Matthew's profile

Matthew's reviews

  5  
Matthew has 7 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 7.
Buyer review
Matt was extremely helpful in helping us find the right home
about 1 month ago
Matt was extremely helpful in helping us find the right home

Matt was extremely helpful in helping us find the right home. His knowledge of the area proved very valuable for us not being from around the area. He even went to showings and had us on video calls when we were out of town. Was always willing to jump on a call or answer questions for us, and we had a lot of questions. Matt was always very responsive and always felt like he had our best intentions at the forefront. I couldn't recommend him enough for someone looking to find the right home.

Buyer review
Matt is a gem! My husband and I had recently purchased our first house, with the help of Matt
6 months ago
Matt is a gem! My husband and I had recently purchased our first house, with the help of Matt

Matt is a gem! My husband and I had recently purchased our first house, with the help of Matt. We were new to the process and didn’t fully know what to expect and Matt really helped break down the process with us and helps you save where you can. Matt has been doing this for 20+ years and it shows! We would recommend Matt in a heartbeat to anyone interested in purchasing a home. Also, Matt has a list of people for things such as the inspections, engineers and etc. he’s worked with over the years that do great work he can recommend. Matt is patient, great at understanding what you’re looking for, quick to get things done, and always there to help. Overall, extremely satisfied and so happy we found Matt!

Seller review
Matthew Pennington is so great that we have used him multiple times! We f
about 1 year ago
Matthew Pennington is so great that we have used him multiple times! We f

Matthew Pennington at American AllStar Realty is so great that we have used him multiple times! We first worked with Matthew a few years ago when we were buying our first home. With it being our first time, the whole process was very new, but Matthew really helped us to feel confident and comfortable. Not only did he completely understand and deliver on what we were looking for, but we also felt that he genuinely cared about us and helping us the best he could. Because we felt so safe and confident with him, my mom used him to look for a vacation home, and then we used him again when we had to sell our home. Matthew was consistent, diligent, and trustworthy with all 3 experiences, and we would certainly use him again if we ever need to. Thank you so much Matthew!

Buyer review
We met Matt at an open house and were immediately impressed by the way he walked us through the home
almost 3 years ago
We met Matt at an open house and were immediately impressed by the way he walked us through the home

We met Matt at an open house and were immediately impressed by the way he walked us through the home and gave a detailed explanation of the different spaces. It was a sharp contrast from other listing agents who did not appear quite as knowledgeable. As first time homebuyers, Matt did a great job taking us through the process starting with getting an idea of what we were looking for and using that information to help us narrow down the areas of Phoenix we might be interested in. He is genuinely curious about the history of the homes he took us to, which helped clarify the condition of the home and if it would be a good fit for us as his clients. When we were ready to make an offer, Matt helped us navigate what the market looked like so we could narrow in on what we thought was a fair purchasing price. Overall we would definitely recommend Matt to anyone else looking to purchase a home with the help of a detail-oriented and diligent realtor.

Seller review
I had the absolute pleasure of working with Matt Pennington
almost 3 years ago
I had the absolute pleasure of working with Matt Pennington

I had the absolute pleasure of working with Matt Pennington. When I reached out to Matt I was in a tough situation that I was embarrassed about and was in a time sensitive situation. I never felt once like I was being judged by Matt instead I actually felt pretty positive by the end of our conversation. Matt listened to my needs and he just took the ball and ran. Unfortunately there were some obstacles that he knew about ahead of time but ones that neither of knew were going to happen and that he never should of had to deal with. Again Matt never made me feel like I was a bother or he should never have taken this listing. He just had us keep moving forward. Numerous times (before, during, after the sale) Matt went above and beyond then a realtor should have. Matt clearly does his job (or makes your at least feel like he does) because he loves it and not just for the sale.Thank you from the bottom of my heartPam

1 - 7 of 7
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent