Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 16 reviewsacross 14 different locations, showing 12.
5 months ago
One in a Million!!!

Kelly and her team were such a blessing to us. Throughout the process she was immediately responsive in answering our questions or finding out information for us. She was incredibly supportive and knowledgeable of the area as well as the Real Estate industry. We were very fortunate to be represented by Kelly and her team all along the way. We highly recommend her for anyone searching to purchase a home and we would do it again if the opportunity arose.

6 months ago
Sharp, Strategic and Sold!

We worked with Kelly Mothershead to sell our home in East Lake/Tarpon Springs, and she delivered. Kelly priced strategically for today’s market, launched with state-of-the-art photography and current, multi-channel marketing that brought serious buyers in quickly. Communication was straight and honest, without the fluff and zero confusion. When offers came in, she laid out the tradeoffs clearly and negotiated without creating friction. Inspections, title, everything ran on schedule and without drama. In a market that hasn’t been easy, Kelly moved the sale forward quickly and kept stress low. We’d hire her again without hesitation.

6 months ago
Excellent realtor

Kelly was very professional and helpful throughout the process of selling our parent's homes. I highly recommend her to anyone in the Pasco county area! Thank you to Kelly and her team!

8 months ago
What a Fantastic Experience from a PRO

This deal almost didn't happen and without Kelly it likely would not have. Kelly worked hard in the final hour with finance team, seller and title company to be sure we closed on time. We cannot say enough about Kelly and her team.

9 months ago
Kelly Mothershead: Realtor, Hero, Magician

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Stars — Kelly Mothershead: Realtor, Hero, Magician The first time I met Kelly was by sheer fate — another realtor I liked went radio silent, and into the gap swooped Kelly. My mom was moving from Colorado to Florida and Kelly immediately jumped in like she’d been prepping for this moment her whole career. We toured a whirlwind week’s worth of homes, but the perfect one didn’t surface, and Mom flew home to Colorado heartbroken. Did Kelly give up? Absolutely not. She kept hunting, found the one, sent it my way, and Mom bought it remotely. Mom still sings her praises to anyone within earshot for truly understanding her wants and needs and delivering the dream home. Flash forward to Hurricane Helene — my house is destroyed. Kelly puts on her cape and springs into action. She connects me with the right people to sell the damaged property and then, like lightning, finds me the perfect replacement home. I don’t know if she has a genie lamp or a time machine, but whatever it is, it works. Fast forward again six months — I spot the perfect getaway property. I call Kelly. One month later, I’m signing papers. Rabbit out of a hat, yet again. Kelly isn’t just a realtor; she’s a dedicated, lightning-fast, caring powerhouse who understands your needs before you’ve finished explaining them. If you want someone who blends hustle, heart, and actual results, call Kelly. In my book, she’s the gold standard — and the reason my family keeps landing in the right homes at exactly the right time.

10 months ago
Sold in hours!

Incredible realtor! This is the second property that we listed with Kelly. We priced the property aggressively and within a few hours we had a full price offer. We couldn’t be happier!!

about 1 year ago
Kelly is a God Send!

This is the 3rd house transaction I have completed with Kelly! Always on her game! Kelly has never one time steered me in the wrong direction or not had an answer for me. Buying or selling a house is a huge event and I will work with Kelly every time!

over 1 year ago
A great experience

Kelly was an amazing help in guiding and advising throughout the entire process making it easy and comfortable the whole time!

over 2 years ago
Always kept informed!!

Kelly went out of her way for me to the extreme! Extremely knowledgeable about the market, so glad she was my agent, I highly recommend her!

almost 3 years ago
Wonderful Team!

Kelly was great communing various steps through the process and her team was great. They made sure all questions were answered and helped until the very last minute. So glad to have been referred to her and her team.

almost 3 years ago
Best Realtor in New Port Richey area

Honestly I can’t describe the professionalism, hard work and positive spirit of Kelly, she really made me feel like I was her only client, I would hundred percent recommend her for realtor needs in the area.

almost 3 years ago
Kelly helped us find our beach home!

She was knowledgeable and available whenever we needed to see a property or had questions on the process. She kept us informed and followed up on all of our questions. Kelly stepped up when we needed her. She is highly recommended!

1 - 12 of 16
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent