Kelli's profile

Kelli's reviews

  4.9  
Kelli has 69 reviewsacross 12 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Kelli's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, patient, reliable, friendly, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Rockstar Agent
over 4 years ago
Rockstar Agent

Kelly was amazing in my process of buying a home. Very knowledgeable and suggestive, providing advice when I needed guidance. Kelly is very professional and kind. I would highly recommend her when you are looking for your next home.

Seller review
Kelli Overmyer was very professional and knowledgeable with selling my home.
over 4 years ago
Kelli Overmyer was very professional and knowledgeable with selling my home.

Kelli Overmyer was extremely helpful and responsive with everything from showing of my home until it closed. I could not have been happier working with her. I would definitely recommend Kelli Overmyer to anyone selling or buying a house. I was very satisfied. Five Stars !

Buyer review
I really enjoyed having Kelli as our realtor
over 5 years ago
I really enjoyed having Kelli as our realtor

I really enjoyed having Kelli as our realtor. She was very professional but also felt like she was a friend as well. She worked hard getting us the best deal we got.

Seller review
Kelli is very personable, capable and knowledgeable
over 5 years ago
Kelli is very personable, capable and knowledgeable

Kelli is very personable, capable and knowledgeable. She is accurate and swift in her abilities and follows through on her word. The Wendt Key Team is extremely helpful, transparent and communicative throughout the entire process. Thank you for making my husband and I feel understood and like a part of your team!

Buyer review
Kelli was super great to work with! Always replied when I needed her and was always willing to show
almost 8 years ago
Kelli was super great to work with! Always replied when I needed her and was always willing to show

Kelli was super great to work with! Always replied when I needed her and was always willing to show us a property whenever needed. Also as first time home buyers she made sure we fully understood everything and walked us through each step so we wouldn't miss anything. She has great communication and I would recommend her to anyone looking for a house!!

Seller review
Kelli is top notch
over 9 years ago
Kelli is top notch

Kelli is top notch. She provided great service, was easy to reach, and very helpful through the process of finding my next home. She knows the real estate business in this area very well and provided thorough consultation through every step of the process.

Seller review
Kelly was great
over 9 years ago
Kelly was great

Kelly was great. We moved from Vermont to Fremont, Ohio. Kelly coordinated the showing, negotiated the price and scheduled the closing to coincide with our closing in Vermont. My wife and I could not be happier with our new home. This was the smoothest experience in purchasing a home I have ever had. Thank you Kelly.

Seller review
Kelli was very knowledgeable and easy to work with
about 10 years ago
Kelli was very knowledgeable and easy to work with

Kelli was very knowledgeable and easy to work with. She was quick with responses and always made herself available at times that were convenient for me.

61 - 69 of 69
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent