Erica's profile

Erica's reviews

  5  
Erica has 20 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Continuous Follow Up was GREAT!
about 2 months ago
Continuous Follow Up was GREAT!

Erica had a big task in front of her. We had multiple liens and issues with our closing but Erica and her team were on top of it. It was stressful but she made it a good experience with all the communication.

Buyer review
Thorough and Detail-Oriented
5 months ago
Thorough and Detail-Oriented

Erica represented me on a for-sale-by-owner purchase and was incredibly thorough from start to finish. The sellers had a strong emotional bond with the property and were reluctant to sell due to the family memories connected to this property. She kept every detail organized and ensured the deal was solid and ready for closing. The property was a post-hurricane renovation from the 2024 storms and located in a co-op, which added extra layers of complexity. Erica anticipated those challenges, connected us with a title company equipped to handle a co-op closing properly, and guided the process all the way through to a successful close.

Buyer review
Knowledgeable Excellent Agent
5 months ago
Knowledgeable Excellent Agent

Erica helped me purchase a storm-damaged unit and expertly guided me through the complexities of the process. She made sure the transaction was advantageous for me as a buyer while also being thoughtful and fair to the seller, who was navigating a difficult situation after the storms. Erica also walked me through the city’s rebuilding requirements, ensuring I was well informed and set up for the best possible outcome with my renovation. I highly recommend her.

Seller review
hard-working
5 months ago
hard-working

did a great job in staying with some troublesome issues from the buyer and kept me informed.

Seller review
She is a PRO!
6 months ago
She is a PRO!

In this market, Port Charlotte, is imperative to have an agent that knows the law and the rules of Real Estate. Some one that is emotionally secure and mature to deal with all the emotions this market is bringing. I thank God for Erica. She was holding the entire transaction strong. I trusted her input, and she went the extra mile in this process. I appreciate her!!!. She is your Realtor!!!

Buyer review
Best Realtor in Florida !!!
8 months ago
Best Realtor in Florida !!!

My husband and I were quite impressed with Erica's knowledge and professionalism in real estate. She listened to our wants and needs in and guided us through the process of purchasing a villa in the Venice/Sarasota area. In a few days visit she showed us many options within our price range, from used to new. When we narrowed it down to two places, she would remember to ask the difficult questions that we would not have thought about. Erica also researched one of the properties further, because I had concern over a flood zone. Erica was thorough in every aspect. She is also very friendly and personable, while always looking out for our best interests. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a home in Florida.

Buyer review
Seamless Florida Home Purchase from Maine!
9 months ago
Seamless Florida Home Purchase from Maine!

We had the pleasure of working with Erica to purchase our seasonal home in Florida, and the experience was exceptional from start to finish. She immediately honed in on our specific needs and matched us with locations and properties that truly fit our lifestyle. Her in-depth knowledge of Florida communities and consistent updates on market conditions gave us confidence throughout the process. Her communication was always timely and professional, and she went above and beyond to ensure that we were well informed, even while managing the purchase from out of state. From guiding us through negotiations to handling the details with care, her expertise and attention to detail were evident at every step. We highly recommend Erica to anyone seeking a realtor who combines professionalism, local expertise, and a client-focused approach. She made what could have been a stressful process seamless, efficient, and ultimately rewarding.

Buyer review
Excellent
11 months ago
Excellent

From the second we said we’d like to buy our place, Erica was on it. She answered every question and concern we had honestly and responded to every call quickly.

Seller review
Erica was professional and absolutely amazing with our house sale.
12 months ago
Erica was professional and absolutely amazing with our house sale.

Erica was with us every step of the way, going above and beyond to make sure our closing went smoothly. She is very professional and dedicated to her clients. She is a full time realtor who is well versed in her profession. She gives great advise and tells you what you need to know, not what you just want to hear. I would highly recommend her.

Seller review
Commitment and Dedication from a great Realtor. Erica Smentowski
about 1 year ago
Commitment and Dedication from a great Realtor. Erica Smentowski

We are very thankful for the successful effort put in by our realtor Erica Smentowski to help us sell our hurricane damaged Longboat Key, Fl home. She went way beyond any expectations. Erica helped us get cleaning services and was willing to show the property when it did not have power or air conditionings at to show the property. She was very active and we appreciate her communications to keeping us encouraged and aware of any and all progress. Erica's expertise and dedication made the process seamless. We highly recommend her to anyone looking a reliable and trustworthy agent.

Buyer review
Helped us buy a slice of heaven
about 1 year ago
Helped us buy a slice of heaven

We had an exceptional experience working with Erica while purchasing our second home in Florida. She guided us through every step of the process, including navigating the unique requirements of a 55+ HOA and the challenges of a distressed property. Erica was knowledgeable, responsive, and detail-oriented—always making sure we were informed and supported. Her professionalism and calm demeanor made a complex transaction feel seamless. We’re grateful for her help and highly recommend her!

Buyer review
Great first home buying experience!
over 1 year ago
Great first home buying experience!

A lot of stress and questions come when buying your first home and Erica made their entire process as seamless as ever. She walked us through every part start to finish to ensured we were set up for success! She communicates well, is efficient with time and we will definitely be using her again if the time comes.

1 - 12 of 20
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent