John Reuter

John Reuter

  •   5   (8 reviews)

About John

John Reuter | Integrity Homes Broker | Founder, Reward Our Heroes John Reuter is a Wisconsin-based real estate advisor and retired Air Force veteran serving Madison and the greater Dane County area. His approach is education-first and no-pressure—focused on helping clients clearly understand their options so they can make confident decisions without feeling rushed or sold to. John’s military background shows up in how he works: disciplined, detail-oriented, and steady under pressure. Clients often describe him as calm, patient, and easy to work with—especially during complex or high-stress transactions. “John always takes the time to answer questions and explain the real estate market in a way that actually makes sense.” — Ian, Waunakee, WI He’s known for hyper-local knowledge of Wisconsin neighborhoods, including schools, community amenities, and long-term livability—not just pricing trends or surface-level stats. John is also the founder of Reward Our Heroes, an initiative dedicated to supporting veterans, first responders, healthcare professionals, and teachers through education, advocacy, and real financial advantages in homeownership. His role isn’t to push decisions—it’s to explain options clearly, communicate honestly, and advocate for his clients every step of the way.

John's reviews

  5  
John has 8 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 6.
Review John
4 months ago
John is amazing! We've worked with him a few times now both in buying and selling in Madison

John is amazing! We've worked with him a few times now both in buying and selling. He really is knowledgeable about current trends and helped us really narrow down our own thoughts and possibilities. He's got a great sense of humor which is nice especially if you drag him around to 6 house showings in a single day (sry John but we found one!) You cant go wrong if you need someone to help buy or sell. One last thing, when we were looking for out first home, he really got to know us and seemed to know at a glance if something was what were were looking for or not. He also tolaught us a lot of what to look for when viewing homes. 10/10 would use again.

6 months ago
We were looking for a Realtor who helps veterans in Madison and found John Reuter with Integrity Hom

We were looking for a Realtor who helps veterans in Madison and found John Reuter with Integrity Homes. From our very first call, John made time for us—he literally stopped moving into a storage unit to talk and learn about our goals. Hannah is a nurse and I'm a Marine Corps vet, and we immediately felt like John understood our unique needs. He made the process enjoyable (we had a lot of laughs!) but also stayed focused and professional. When we found the perfect home in Madison, the seller wasn’t willing to budge much—but John still negotiated $4,000 in savings for us. Then our lender hit a delay, and John somehow got us early access to move in so we wouldn’t be left scrambling. That kind of care and dedication meant the world. We’re beyond grateful to John and the Integrity Homes team for helping us buy our first home in a competitive market with confidence. — Ryan & Hannah Madison, WI #VeteranHomeBuyer #MadisonHomes #MadisonRealtor #IntegrityHomesWI

6 months ago
John and his crew were so knowledgeable about reality

John and his crew were so knowledgeable about reality. They guided me through selling my family home with ease. I definitely recommend John to anyone buying or selling a home. Sara H.

about 1 year ago
I had heard amazing things about John Reuter from other unit members before my PCS to Madison, WI

I had heard amazing things about John Reuter from other unit members before my PCS to Madison, WI for a full-time military assignment. I needed someone who truly understood the complexities of military relocation and the competitive real estate market in Dane County. John came highly recommended, and now I know why. From the moment we connected, John provided top-tier service. He helped me sell my home fast and simultaneously buy a new home in Windsor, WI — a rare gem in a tight housing market. Even with limited homes for sale, John managed to find the perfect home for us and negotiated $65,000 off the list price! His knowledge of the Waunakee, Windsor, and Madison real estate markets was invaluable – best Realtor hands down. The communication throughout the home buying and selling process was exceptional. John's attention to detail, responsiveness, and professionalism gave me confidence every step of the way. His team stayed on top of every detail, making this a smooth transition for me and my family. If you’re a military family or anyone looking to buy or sell a home in Waunakee, Windsor, DeForest, or the greater Madison area, I cannot recommend John Reuter enough. As an Air Force veteran and trusted local realtor, he gets the job done — and done right.

Show all 8 reviews

John's properties

John has 9 properties for sale and sold 18 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$449,900
383 Sunnyview Lane
Marshall WI 53559
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Integrity Homes - Real Broker LLC
For Sale
$789,900
1394 Winchester Pass
Verona WI 53593
5
3
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Integrity Homes - Real Broker LLC
SoldMay 1, 2026
$430,000
1604 Rustic Drive
Sun Prairie WI 53590
3
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Integrity Homes - Real Broker LLC and Stark Company, REALTORS
For Sale
$154,900
1016 South 35th Street
Milwaukee WI 53215
3
1
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Integrity Homes - Real Broker LLC
Show all 27 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent