Karly Wentzloff

Karly Wentzloff

  •   5   (5 reviews)

About Karly

Karly is a Real Estate Agent at Real Estate One - Traverse City Randolph St.. They have 5 verified reviews with an average rating of 5 stars. They currently have 2 active property listings and 10 sold property listings over the past 12 months worth $3,995,275.

Karly's reviews

  5  
Karly has 5 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 5.
Review Karly
about 4 years ago
Incredible Karly!

Working with Karly to find a home was a great experience! Karly has went above and beyond to put me and my wife in a home. Karly is a joy to work with, she is very personal with her clients making the whole experience stress free. Her ability to solve any problem that can happen when buying a house is extra ordinary. Karly's work ethic and how she accomplish's any task at hand is what makes her so Incredible! Thank you Karly!

over 4 years ago
An absolute pleasure to work with - we love Karly!!!

Karly has been an amazing realtor to work with. She has represented us in both buying a new home and selling our previous home. The thing we like the most about her is that she is very honest and transparent with us. If she doesn't think a home is the right fit for you, she will tell you right away and why. She has also made this process so seamless and easy! I feel like we've barely had to do anything for the purchase or sale, and can focus on the the things that are more important to us like organizing, packing, and moving! Lastly Karly was able to help us get our new home significantly under it's listing price while selling our previous home for significantly above listing price (which is a homeowners dream right?!) We will definitely be recommending Karly to all of our friends.

over 4 years ago
Long distance move made easy, thanks to Karly!

Karly was absolutely fantastic to work with. We were first-time homebuyers, relocating to Northern Michigan from the west coast. Karly was very helpful and understood the challenges of house-hunting remotely and had a solution for every situation. We loved that she attends home inspections when she can just to be a more knowledgeable agent for her clients. She did a great job keeping us in the loop and was quick to act when we made decisions or wanted to move forward. We had our first offer accepted within a week of beginning our search. We highly recommend Karly to anyone in the area!

over 4 years ago
Larly is the best!

Karly is the best! We first worked with her in 2012. She helped us buy our home. We were first time buyers and she was so patient with us. We were doing a USDA loan which made it a little more complicated. When we decided it was time to sell we knew we wanted her again! She guided us through the whole process. She is very knowledgeable and always answered all of our questions. If we hadn't been moving out of state we would have wanted her for buying our next house.

over 4 years ago
Buyer and Seller

I was initially a first time homebuyer working with Karly and she walked me through every step answering questions I didn’t even know I had about taxes, insurance, mortgages.. the list goes on. She recommended amazing lenders and housing inspectors. I felt very comfortable throughout the whole process. Once I was ready to move on to a new home, not only did she sell my home so I made a profit but she worked so hard to ensure I got my dream home in a multiple offer situation. I HIGHLY recommend Karly. She worked for me even while on a family vacation in Florida where she was when the seller accepted my offer. If you’re buying or selling in northern Michigan she’s a pro either way!

Karly's properties

Karly has 2 properties for sale and sold 16 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldApr 27, 2026
$448,000
3800 N 13 Rd
Wexford County MI 49668
4
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REO-TCRandolph-233022 and REMAX Bayshore - W Bay Shore Dr TC
Under Contract
$549,900
5578 Heritage Way
Traverse City MI 49684
4
4
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REO-TCRandolph-233022
SoldFeb 27, 2026
$397,000
5260 Blair Town Hall Road
Grawn MI 49637
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of REO-TCRandolph-233022 and Wentworth Real Estate Group
SoldFeb 13, 2026
$466,000
1568 Nightingale Ln
Kingsley MI 49649
4
3
3
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Key Realty One-TC and REO-TCRandolph-233022
Show all 18 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent