Jay's profile

Jay's reviews

  5  
Jay has 82 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Jay is TOP NOTCH!

Jay is the only realtor I will use. He is knowledgeable, helpful, and efficient. Jay makes the selling process as easy as possible and is always there for his clients.

over 2 years ago
Awesome experience!

Jay and Dustin were both very helpful throughout this process. I couldn’t have asked for a better experience!!! Amazing experience and I would recommend to anyone!

over 2 years ago
Return Customers

This was our second time using Jay to buy a house and he always gets it done. We were looking for a specific type of home for a long time. Closing became a challenge with the sellers but Jay worked it all out and we closed on time.

almost 3 years ago
Patient and knowledgeable

Jay worked with us to help us find the perfect condo. He was knowledgeable and was available to visit the homes whenever we asked. He responded quickly to my hundreds of questions. I highly recommend him

almost 3 years ago
Jay Mattlin was a joy to work with!

Selling a home and moving a distance away from family is always hard. Jay helped by making the process of selling the home seamless. The timely reminders throughout the process were very helpful- keeping us all on track.

almost 3 years ago
House buying made easy!

My house buying process was a breeze with helpful recommendations from Jay, an easy singing process, and Jay’s availability to answer all of my questions along the way! Thank you for helping me buy my first home!!

about 3 years ago
Painless transaction

After hiring Jay to oversee the sale of my property, my experience was painless and easy. He took care of everything and kept me informed. He was able to answer all my questions quickly and accurately. I certainly will use him again.

about 3 years ago
Smooth and Seamless Transaction

Thank you Jay Mattlin, Key Realty for selling my property in Ohio. As always, a smooth and seamless transaction, even while living in another state. I couldn't ask for a better realtor to sell my home. I have worked with Jay multiple times selling and buying homes, and every time it has been a pleasure. Jay has extensive knowledge and experience, and each of my experiences has been smooth and hassle-free. I highly recommend Jay without any reservations.

about 3 years ago
Easiest transaction ever!

Wow excellent agent! Easiest transaction I've ever did everything went smooth he had my house sold in less than 30 days

over 3 years ago
You won’t be disappointed!

Jay did a phenomenal job helping us sell our rental property. He was just as motivated as we were to get it sold! He was knowledgeable and always available for our many, many questions. If we ever need any other realtor needs, he will be our go to guy!

over 3 years ago
Sold Land Quickly

Jay was able to post and sale our land pretty quickly. He was able to work with the buyer and my wife and I efficiently and effectively. There was zero issues with any of the process from opening to closing.

13 - 24 of 82
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent