Keith's profile

Keith's reviews

  5  
Keith has 144 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Keith's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, honest, supportive, reliable, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Above and Beyond!
1 day ago
Above and Beyond!

Keith was amazing, walking us through each step and making everything easy. He was available for all of our questions and we had many! His staff is also wonderful! He was like an old friend from the start. Very knowledgeable and easy going. We said many times we “lucked out” getting Keith! - Annie I knew from the beginning that Keith was the right agent for us. He was unbelievably helpful! Kind, considerate, truly a good soul! Thank you so much Keith! -Brad

Seller review
Performance of excellence.
5 days ago
Performance of excellence.

Don't mess around with anyone but Keith. If you want information at every step, he keeps you informed. Have questions at 8pm? He calls you back that night. Want honest answers? Keith gives you the hard honest facts. Selling, buying, any relestate need, the only person I will use.

Buyer review
We chose Keith for his experience,  and we got the best service from an agent we could have dreamed
11 days ago
We chose Keith for his experience, and we got the best service from an agent we could have dreamed

Keith knew every question without hesitation. We were brand new at commercial real estate, and Keith made our lives simple! Every single time we called or texted or emailed, Keith was Jonny on the spot! He spoke with our lenders, and translated everything where we could understand. Even in the difficult moments, Keith never made us feel like a burden or made us feel like we're were dumb. He was always there for us from the first call.

Buyer review
5 stars not high enough to evaluate / rate  Keith Nichols.
about 2 months ago
5 stars not high enough to evaluate / rate Keith Nichols.

Keith is VERY smart, his intelligence & savvy of the business was a huge help in working with VA. He ALWAYS made us feel we were important. His patience with us was awesome. You will NOT GO WRONG in putting your real Estate needs in the best "RealEstater" .

Seller review
5 stars review!
2 months ago
5 stars review!

My agent Keith Nichols in Orofino got back to my phone calls and texts within 24 hours time. He has exceptional customer service we chose Keith Nichols in Orofino because he has a 360 degree camera for virtual tour of my property and an aerial drone for high resolution pictures. If you’re buying or selling property in the Kamiah or Orofino areas, Keith Nichols is the best real estate agent in Idaho County!

Seller review
Excellant Communications
2 months ago
Excellant Communications

Keith is very personable, excellant in communitations , keeping us undated as the process and of any status changes. Working with Keith has been a pleasant experience.

Seller review
Excellent Service
3 months ago
Excellent Service

Keith was always in touch with us to let us know what was happening with our property and always ready to answer any questions we had , excellent service .

Buyer review
Great Communication
3 months ago
Great Communication

Keith was always available and great at communicating with us. He helped make our real estate transaction go smoothly. We would recommend Keith to anyone looking for a real estate agent.

Seller review
Gave us a chance.
3 months ago
Gave us a chance.

We spoke with a different realtor before speaking with Keith and they didn’t even want to come look at our property, saying it would never sell for what we wanted. We decided to get a second opinion and chatted with Keith. He was happy to come see our place and more than willing to list it for what we wanted. He was friendly, informative, and communicative. We in fact did sell our land for exactly what we wanted, and very quickly. Would absolutely recommend Keith! He was great to work with.

Seller review
Perseverance
4 months ago
Perseverance

Throughout the sale of my property, Keith was always there to answer any questions I had even in dealing with the title company. Who we will say was marching to the beat of their own drum. He stayed on them, Got the deal done and Made sure that everything was handled professionally.

Seller review
Excellent service
4 months ago
Excellent service

Working with Keith Nickols was an excellent experience from start to finish. His knowledge of the local real estate market was invaluable and made a huge difference throughout the process. He understood current market trends, neighborhood values, and pricing strategies, which helped us make informed decisions with confidence. Keith was always responsive, professional, and willing to answer our questions. He took the time to explain every step, kept us updated throughout the transaction, and made what could have been a stressful process feel straightforward and manageable. His attention to detail, strong negotiation skills, and commitment to our best interests were evident from day one. If you're looking for a real estate agent who truly knows the local market, communicates well, and works hard to get the best possible outcome, I highly recommend Keith Nickols. His expertise and dedication exceeded our expectations, and we wouldn't hesitate to work with him again. If this is for Google Reviews, this version is an ideal length and includes keywords like "local real estate market," "market trends," and "neighborhood values" that can also be helpful for search visibility.

1 - 12 of 144
© 2026 RateMyAgent