Kelly's profile

Kelly's reviews

  5  
Kelly has 10 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 10.
Map view
Kelly's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert, well-prepared.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
My wife and I can’t say enough good things about Kelly! From the bottom of our hearts, we’re so grat
about 1 month ago
My wife and I can’t say enough good things about Kelly! From the bottom of our hearts, we’re so grat

My wife and I can’t say enough good things about Kelly! From the bottom of our hearts, we’re so grateful to have had her by our side throughout this journey. Buying your first home can be an emotional and sometimes stressful experience, but Kelly made us feel supported, cared for, and confident every step of the way. What really sets Kelly apart is that she genuinely cares about her clients. She goes above and beyond, takes the time to listen, and makes you feel like more than just another transaction. Her kindness, patience, dedication, and willingness to help made such a difference for us. It’s not every day you meet someone who puts so much heart into what they do, and we feel truly fortunate to have worked with her. If you’re looking for a realtor who will treat you with care, honesty, and genuine compassion, we wholeheartedly recommend Kelly. We’re incredibly thankful for everything she’s done for us and couldn’t have asked for a better person to guide us through this experience!

Seller review
I am a licensed real estate professional myself, and I still chose to hire Kelly McCarthy to sell 3
about 2 months ago
I am a licensed real estate professional myself, and I still chose to hire Kelly McCarthy to sell 3

I am a licensed real estate professional myself, and I still chose to hire Kelly McCarthy to sell 3 of my homes. I wanted a trusted colleague who could keep my emotion out of the process, and she did exactly that. This is the third property she has sold for my family, and she has earned that trust every time. Our sale had challenges as many do, including home inspection items, punch list items, and several rounds of negotiation, HOA difficulties. Kelly stayed calm, communicated clearly, and responded promptly whenever an issue came up. She protected my best interest at every step while keeping the transaction moving. Her network of contractors made a measurable difference. One repair I had planned to hire out was quoted at $11,000. Kelly connected me with a contractor who completed it for $4,000, saving me $7,000 along with a lot of time and stress. Her dedication and thoughtfulness show in everything she does. I recommend her without reservation.

Seller review
Kelly was a pleasure to work with
about 2 months ago
Kelly was a pleasure to work with

Kelly was a pleasure to work with. She represented the sellers while I represented the buyers, and throughout the entire transaction she was professional, knowledgeable, responsive, and very efficient. Communication was always easy, and she did a great job keeping everything moving forward in a timely manner. I truly enjoyed working with her and would gladly work with Kelly again on another transaction.

Buyer review
I’ve had several real estate transactions in the past but never had an experience as with Kelly
3 months ago
I’ve had several real estate transactions in the past but never had an experience as with Kelly

I’ve had several real estate transactions in the past but never had an experience as with Kelly. She is the ultimate professional, very knowledgeable, communicative and would do (and does!) anything for her clients. While living on the opposite coast Kelly shared live videos with me, stood in for me with deliveries and repairs when I couldn’t be there even after closing! Kelly offered to help before I even knew I needed help. The search, purchase and close of my new home was seamless - Kelly went above and beyond in every aspect. I highly recommend Kelly, she’s one in a million!

Buyer review
I had an outstanding experience working with Kelly McCarthy
5 months ago
I had an outstanding experience working with Kelly McCarthy

I had an outstanding experience working with Kelly McCarthy. From start to finish, Kelly was professional, knowledgeable, and truly dedicated to making the process as smooth and stress‑free as possible. She took the time to understand my needs, provided clear guidance every step of the way, and was always quick to respond to questions or concerns. Kelly’s attention to detail and strong communication made a significant difference, and I always felt confident that I was in good hands. Her expertise in the market and commitment to her clients really set her apart. I highly recommend Kelly McCarthy to anyone looking for a reliable, responsive, and results‑driven Realtor. A true 5‑star experience! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Seller review
Kelly is absolutely fantastic! As another licensed agent who’s been doing business for a long time,
7 months ago
Kelly is absolutely fantastic! As another licensed agent who’s been doing business for a long time,

Kelly is absolutely fantastic! As another licensed agent who’s been doing business for a long time, I can say Kelly gets it. Had buyers who could only see property at a specific time and I could not be there. Most listing agents would tell you to find a time when you could be there but not Kelly. She did not hesitate to help. Whether you are buying or selling, Kelly is a great person to work with!

1 - 10 of 10
© 2026 RateMyAgent