Katannya Hartwell

Katannya Hartwell

REALTOR® / Licensed Real Estate Agent at Coldwell Banker Northland
AZ: SA684006000
  •   5   (13 reviews)

About Katannya

Katannya Hartwell, ABR®, RSPS, believes real estate should feel less like a transaction and more like a grounded, intuitive experience. A Flagstaff-based Realtor® since 2019, Katannya brings strategic clarity and calm to every step of the real estate journey — whether you’re buying a first home, selling a long-time residence, or investing in a property with income potential. She specializes in unique homes, second properties, and lifestyle-driven decisions, offering guidance that’s as thoughtful as it is practical. Katannya’s approach is shaped by a diverse background in psychology, Waldorf education, and small business. Before real estate, she taught in both public and private schools and ran a successful TaeKwonDo school. That blend of teaching, leadership, and lifelong learning informs her steady, client-centered style. She also brings five years of experience in the short-term rental space through Bear Paw Comforts LLC, a business she helped build to support hospitality-focused property owners. This firsthand perspective gives her clients a deeper understanding of what it means to buy, sell, or invest in a home that serves both personal and practical needs. Curious by nature and grounded in Flagstaff’s outdoor lifestyle, Katannya’s interests range from hiking, climbing, and snowboarding to science fiction, the human condition, and well-loved episodes of Survivor. Whether she’s guiding clients or exploring a new trail, her work reflects a deep appreciation for growth, resilience, and meaningful connection. Clients describe her as intuitive, strategic, and quietly brilliant — the kind of Realtor® who helps you tune into what matters and move forward with confidence.

Katannya's reviews

  5  
Katannya has 13 reviewsacross 3 different locations, showing 6.
Review Katannya
8 months ago
Katannya Hartwell was extremely knowledgeable, compassionate and a savvy negotiator!

In working with Katannya, I found her to be extremely knowledgeable of the Flagstaff real estate market, both in residential sales and in the short term rental space. It was really obvious that she has spent a lot of time and energy exploring and learning the Flagstaff and surrounding areas of northern Arizona. She also has a very analytical approach to her work. Pay attention to her growing list of real estate designations and credentials and you will see she is committed to her profession. I would highly recommend her as a buyer's agent, a listing agent and a consultant for someone looking to buy an investment property. She really knows all of these areas well. She is a great agent with a lot to offer.

12 months ago
Fast sale, smooth process, highly recommend!

My husband and I couldn’t be more impressed with the outstanding service provided by Katannya. Her professionalism, market knowledge, and strategic approach stood out. Our home was listed and under contract, in just three days—with multiple offers at well over asking price. Katannya guided us through every step, making what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and seamless. If you're looking for an agent who gets results and will go the extra mile, you won't be disappointed with Katannya.

about 1 year ago
Great Agent for Property Investment

I was referred to Katannya while searching for an investment property. She was very knowledgeable in the N. Arizona market and knew exactly what I was looking for. Katannya was responsive to feedback and was easy to work with. I would work with her again in the future.

almost 2 years ago
Katannya is knowledgeable and professional while being kind and personable as well

Katannya is knowledgeable and professional while being kind and personable as well. She gave great care and attention while I was shopping for a home and was able to pick up on my wants that I hadn't even realized I had! I would recommend her to any home buyer in the Flagstaff area and look forward to working with her in the future.

almost 2 years ago
Unique Property for a Vacation Getaway

My wife and I worked with Katannya to buy a place in Flagstaff a few years ago. She was a terrific agent, keeping us informed throughout negotiations, giving advice and then even helping us find people to fix the place up after we bought it. Katannya is attentive, courteous and hardworking. We highly working with her! Peter

Show all 13 reviews

Katannya's properties

Katannya has 2 properties for sale and sold 1 property in the last 12 months, showing 3, sorted by most recent activity

SoldSep 5, 2025
For Sale
$299,000
2187 South Warriors Run
Verde Village AZ 86326
2
2
1
Other
For Sale
$200,000
4685 Aquila Way
Flagstaff AZ 86004
Land
Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Northland
Show all 3 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent