Jason's profile

Jason's reviews

  5  
Jason has 27 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Jason's qualities as told by our client reviews: local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Jason was great all the way. Perfect experience
2 months ago
Jason was great all the way. Perfect experience

Jason worked past every hurdle. Got a great value on the listing and was amazing in communication. He used every resource to help make the best deal for all parties. Great job. Highly recommend!

Buyer review
Expert Guidance for Real Estate on the Lake Erie Islands
2 months ago
Expert Guidance for Real Estate on the Lake Erie Islands

Jason was great to work with throughout a long transaction that involved a number of complexities. From navigating unique property considerations to working through contingencies and timing challenges, he stayed patient, responsive, and steady the entire time. What stood out most was his knowledge of the market, village, and county, especially when it came to navigating nuances around private road access, easements, and local zoning considerations. On the island, it’s not uncommon for older agreements or property arrangements to need updating to meet modern title and lending requirements, and his experience navigating those details was pivotal in moving the sale forward. Jason also helped think through not just the purchase itself, but the longer-term considerations of the property. He was always available to answer questions, kept things moving forward, and was proactive in coordinating with all parties involved. Real estate transactions on the island can come with their own set of challenges, and having someone experienced and level-headed made a big difference. I’d absolutely recommend Jason to anyone looking to buy or sell property on Kelleys Island.

Buyer review
Super Star!
3 months ago
Super Star!

I initially worked with Jason for short-term rentals on Kelleys Island over the past 10 years or so. I found him to be incredibly responsive, extremely knowledgeable about the area and wonderful to work with. When a condo in an ideal location came up for purchase recently, I reached out to Jason, and he responded very quickly. Again, he was knowledgeable about the area and thorough in his research. He answered all of my questions and was supportive throughout the process. I found his expertise and advice to be extremely helpful in a competitive bid. This was especially important since I was buying from out of state. I strongly recommend this experienced and caring Real Estate Professional!

Seller review
Trusted Expert for Kelleys Island Real Estate
4 months ago
Trusted Expert for Kelleys Island Real Estate

I have worked with Jason on multiple Kelleys Island transactions. He helped with my original home purchase and, years later, the sale of that home along with the purchase of a new island property. Jason is extremely knowledgeable about the nuances of the KI market, rental considerations, and what it really entails to be an island homeowner. His guidance went well beyond the transaction itself, and his advice has been invaluable. I highly recommend Jason to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Knowledgeable, efficient, courteous
6 months ago
Knowledgeable, efficient, courteous

Jason served as our agent to purchase land on Kelley's Island. He could answer all of my questions about land, utilities, HOAs, builders, and more. If he did not know the answer to a question, he would find out and get back to me in a timely fashion. He was always quick to answer my phone calls and emails. We are now building our dream getaway on Kelley's Island. I don't plan on selling our new house anytime soon, but if I were, I would want Jason to be my realtor.

Seller review
Excellent!
6 months ago
Excellent!

Jason Smith is excellent to work with. His market knowledge was clear from the start—he understood the local trends, pricing strategy, and what buyers are looking for. His communication was consistent, clear, and always timely, which made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Jason carries himself with a high level of professionalism, and I always felt that he had my best interests in mind. I would happily work with him again and strongly recommend him to anyone looking for a dedicated and knowledgeable real estate agent.

Buyer review
Excellent.
7 months ago
Excellent.

Jason knows Kelleys island like no other agent. He’s the best

Buyer review
Make Jason Smith Your Agent!
7 months ago
Make Jason Smith Your Agent!

Our daughter and son in law had a wonderful experience when they purchased the home of their dreams with Jason’s help. Therefore when my husband and I started looking to relocate and downsize, Jason’s expertise came to mind immediately! He showed us many homes and condos taking into account our needs. We really appreciated his patience with us. Finally, a move became necessary while we were out of the state. Our daughter contacted Jason about a new home we liked in a development across the street from her. Jason immediately showed them the home on a Friday. We made a bid across the miles on Saturday that was accepted on Monday. Throughout the process Jason went above and beyond to make us feel comfortable about the purchase. Jason was in constant contact with us. He came to the home on several occasions to act on our behalf. When we finally walked through the front door of our new home we were so thankful Jason Smith was our realtor!

Seller review
Extremely knowledgeable, hard working, and professional.
7 months ago
Extremely knowledgeable, hard working, and professional.

Jason did an outstanding job helping us sell multiple properties. He walked us through the process, was quick to respond to any concerns or questions we had, and always gave us good advice. I would highly recommend him to anyone selling a home or property. Jason is an exceptional realtor.

Buyer review
Best KI Realtor
8 months ago
Best KI Realtor

Jason's reputation on Kelley's Island precedes him. He knows the island, he's knowledgable about renting/short-term rentals, and he cares a lot about the area. He walked us through the process and helped a lot when things got a little difficult due to issues with our bank as well as issues with the seller.

Seller review
Relentless Representation
8 months ago
Relentless Representation

Jason dealt with challenging circumstances during the sale of my Kelleys Island home. Jason was professional & thoughtful throughout the process while being nimble with each hurdle thrown our way. His island expertise was a big reason for the successful sale! I would recommend Jason for any of your real estate needs!

Buyer review
Exactly What We Wanted
8 months ago
Exactly What We Wanted

We could not have asked to work with a better realtor in finding the perfect house for us. He listened to our every want and need and found the perfect fit. He took the time with us to make sure that we found the house for us. Could not recommend anyone else.

1 - 12 of 27
© 2026 RateMyAgent