Melissa's profile

Melissa's reviews

  5  
Melissa has 14 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
We are so grateful for everything Melissa did for us in purchasing our first home! Thank you!!
about 2 months ago
We are so grateful for everything Melissa did for us in purchasing our first home! Thank you!!

I am super grateful for Melissa helping us purchase our first home. She made me and my husband feel at ease the whole process. Being first homeowners we really didn't know a lot and gained so much knowledge having her as a realtor. She really listened to the things that we were looking for when buying a home and never once made us feel like we couldn't ask questions. Melissa had a lot of knowledge on comparable homes in the area and helped us negotiate a great deal on our home!! Thank you again Melissa Mariola -David at Cutler realty for helping us! We couldn't be happier in our new home!! I will be highly recommending her to everyone I meet! Again thank you so MUCH!

Seller review
Absolutely the most wonderful experience i have ever had with a realtor.... just wonderful!!!
3 months ago
Absolutely the most wonderful experience i have ever had with a realtor.... just wonderful!!!

It's hard to put into words the fantastic experience i had with Melissa and her caring wonderful team at Cutler. I had just gone through the most devastating tragedy you can imagine right before listing my home and I would not have made it through this process without her. She went way above and beyond to help me. Every step of the way she was there with me. A lot of the time I wasn't even there and she did things ....many, many things I should have been doing and I just couldn't. I can't say enough great things about the experience I had selling my home with Melissa Davis at Cutler Reality.

Seller review
Understood market and presented house well.
4 months ago
Understood market and presented house well.

Melissa did a good job helping us determine selling price, did a nice job presenting house in photos and then led us through the process with a positive outcome in a relatively short period of time.

Seller review
Amazing realtor team!
4 months ago
Amazing realtor team!

Tasked with not only selling one home, but two as we combined families into a new construction home, with a very specific timeframe! Melissa knew exactly when we should list and how quickly it would sell. Our house sold before actually being listed because this team was in the know and had prospective buyers before we needed to! It worked out so well being close to the holidays to have a buyer so quick! My dad’s home sold in under 15 days. It doesn’t get any better than that. Melissa and Scott are understanding, gracious, and they listened to our needs. Responsive and timely in all our interactions. Would highly recommend!

Seller review
Great to work with!
5 months ago
Great to work with!

Melissa was very knowledgeable of the market trends and very responsive with changes to the listing as needed. 10/10 would recommend!

Buyer review
Pleasant experience
6 months ago
Pleasant experience

Wonderful experience. Melissa found the ideal house that checked all of our boxes. She is very knowledgeable of the area and walked us through the entire closing process.

Seller review
Wonderful and professional realtor
6 months ago
Wonderful and professional realtor

Melissa is a true professional, and went above and beyond to help me sell my home in Wooster. I live an hour away, and she made herself available to help me to minimize my trips to Wooster. She has great expertise in her field, and made the process seamless for me. She really went the extra mile to help me. I would recommend Melissa to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She is thoughtful, kind, considerate and a great communicator.

Seller review
Friendly and Proffessional
6 months ago
Friendly and Proffessional

We both sold and bought a house with Melissa, and from day one she guided us through the process with diligence. We had multiple competing offers for our house and she was great walking us through, selecting the best take-home offer. If ever buying or selling a house again, Melissa is who we will be using.

Buyer review
Our Home Buying Experience with Melissa
7 months ago
Our Home Buying Experience with Melissa

Working with Melissa on purchasing our new home was a very enjoyable experience. From the beginning, Melissa demonstrated a genuine interest in understanding our needs and preferences for our future home. Melissa took the time to listen to us and made sure she understood exactly what features and qualities were most important to us. She was attentive and patient, ensuring that every aspect on our wish list was considered during the home search process. After carefully considering our requirements, Melissa helped us find a home that was a perfect fit for our needs. She guided us through the options available and supported us in making an informed decision. Melissa remained informative and supportive throughout the closing process. She provided us with clear explanations and timely updates, which made the entire experience smooth and stress-free. In addition, she offered helpful recommendations for contractors, making it easier for us to turn our new house into a home.

Seller review
Melissa is a trusted advisor
7 months ago
Melissa is a trusted advisor

Melissa is very professional and amazing to work with. The industry knowledge and expertise is unmattched. Melissa is a trusted advisor and that is why I go to her for all things real-estate.

Seller review
True Professionals
8 months ago
True Professionals

Melissa and Scott prepared a very through analysis of the market and advised as to the best price for our home. Due to their diligence and guidance, we were able to sell our home in 3 days. In addition, Melissa was very patient as she help navigate us through the steps in prep work, followup tasks and closing on the sale of our home. As first time sellers, we would not have been able to sell our home as quickly and at the final price without her guidance.

1 - 12 of 14
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent