Mandy's profile

Mandy's reviews

  5  
Mandy has 15 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Mandy's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Amazing and Top notch
about 1 year ago
Amazing and Top notch

From first meet Mandy has been so amazing and very knowledgeable and thorough. She was on her A game the entire time. I couldn't have asked for a better agent!!!!! I am so grateful and blessed to have been introduced to Mandy and her team. The BEST in the industry. Thank you Mandy for everything ❤

Seller review
You know this will be smooth!
over 1 year ago
You know this will be smooth!

Always a bright spot working with you, Mandy! Can't wait to do it again.

Buyer review
Mandy Costello
almost 2 years ago
Mandy Costello

Mandy has been a terrific agent and has gone above and beyond in her service and especially her listening

Buyer review
A Wonderful Professional to Work With: Mandy Costello
almost 2 years ago
A Wonderful Professional to Work With: Mandy Costello

Mandy Costello worked extremely hard to help me find a home in close proximity to Emory University that I could afford. She was very patient and methodical in serving my needs. I highly recommend her as a realtor, and would hire her myself if I sell my home at some point.

Buyer review
Great agent!
almost 2 years ago
Great agent!

We had an excellent experience working with our real estate agent. One of the things we appreciated most was her non-pushy approach, which made us feel comfortable and in control throughout the process. She was consistently clear and honest in her communications, providing us with straightforward information and guidance every step of the way. This level of transparency helped us make informed decisions and truly trust in the advice given. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a trustworthy and effective real estate professional.

Buyer review
Excellent Organized and Knowledgeable!
about 2 years ago
Excellent Organized and Knowledgeable!

Mandy was very knowledgeable and extremely organized and helpful throughout the entire process. She kept us informed as our home was being built and frequently checked on it by visiting the site and making videos of the progress along the way. She worked well with the builder and the other real estate agent. We are so grateful for her and all she did to help us from start to finish!

Buyer review
Highly recommended
about 2 years ago
Highly recommended

Mandy went above and beyond helping my wife and me understand what to expect when building. She was always in our corner and gave great advice. A genuine pleasure!

Buyer review
Mandy is a true professional!
about 2 years ago
Mandy is a true professional!

After living in the same home for 32 years, we were looking for our retirement home away from the city. Mandy researched prospective homes and narrowed them down, took video tours for us to review before deciding which homes to actually travel to. It was wonderful and we couldn't be happier. She helped every step of the way!

Seller review
Mandy is just amazing!
about 2 years ago
Mandy is just amazing!

She goes above and beyond, making sure every step of the process is just perfect. I was scared and nervous after living in the same home for 32 years and now I have never been happier. Thank you Mandy1

Buyer review
Mandy was so helpful with my first home purchase!
over 2 years ago
Mandy was so helpful with my first home purchase!

This is my first home purchase, and I got a great deal on a better house than I thought I was going to be able to buy. Mandy was able to help me build my credit and find the extra money I needed to get started. No way I could have done this without her.

Seller review
The Best in the Business
almost 3 years ago
The Best in the Business

Mandy is the best! Attentive, quick responses, informative, excellent people person, and every positive adjective in the dictionary! She had a buyer for our property in less than 12 hours. She knows how to market and get the job done! She will get every listing we ever do!

Buyer review
Best experience I’ve Had with an agent!
over 3 years ago
Best experience I’ve Had with an agent!

Mandy was the biggest asset in finding our vacation rental, and quickly getting it set up and making money. She negotiated a great deal, at the height of the market, for a great cabin. She got us the lot next door for nothing, which gave us water access (at the HEIGHT of the market). She worked with her designer to beautifully furnish it at a very reasonable cost, and worked her tail off to get us ready to list. Her photographer was fantastic, and her expertise had us making a profit in the first five weeks. In this market, that says a lot. After our first 20 guests, her advice has enabled to us to keep our five star review, and near 100% occupancy rate. I can’t say enough about how invaluable she has been. I’m saving up to do my next deal with her!

1 - 12 of 15
© 2026 RateMyAgent