Erin's profile

Erin's reviews

  5  
Erin has 28 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Erin's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, well-prepared, reliable, responsive, proactive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
You will be in good hands with them!
almost 2 years ago
You will be in good hands with them!

"Fabulous experience with the entire Thomas Riddle team, and especially agent extraordinaire Erin Spalding! We both sold and bought with Erin and she really came through in every possible aspect. We had several curve balls that came up during the sale of our home. I can't say enough how comforting it was to have an agent that we trusted with such an important transition period in our lives - she handled everything with professionalism, ease, and her experience really shined through. She really did go above and beyond!! We highly recommend Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group and Erin, and would trust her again and again with any future real estate transactions. New Albany is a unique market and you want a firm and agent who know the area and know how to navigate this roller coaster of a market. You will be in good hands with them!"

Buyer review
Once again we have received 5 star service from Erin Spalding
about 2 years ago
Once again we have received 5 star service from Erin Spalding

Once again we have received 5 star service from Erin Spalding and the whole Thomas Riddle team. This is our third real estate transition with Erin and her team. We were able to purchase our dream home, under ask, and avoid multiple buyers. Her knowledge of the NA area is unmatched. Erin and her team made sure we knew what to expect during every point of the process and helped us stay on cop of all the different deadlines. They even send out a helpful email to help you switch over the utilities. We are hoping to be in this home for a very long time, but if we ever move again, we know we will use Erin and the Thomas Riddle team.

Buyer review
I would like to thank Erin Spalding
about 2 years ago
I would like to thank Erin Spalding

I would like to thank Erin Spalding for working with us from start to finish on finding us a home in the Columbus area to be near our grandchildren. It was a process as we had lived 40 years at our previous home, but she was there to guide us through all of it. She showed us many homes and was always just a phone call away to answer all our questions, texts, and emails. I highly recommend her as she is very professional and knowledgeable. Erin is a lovely person and a great realtor. Thanks for everything and the very best to you.

Buyer review
Fabulous experience with the entire Thomas Riddle team
about 2 years ago
Fabulous experience with the entire Thomas Riddle team

"Fabulous experience with the entire Thomas Riddle team, and especially agent extraordinaire Erin Spalding! We both sold and bought with Erin and she really came through in every possible aspect. We had several curve balls that came up during the sale of our home. I can't say enough how comforting it was to have an agent that we trusted with such an important transition period in our lives - she handled everything with professionalism, ease, and her experience really shined through. She really did go above and beyond!! We highly recommend Thomas Riddle Real Estate Group and Erin, and would trust her again and again with any future real estate transactions. New Albany is a unique market and you want a firm and agent who know the area and know how to navigate this roller coaster of a market. You will be in good hands with them!"

Buyer review
We had a first class experience working with Rob, Erin and the team
about 2 years ago
We had a first class experience working with Rob, Erin and the team

We had a first class experience working with Rob, Erin and the team at New Albany Realty from start to finish. They were able to ensure a seamless process on the sale of our current home and purchase of our next home in a competitive market. They truly made us feel like a priority and kept us informed every step along the way. We can't recommend them enough!

Seller review
Great team to work w
over 2 years ago
Great team to work w

Great team to work with and navigate the real estate transaction process!

Buyer review
Erin's proactive approach and attention to detail were instrumental
over 2 years ago
Erin's proactive approach and attention to detail were instrumental

I recently had the pleasure of working with Erin Spalding as our realtor in the search for and purchase of our new home, and I couldn't be more impressed with her professionalism, expertise, and dedication to ensuring a smooth and efficient process from start to finish. Erin's proactive approach and attention to detail were instrumental in helping us find our dream home quickly. She was always available to answer any questions or address any concerns we had making us feel supported and confident throughout the entire process. Her communication skills were exceptional, keeping us informed of new listings, scheduling viewings promptly, and negotiating on our behalf with skill and finesse. One of the most impressive aspects of working with Erin was her commitment to ensuring a super quick and seamless closing process. Thank you, Erin, for your outstanding service and for helping us achieve our new house goals

Seller review
Erin was amazing
over 2 years ago
Erin was amazing

Erin was amazing during the process of renovating and selling our home. Nearly immediate response time to any questions or concerns, and knowledge of which home improvement projects would garner the biggest win with buyers. She also had a team of contractors at the ready for fast improvements and repairs. We had multiple offers over asking and Erin made sure every step of the process went smoothly for us.

Seller review
I highly recommend Thomas | Riddle Realtors
about 3 years ago
I highly recommend Thomas | Riddle Realtors

I highly recommend Thomas | Riddle Realtors to anyone in the area who has a property to sell. Erin Spalding and Rob Riddle successfully helped me get my house sold in less than 5 weeks from my initial contact with Erin to the final closing, They understood my needs, offered open opinions/suggestions, and took care ofall the needed tasks while I was traveling abroad. Throughout the entire process, Erin was not only on top things but also very responsive (even with 10-12 hours oftime differences). In short, their services truly exceeded my expectations - i.e. achieving my objectives with minimum cost and quick turnaround time in a very professional manner!

Seller review
Wonderful  experience
over 3 years ago
Wonderful experience

Erin made the entire experience of listing and selling our home in New Albany wonderful and easy. From our initial meeting where we laid out our goals and dream scenario, she delivered on everything we hoped for in a swift sale, with multiple offers above ask price. Erin goes the extra step to be incredibly accessible for questions and support, even dropping off moving boxes to our home to help with our move. Erin, and the whole Thomas Riddle team, are who you should trust if you are looking to list your home successfully.

Seller review
Erin Spalding came highly recommended
almost 4 years ago
Erin Spalding came highly recommended

Erin Spalding came highly recommended to us by a neighbor and we could not have been more thrilled with our experience with her and the Thomas Riddle group. Erin took the time to understand exactly what we were looking for in a new home and brought a notable personal warmth to the relationship and experience as a whole. We loved how aggressive she was for us throughout the offer process, her responsiveness, and her constant guidance within a very chaotic market. Working with Erin was truly a pleasure, and we could not be more pleased.

Buyer review
Erin Spalding was an absolute pleasure to work with
about 4 years ago
Erin Spalding was an absolute pleasure to work with

Erin Spalding was an absolute pleasure to work with throughout the entire process of purchasing our first home. Her knowledge, communication, and responsiveness were all extremely valuable to us in helping us find the right home and getting our offer accepted in this tough market!

13 - 24 of 28
© 2026 RateMyAgent