Michelle Garcia

Michelle Garcia

FL: SL3466809
  •   5   (31 reviews)

About Michelle

Michelle is a well-rounded business professional equipped with an unparalleled work ethic characterized by integrity, positivity, and a willingness to go above and beyond. Her mission is to be a trusted advisor and asset to home buyers and sellers while guiding and educating them through the transaction process. Michelle was born and raised in the South Seminole Heights area of Tampa, Florida. In her early twenties, she began to establish roots in the Greater Orlando area, where she has resided for nearly a decade. Soon after earning a B.S. in Hospitality Management from world-renowned UCF Rosen College of Hospitality Management, she began her real estate career as an Operations Manager for a newly established, boutique real estate brokerage. By March of 2020, Michelle became a licensed Florida Real Estate Sales Associate with Charles Rutenberg Realty. Over the last 4 years, Michelle successfully established a 100% referral-based business, having served over 60 buyers and sellers and achieving more than $20M in sales volume, all while maintaining a 5-star review rating on Google with over 20 reviews. She prides herself on her knowledge and market expertise across the state, serving 15 different markets throughout Central Florida, with focus on Greater Orlando and Greater Tampa areas. 

Michelle's reviews

  5  
Michelle has 31 reviewsacross 21 different locations, showing 6.
Review Michelle
over 2 years ago
Turned a disaster into a Reinvigorating experience

A new york bluntness with refreshing honesty and transparency. After multiple open houses. fixing my MLS listing my prior agent screwed up, finding home insurance for my old home when no one is insuring them. She had cleaners, lawn service, pressure washers, inspectors, plumbers, electricians, etc... She pulled permits I couldn't find, and records. where the prior agent screwed up my home valuation Michelle fixed. She even has a nice photographer too :) with a drone for photos and 360 view. What about comps you asked? She got you covered like the magnum in your wallet. Oh wait, there's more. Our sellers for the home we wanted, did not want to wait for another buyer. They didn't want the contingency anymore. Michelle set me up with NAF to buy the sellers home for us in order to buy from them once our home sold. The other best part. SHE COMMUNICATES with your real-estate lawyer, insurance provider, mortgage company, all of it. She even gave me the best cost method for moving. I changed lenders 4x with her (this is totally on me, I had 17 lenders on an Excel sheet getting the best rate possible) Changed law firms once (the original closed their doors) went through 2 buying processes for my current home 5 buyers, 3 escrow pay outs, 1 valid buyer (VA Buyer) remaining FHA buyers 1 bad agent we worked with until Wendy was removed 4 inspections 2 of whom had ZERO clue on my AC system (TY Rinaldi), no clue how a salt water pool system works, and zero clues on how solar hot water system works. While I may have been the most unique crazy experience of home buying and selling experience for her, it was definitely her saving grace that kept me in play and allowed us to buy a 5/4 within our budget, in the county we wanted, quiet, and checked most of our boxes. My 3498 5/4 full bath home I can say we truly love it. Michelle made it happen. She will fight the good fight with a LOT of these clueless agents out there.

almost 3 years ago
Will fight for the best deals for you.

Michelle and Dan were fantastic to work with! They were incredibly informative, super helpful and will fight for the best deals for you. I will be recommending them to anyone who is looking for a new home!

almost 3 years ago
They really listened to what we wanted.

Just wanted to give a shout out to Dan and Michelle! They were awesome from day one and really listened to what we wanted… to the point of helping us think outside the box to fit our needs in this challenging market.. they walked us through every step we needed to take and ended up making a solid deal on a house we love.. would absolutely work with them again if we ever move, might be awhile since they found us such a perfect first home.. thanks again!!! Dani(and nick)

over 3 years ago
Michelle’s experience really made it seem like we were always one step ahead.

Michelle and Dan were such a great team to have on our side during our search for a new home. They took their time to get to know us and helped us make the best decision for our family. Michelle’s experience really made it seem like we were always one step ahead. They were available to answers questions at any hour and remained positive at all times. We would definitely recommend them to our friends and family.

over 3 years ago
Ten stars if I could!! Michelle found the perfect investment property for me.

Ten stars if I could!! Michelle found the perfect investment property for me. She and Dan worked relentlessly to find the right property and to make it happen. As a team they have provided a level of service you will not find elsewhere. They are ethical and hardworking pros at what they do. Completely happy with my entire experience!

over 3 years ago
Superiority above all others. Michelle is a pure genius🤩

Outstanding team Michelle and Dan! Superiority above all others. Our situation wasn't ideal but they somehow made the impossible possible!! They are miracle workers with compassion and heart❤️ Michelle is a pure genius🤩 How she and Dan worked relentlessly to get our new home approved was pure mastery to say the least!!

Show all 31 reviews

Michelle's properties

Michelle has sold 2 properties in the last 12 months, showing 2, sorted by most recent activity

SoldDec 23, 2025
$660,000
2110 West Farewell Drive
Tampa FL 33603
4
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of CHARLES RUTENBERG REALTY ORLANDO and SUCCESS PROPERTY MANAGEMENT IN
SoldJun 16, 2025
$127,000
2/275 114th Avenue North
St. Petersburg FL 33716
2
1
1
Condo
Listing courtesy of CHARLES RUTENBERG REALTY ORLANDO and ACROPOLIS REALTY GROUP LLC - Syracuse
Show all 2 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent