Holly's profile

Holly's reviews

  5  
Holly has 42 reviewsacross 20 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Holly's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, empathetic, detail-oriented, clear communication, reliable, responsive, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Best Realtor in the Business
13 days ago
Best Realtor in the Business

Working with Holly and her team was truly an exceptional experience. She is so knowledgeable about the buying and selling process. She was helpful in guiding us when we had questions and super helpful in showing us properties . I would highly recommend Holly .

Seller review
Holly's integrity, professionalism and dedication made selling our home seamless.
13 days ago
Holly's integrity, professionalism and dedication made selling our home seamless.

Working with Holly was exceptional from start to finish. She was thorough, communicative and transparent throughout the entire process. Her market knowledge helped us price and position our home competitively. What stood out most was her integrity and she always did what was right, even when things got complicated. From coordinating contractors and inspections to navigating the HOA and buyer negotiations, she handled everything professionally and made our lives significantly easier during what was already a major life transition. We were relocating out of state while selling remotely and Holly managed every detail with care and competence. We would recommend her without hesitation to anyone looking for a realtor who truly has their client's best interests at heart.

Buyer review
Holly is caring, knowledgeable and thorough
11 months ago
Holly is caring, knowledgeable and thorough

We absolutely loved having Holly as our agent. She always has our best interest at heart, is completely available at all times, and is an expert at all things realty-wise. She is a true pleasure to work with!

Buyer review
Fantastic experience.
11 months ago
Fantastic experience.

One of the elite realtors in the market. Very experienced and knowledgeable about the entire Denver metro area, especially cities in the southern suburbs. Always available for questions and will go to bat for her clients.

Buyer review
Highly Recommend!
11 months ago
Highly Recommend!

As a first time homebuyer, Holly was an incredible partner for us throughout the entire process. She took every chance to educate us on the process, and make sure we were comfortable with all of the commitments we were making. She also made sure that every term in the deal worked favorably for us, and that all inspection items were thoroughly covered.

Seller review
Excellent!
12 months ago
Excellent!

Holly was amazing at communicating and making the process of selling my house so easy. She took the time to explain the process and had so much knowledge. She continuously updated me on how the sale was going and was always available for questions. 10/10 would recommend!

Seller review
5 star experience
about 1 year ago
5 star experience

Holly and her team were absolutely amazing to work with. She was always available, and so helpful with questions and concerns. I could not recommend using her, more.

Seller review
Holly Payne needs her own billboard!!!
over 1 year ago
Holly Payne needs her own billboard!!!

Holly Payne is an amazing, wonderful, knowledgeable, strong woman who is the best realtor ever!! We have moved around so much and used others, and she is the top, #1! We have used her twice to buy and sell. Our friends have also used her on our recommendation. She will always take your calls, return calls, has your back and goes the extra mile on everything! She listens to your needs and finds the perfect home! We will always pick her! Thank you Holly!!

Seller review
Best Agent (and mom) Around!
over 1 year ago
Best Agent (and mom) Around!

Holly is the best agent there is. She is kind, thoughtful, and communicative. She advocates well for her clients and she got us under contract after just one weekend on the market. She is a pro at dealing with other agents, as well as her Type A, nagging daughter who sent perhaps one too many texts regarding the transaction :) I choose Holly as my agent, not only because she is my mom, but because she truly is the best agent around.

Seller review
Holly is attentive, informed, and personable
over 1 year ago
Holly is attentive, informed, and personable

Holly was amazing in timeliness, attentiveness, and knowing what needs to be done and when. She was always open to questions and explaining the options and paths forward. I always felt that I was able to make well informed decisions thanks to her consultation and judgement. She definitely paid attention to where I was and where I wanted to go and personalized her advice for me. I know for a fact I will be reaching out to Holly for my future moves and will definitely recommend her to others.

Seller review
Best realtor in Colorado!
almost 2 years ago
Best realtor in Colorado!

Holly is the best. I am always confident she’s going to do what’s best for me as a seller/buyer. She is very knowledgeable in her skill as a realtor! I would recommend her to everyone I know who is buying or selling their home!

1 - 12 of 42
© 2026 RateMyAgent