Mathew Sickler

Mathew Sickler

Director / Licensed Real Estate Agent / Owner at Keller Williams - Main Street
  •   5   (10 reviews)

About Mathew

With roots firmly planted in the diverse landscapes of New Jersey and Pennsylvania, I've traversed the bustling streets of Southern Jersey and Philadelphia, calling various neighborhoods home from Mays Landing to Cedarbrook, Society Hill PA, Upper Deerfield to Richwood, and ultimately finding my sanctuary in the vibrant heart of Old City Philadelphia. From a young age, I was immersed in the world of real estate, growing up as the son of a real estate investor family. This early exposure instilled in me a deep understanding of the industry's intricacies and a passion for serving discerning individuals. Throughout my career, I've been honored to receive numerous accolades, including the prestigious Realtors Circle of Excellence award year after year, recognition in Top Agent Magazine, and inclusion in South Jersey REAL PRODUCERS TOP 40 UNDER 40: Recognizing Young Achievers. As an accredited Keller Williams Luxury agent and a perennial member of the Million Dollar Club, I've consistently demonstrated my commitment to excellence. Furthermore, I am proud to be a preferred agent for Veterans United, dedicated to serving veterans and military families in Pennsylvania and New Jersey. At the core of my practice lies a simple yet profound mission: to earn the trust of my clients and guide them through the most significant purchase of their lifetime with unwavering integrity and expertise. I am deeply committed to ensuring that each client's journey is seamless, rewarding, and free from regrets. With a steadfast dedication to service and a relentless pursuit of excellence, I am honored to be entrusted with the privilege of helping my clients achieve their real estate goals and dreams.

Mathew's reviews

  5  
Mathew has 10 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 6.
Review Mathew
7 months ago
It was Great experience overall

It was Great experience overall. Very responsive, professional, and knowledgeable throughout the process. Made selling my home smooth and low-stress. Would definitely recommend.

about 1 year ago
Mathew was amazing to work with

Mathew was amazing to work with. We ran into one issue after another when we were trying to close and Mathew helped me steer through each one. If anyone was to ask I would definitely recommend using Mathew!

about 1 year ago
I cannot recommend my Realtor, Mathew Sickler, highly enough! From start to finish, he went above an

I cannot recommend my Realtor, Mathew Sickler, highly enough! From start to finish, he went above and beyond to make my first home-buying experience seamless, stress-free, and truly enjoyable. His exceptional communication kept me in the loop at every step, ensuring I always knew what to expect and felt confident in the process. He anticipated my needs, answered every question with patience and expertise, and handled every detail with professionalism and care. Whether it was negotiating the best deal, coordinating with lenders, or resolving unexpected challenges, he was always one step ahead, making the entire journey feel effortless. His dedication, market knowledge, and genuine commitment to my happiness set him apart as a true superstar in real estate. If you’re looking for a Realtor who will exceed your expectations and make your home-buying or selling process a breeze, look no further than Mathew Sickler!

over 1 year ago
Mathew was amazing to work with

Mathew was amazing to work with. We ran into one issue after another when we were house hunting and Mathew helped us steer through each one. Not that we plan to buy another house any time soon but if we do we will definitely use Mathew again!

about 2 years ago
Mathew is an OUTSTANDING agent

Mathew is an OUTSTANDING agent. He is extremely knowledgeable and experienced with all things real estate. He dealt with each step of the selling process with a calm, approachable demeanor. My mother also used him for the sale of her property and he explained the process to her and was always available whenever she had questions. Both my Mother and I are extremely grateful for Mathew. We would 100% refer him for all of your real estate needs. You will not be disappointed! Thank you, Mathew!

about 2 years ago
The Very Best Experience Ever!

Mathew is one of the most professional individuals I have ever encountered. He answered every question honestly and thoroughly. The buying process was minimal due to his dedication and willingness to work in our best interest in every regard. I have learned so much from Mathew and his passion for the profession is obvious. If you are selling or buying a property, Mathew is the one you need to support you through the process with ease. Mathew’s name is spelled with one T as a reminder of his uniqueness and top notch service. When we first met Mathew we were beyond impressed. He was kind, engaging, caring and funny! He will always be my go to person for future buying and selling agendas. I challenge all of you to contact Mathew for assistance, and there will be no regrets.

Show all 10 reviews

Mathew's properties

Mathew has 18 properties for sale and sold 14 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldJul 31, 2026
$680,000
410 Wayne Drive
Cinnaminson Township NJ 08077
4
3
6
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Weichert Realtors - Moorestown and Keller Williams - Main Street
SoldJun 25, 2026
$192,000
237 Morris St
Gloucester City NJ 08030
3
2
Townhouse
Listing courtesy of Society and Keller Williams - Main Street
SoldJun 25, 2026
$330,000
29 Oberlin Rd
Pennsville NJ 08070
5
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams - Main Street and American Dream Realty of South Jersey
Under Contract
$255,000
303 Columbine Avenue
Millville NJ 08332
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Keller Williams - Main Street
Show all 32 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent