Mary Pepper's profile

Mary Pepper's reviews

  5  
Mary Pepper has 11 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 11.
2 months ago
A joy to work with from day one..

I was new to Lexington and Pepper treated me like we were old friends. Took the time to walk me through every step and patience for all of my questions. We went to many condos looking for my forever home. I never felt alone throughout the entire process and knew I had Pepper by my side. Pepper was a joy to work with. I would recommend her to everyone.

4 months ago
Best of the best!

Between the two of us, this is our fourth transaction working with Pepper - and we’re so grateful that she’s been able to support us through each one! Pepper is knowledgeable, experienced, well-connected, and a genuinely friendly and down-to-earth person. She helped us navigate a particularly stressful selling experience recently and we thanked our stars daily to be working with her. She has a keen eye for details and a good sense of the local market and truly makes the entire process feel manageable and simple. Would recommend her to anyone and everyone!

5 months ago
The very best!

Knowledgeable, skilled, professional individual on all levels of sale and closing work in commercial, residential and farm real property transactions. Always responsive and goal oriented. Truly at the top of her field. The very best!

5 months ago
Pepper is a winner!

Pepper was so easy to work with. She helped us navigate some obstacles in the purchase of an investment property that needs extensive work. She did the leg work. We reviewed and signed. Easy process. Pepper has a moral compass. I’d use her again without hesitation.

6 months ago
Professional, responsive, strong advocate

My boyfriend and I worked with Pepper and she was a great partner during our home purchasing process. She was knowledgeable and professional, giving good advice when solicited and backing us up when we had requests for the sellers. Pepper was patient and respectful during the negotiation and helped us close with the repairs we asked for. Highly recommended!

over 1 year ago
Fabulous Realtor!

I highly recommend Pepper Johnstone! I hadn’t bought a house in over 20 yrs— so was basically like a first time homebuyer again— and Pepper helped make my experience a smooth and enjoyable one. She is genuine, and always found time to work around my schedule— so I felt like I was her only client. She was always timely in her response to any of my questions or requests to see properties. She helped me get into a perfect house for me— and it really felt like she was in my corner acting as a buyer’s agent for me. I absolutely recommend Pepper without reservation.

over 1 year ago
Best Realtor there is

If you are in the hunt for a realtor I kid you not look no further. Pepper is by far the best realtor I have ever used. I wish I had used her on my first home purchase because the work communication and overall effort she puts in are amazing. You will never be wrong choosing Pepper as your realtor !

over 1 year ago
Fantastic!

Without Pepper my daughter and I could not of sold our two houses as efficiently. She is the best and has a lot of experience and wisdom. Highly recommend her to anyone listing or buying!!

almost 2 years ago
Best realtor in Lexington

Pepper has been involved with me as both a buyer and a seller. She is worth her weight in gold for the knowledge and skills she brings to the process.

almost 4 years ago
Couldn’t be happier with my first experience!

Pepper was an amazing realtor! Her patience and insight was second to none. She took great care in listening to my needs and wants and went above and beyond to deliver. She was always ready with multiple sites even in this crazy property climate. She was extremely patient, very attentive and was always available when I needed her. There were times I was ready to throw in the towel and Pepper never seemed to give up even when I was ready to. She found me a great first home and I couldn’t be happier! I can’t recommend her enough especially for Lexington area and beyond!

about 5 years ago
Extremely knowledgable

1) Recomended a offer price and contract structure that resulted in obtaining the home we wanted without overpaying. 2) Recommended a morgage company that was able to get us to closely on the very aggressive timeline we had established in the contract.

1 - 11 of 11
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent