Matthew's profile

Matthew's reviews

  5  
Matthew has 24 reviewsacross 15 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Matthew's qualities as told by our client reviews: friendly, patient, clear communication, responsive, dedicated, local expert, well-prepared.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Working with Matthew was an exceptional experience from beginning to end
9 days ago
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Working with Matthew was an exceptional experience from beginning to end

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Working with Matthew was an exceptional experience from beginning to end. His deep understanding of the market, thoughtful pricing strategy, meticulous attention to detail, and ability to position our home to attract the right buyers truly set him apart. His communication was clear and timely, his recommendations were thoughtful, and his execution was seamless. One open house and our home sold within a week! Beyond his professional expertise, what impressed me most was his emotional intelligence and genuine appreciation for the pride, memories, and sentimental value we attached to our home. He balanced compassion with confidence, making every decision feel intentional and well guided. His professionalism, integrity, and dedication made a significant milestone feel effortless. I couldn’t recommend him more highly!

Seller review
Couldn't recommend Matthew enough!
4 months ago
Couldn't recommend Matthew enough!

I was lucky enough to connect with Matthew at an open house he was hosting in my neighborhood. I had just decided to kick off my process of selling/buying and decided to start by assessing the market and checking out what was out there. I am so glad I decided to go! While it wasn't the right apartment for me, I met Matthew and it led to a yearlong partnership and journey that netted in my selling my place at an amazing price and buying my dream home with the exact things I wanted. Matthew has been consistent, supportive, reliable, strategic, and best of all FUN! He demystified the process and was there for every step of the way. Not only did he serve as my selling and buying agent, but he also connected me to wonderful experts along the way - Legal, mortgage, and even a contractor! I felt very supported throughout and still do. Both transactions are over, yet he is still checking in to see how things are going with the next phase - renovation! I couldn't recommend Matthew enough. You will not regret it!!!

Buyer review
We highly recommend Matt! He was very calm and supportive throughout the process
4 months ago
We highly recommend Matt! He was very calm and supportive throughout the process

Matt was our real estate agent for a home in Queens, NY and we highly recommend him! Matt was very calm and supportive throughout the process and knew when to guide us and when not to push us. He provided detailed comps, stayed in great communication throughout, and even helped us with our previous rental situation.

Seller review
Historic Home. Record Sale Price!
5 months ago
Historic Home. Record Sale Price!

From our first meeting to discuss the sale of my home to the closing, Matthew was the consummate professional. He followed through on every request. He also understood the emotional aspects of selling a home not just a house. It was a true partnership from beginning to end. He made thoughtful and insightful suggestions, based on his years of real estate and marketing experience, that maximized the showings. Because of his expertise, I received 5 offers in 3 weeks during the holiday season and a down market—one of which led to the final sale. Anyone who is looking for a professional, knowledgeable, respectful, patient, honest, and outstanding broker, Matthew Wynter is that broker.

Buyer review
Matt is a one of a kind realtor and we are blessed to have been matched with him
10 months ago
Matt is a one of a kind realtor and we are blessed to have been matched with him

Matt is a one of a kind realtor and we are blessed to have been matched with him. As our buyer's agent on our first property purchase he went above and beyond for us and always made us feel informed, prepared, and confident every step of the way. What make's Matt one of the best in the business is not just his professionalism, but the warmth and care that he exudes. Matt commands respect from all parties throughout the process, so having him on your team is a serious boost to achieving your goals. Our financial situation going into this purchase was not ideal and we faced many challenges along the way, but Matt was tireless in working through those challenges and coming up with solutions to secure the property. Matt is professional, knowledgeable, patient, and resourceful. He handles every step of the process thoroughly and with warmth and care. Despite feeling doubtful that we could close, Matt was the rock that helped us overcome every hurdle. I can't express how amazing Matt is. I truly believe we would not have been able to close without Matt having our back. We went through several brokers before finding Matt, and Matt is in a class of his own. Thank you so much Matt!

Buyer review
Working with Matthew Wynter was an absolute pleasure
11 months ago
Working with Matthew Wynter was an absolute pleasure

Working with Matthew Wynter was an absolute pleasure. He served as our buyer's agent for our first major property purchase in NYC and went above and beyond at every step. From the initial property viewing through closing, Matthew was professional, detail-oriented, and genuinely invested in helping us find the right home. He negotiated on our behalf to secure an additional $10K seller credit, connected us seamlessly with our attorney and lender, and coordinated every detail of the closing process with remarkable ease. What stood out most was his warmth and accessibility. He remained available even after closing to answer questions about the building and maintenance, the mark of someone who truly cares about their clients' experience. And his thoughtful housewarming gift was a wonderful touch that showed real care. Beyond being an exceptional agent, Matthew has become a friend, which speaks volumes about his character. If you're looking for a buyer's agent in NYC who is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in your success, I can't recommend Matthew highly enough. He made our first purchase experience smooth, stress-free, and genuinely enjoyable.

Seller review
Working with Matt was an excellent experience from start to finish
about 1 year ago
Working with Matt was an excellent experience from start to finish

Working with Matt was an excellent experience from start to finish. He patiently stayed in touch and guided me over multiple years as I decided when the right time would be to sell my apartment. When I was finally ready, he priced the place perfectly — and we received an offer and closed in a short amount of time. Throughout the process, Matt was responsive, knowledgeable about the local market, and always clear in his communication. He made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and straightforward. Overall, he’s a true professional and a pleasure to work with. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell.

Seller review
Matthew Wynter is a committed realtor
about 1 year ago
Matthew Wynter is a committed realtor

Matthew Wynter is a committed realtor. Looking to sell in New York, he’s the person that keeps you updated, informed and will get the job done. What a blessing, Thank you again ! !

Buyer review
Matthew is very helpful and resourceful
about 1 year ago
Matthew is very helpful and resourceful

Matthew is very helpful and resourceful. He zeros in on your likes and then finds appropriate houses. Also, he knows the market well. You are in good hands with him!

Buyer review
My girlfriend and I had the absolute pleasure of working with Matthew to purchase our first property
over 1 year ago
My girlfriend and I had the absolute pleasure of working with Matthew to purchase our first property

My girlfriend and I had the absolute pleasure of working with Matthew to purchase our first property in NYC, and we cannot recommend him highly enough. Navigating the NYC real estate market can be overwhelming, but he made the entire process feel manageable and even enjoyable. We’re now settled into a place we love, and it wouldn’t have been possible without Matthew. If you’re looking for someone who genuinely cares, and will advocate for you every step of the way, look no further. Thank you again, Matthew!

Seller review
Matthew is a phenomenal realtor
over 1 year ago
Matthew is a phenomenal realtor

Matthew is a phenomenal realtor. He was friendly and professional. He was readily accessible for any questions we had. He delivered on the promise he’d made and the entire sale was unbelievably smooth.

1 - 12 of 24
© 2026 RateMyAgent