!

Mikayla is an expert matchmaker! She’s adept at understanding her buyers’ needs and matching them to the home of their dreams. Her marketing background makes her an ideal listing agent as she understands what catches a buyer’s attention. She’s detailed, knowledgeable, and professional. You’ll be in great hands with Mikayla!

Buyer review
As a first-time home buyer, she guided me and provided so much info for me!
over 3 years ago
As a first-time home buyer, she guided me and provided so much info for me!

Mikayla was so amazing!! As a first-time home buyer, she guided me and provided so much info for me! I could not imagine working with anyone else! Mikayla is the best agent and I would absolutely recommend her to literally anyone. I have 100000% trust in her for any and all of my future real estate purchases.

1 - 12 of 20
© 2026 RateMyAgent