Kaitlyn Reef

Kaitlyn Reef

Sales: 2019003316
  •   5   (6 reviews)

About Kaitlyn

Kaitlyn grew up in Baltimore and graduated from Liberty Union-Thurston High School in 2012. She obtained her Real Estate Certification at Columbus State Community College. Representing Central Ohio, she has been helping families and individuals with their real estate goals since 2019, selling over $11.2 Million worth of volume. She is dedicated to her clients and committed to providing the best service possible. She is a Certified Real Estate Negotiator, has received multiple awards for her sales volume, and has also been recognized as a top agent on social media in Ohio. With experience in the buying and selling of pre-existing real estate, as well as new build construction, Kaitlyn is qualified in multiple areas and confident in her work ethic and the insight she brings to any real estate transaction. Kaitlyn also prides herself in being involved within her communities. Whether it be serving on the YPN board with the Lancaster Board of Realtors, acting as vice-president in the Lancaster chapter of the Kiwanis club, or simply just volunteering at the farmer's market, Kaitlyn loves to stay active and provide help in any way that she can.

Kaitlyn's reviews

  5  
Kaitlyn has 6 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 6.
Review Kaitlyn
Seller review
Quick & Easy
19 days ago
Quick & Easy

Kaitlyn's dedication to helping us through selling our first home was excellent! She was in constant communication throughout the entire process. Our family was grateful to leave such precious memories in great hands. Thanks for helping us sell our first home!

Seller review
Excellent
11 months ago
Excellent

From the beginning of our experience with Kaitlyn, she was personable and professional. She explained the sale process to us in her office and provided us with learning materials prior to listing our home. Kaitlyn was always willing to show us homes that were of interest to us and always took time out of her busy schedule to do so. She was always available for questions and provided us with feedback we requested on certain properties. I would not hesitate to recommend Kaitlyn to anyone ready to sell or purchase a home. She is a truly nice person and someone we hope to stay in touch with in the future.

Seller review
Kaitlyn has all the answers to any question.
about 1 year ago
Kaitlyn has all the answers to any question.

I have been very satisfied with the service Kaitlyn has provided in the recent sale of my home. Kaitlyn had provided excellent service on the sale of a home prior to this time and I was very pleased with her knowledge and if I had a question I always knew she would have the answer. She kept everything moving along and therefore everything went well.

Seller review
Good with Communication
over 1 year ago
Good with Communication

Kaitlyn was wonderful to work with. She worked hard to not only sell our house but to find us a new one as well. Our new house was contingent on selling our old house so Kaitlyn worked hard to sell our house so we could move forward with the sale. Kaitlyn is very good with communication during the entire buying/selling process.

Buyer review
Very nice and helpful
over 1 year ago
Very nice and helpful

Kaitlyn was prompt and helpful. We had a difficult closing with our buyers and Kaitlyn was a huge help throughout the process.

Seller review
Outstanding agent
over 2 years ago
Outstanding agent

We worked with Kaitlyn for 3 years looking for our dream retirement property. She was always available to show us any house we wanted to see. I had even apologized for not being able to decided her comment was “Not a problem it’s just not the right house yet” So after 3 years we found our perfect property. Kaitlyn was super knowledgeable and helpful with the whole process even in selling our home at top dollar . I have already recommended her to friends and would definitely continue to do so . This is the 5 home we have purchased and Kaitlyn is above far the best agent we have worked with.

Kaitlyn's properties

Kaitlyn has 2 properties for sale and sold 4 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 13, 2026
$350,000
14948 Jack Run Road
Rockbridge OH 43149
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOWARD HANNA REAL ESTATE SVCS and BARTLETT BENNER REALTY
SoldApr 17, 2026
$219,900
2976 Pleasant Dr NE
Lancaster OH 43130
3
1
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOWARD HANNA REAL ESTATE SVCS and RE/MAX ONE
For Sale
$165,000
301 North Main Street
Pleasantville OH 43148
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of HOWARD HANNA REAL ESTATE SVCS
SoldMay 23, 2025
$329,000
494 Sells Road
Lancaster OH 43130
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Key Realty
Show all 6 properties
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent