Jeff and Betty's profile

Jeff and Betty's reviews

  4.9  
Jeff and Betty has 19 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jeff and Betty's qualities as told by our client reviews: patient, clear communication, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Excellent in Everything She Did
24 days ago
Excellent in Everything She Did

Betty is awesome. She helped us purchase and eventually sell our vacation home at Lake Naci. We couldnt have asked for a better more informed person to trust with the process. She is very knowledgable about the local HOA regulations within Herritage Ranch.

Seller review
Start to Finish, She Was Exceptional.
27 days ago
Start to Finish, She Was Exceptional.

Betty helped us find this lake house, and years later, she helped us say goodbye to it. That kind of full-circle trust isn't something you find everywhere. From the very first showing to the final closing, she was present, professional, and genuinely cared about more than just the transaction. The memories we made in that house will last a lifetime — and so will our gratitude for the person who helped us find it. If you want an agent who shows up for the whole journey, Betty is your person.

Seller review
Two individuals who had my best interests in mind.
about 2 months ago
Two individuals who had my best interests in mind.

Jeff and Betty worked tirelessly to ensure that we received the best experience possible. Jeff did a great job of communicating with us throughout the process. He explained everything so that we could understand and make the right decisions. Their years of experience paid off when the buyers tried to play games with the process. Jeff made sure that our interests were top priority.

Buyer review
Trust and care
over 1 year ago
Trust and care

Complete work with trust and good support.

Buyer review
Great Experience With Jeff & Betty
over 1 year ago
Great Experience With Jeff & Betty

We had a great experience working with Jeff and Betty on the purchase of our property. They were always available to answer any questions we had and working with them made the buying process such a breeze. Would highly recommend working with them.

Buyer review
The Dream Team
over 1 year ago
The Dream Team

We have worked with Jeff and Betty Stelzl for two homes over the past several years. They are highly knowledgeable and deeply committed to ensuring the best outcome for their clients. This time, they showed us multiple houses for about a year until we found the perfect one. They always responded to any questions, provided clear explanations, and advocated for us as buyers every step of the way. Jeff and Betty are highly skilled negotiators and they worked tirelessly on our behalf to help us get the best possible deal on both homes we've purchased. If you're looking for realtors who are professional, personable, and truly care about your best interests, look no further than Jeff and Betty Stelzl.

Buyer review
Outstanding Experience with Jeff and Betty Stelzl!
over 1 year ago
Outstanding Experience with Jeff and Betty Stelzl!

Over the past 2+ years, we've had the opportunity to work with Jeff and Betty Stelzl in our search for the perfect home. This is our second home purchase with them, and I can confidently say that their expertise, dedication, and commitment to us as clients have been nothing short of exceptional. From the very beginning, Jeff and Betty took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for. They were always quick to notify us of new properties on the market that fit our criteria, and we never felt pressured to rush into a decision. They were patient, thorough, and willing to show us as many homes as we needed until we found the right fit. Their deep knowledge of the market, paired with their relentless drive to find us the best options, made the entire process so much easier. One of the things that really sets Jeff apart is his incredible negotiation skills. He worked tirelessly to ensure we got the best deals on each of our purchases, handling every detail with care and precision. His experience showed in how he was able to resolve any issue that arose, and we always felt supported, even in challenging situations. In addition to their real estate expertise, Jeff and Betty were incredibly helpful in connecting us with reliable contractors and handymen, which made settling into our new homes much smoother. They didn’t just stop at the sale; they were with us every step of the way, ensuring we had the right resources and contacts to make each house truly feel like home. If you are looking for realtors who are not only knowledgeable and professional but also deeply invested in your success, Jeff and Betty Stelzl are the team to trust. They went above and beyond for us, and we can’t recommend them highly enough.

Buyer review
Jeff and Betty Stelzl - superior real estate experience!
almost 2 years ago
Jeff and Betty Stelzl - superior real estate experience!

My husband and I spent several years researching the Paso Robles area for potential rental property investments as well as a retirement home. We were new to the concept of putting down roots there with no previous knowledge about that part of California. Jeff and Betty Stelzl were the perfect partners for us during our investigations. Jeff met with us several times before we decided to make a rental property investment. He patiently explained the nuances of the City's ordinances around rental properties. He exposed us to various types of properties that were available and educated us on the pro and con of each type. Jeff and Betty kept us informed of potential properties for investment by providing screened listings for us to review. When time drew closer to make a decision on the actual property purchase, Jeff showed us a wide range of properties to consider and provided valuable feedback on their market potential. Being residents of Paso Robles, they knew all the nooks and crannies of the City and were able to advise us wisely on the optimal choices for our purchase. When we did purchase, the timelines were tight as dictated by the 1031 exchange rules that covered the transaction. Jeff and Betty were instrumental with negotiating efficiently with the Seller, expediting repairs, and processing the paperwork to close the sale. Their knowledge of the commercial issues that needed to be managed was key to meeting the deadlines required. I highly recommend Jeff and Betty for your real estate needs! In fact, we are already looking at a second investment and would not turn to anyone else.

Seller review
Efficient and Experienced: Jeff and Betty Stelzl Sold My Home Fast!
almost 2 years ago
Efficient and Experienced: Jeff and Betty Stelzl Sold My Home Fast!

Jeff and Betty are seasoned real estate agents with an impressive 45 years of experience. Their professionalism and deep knowledge of the market were evident from our very first meeting. Selling a home can be a daunting process, but Jeff and Betty made it seamless and stress-free. They provided invaluable advice on preparing the property for sale, ensuring it looked its absolute best to attract potential buyers. Their years of experience shone through in their strategic pricing, They have many professional contacts for any work needed and facilitated all jobs. Throughout the entire process, Jeff and Betty were proactive communicators, keeping me informed every step of the way. They were responsive to all my questions and concerns, and their guidance was invaluable in navigating negotiations and closing the deal swiftly and efficiently. What impressed me most about Jeff and Betty was their dedication to achieving results. They didn't just list my home; they actively worked preparing it to bring it to market and bring qualified buyers to the table. I would wholeheartedly recommend Jeff and Betty Stelzl to anyone looking to sell their home. Their experience, professionalism, and commitment to their clients set them apart in the real estate market. Thank you, Jeff and Betty, for your exceptional service and for selling my home quickly and smoothly!

Seller review
The Stelzl team works hard.
about 2 years ago
The Stelzl team works hard.

Jeff and Betty took charge of the selling of our house and gave us their best effort. The house sold within 3 weeks at an excellent price. They are a very efficient knowledgeable team.

Seller review
Selling a home in a difficult market
about 2 years ago
Selling a home in a difficult market

Things can happen during a sale of a home, but having solid agents in your corner it WILL get done.

Buyer review
Great experience!
about 2 years ago
Great experience!

Jeff and Betty are excellent to work with. They're both incredibly responsive, thorough and patient. Would absolutely work with them again, thanks Jeff and Betty!

1 - 12 of 19
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent