Donna's profile

Donna's reviews

  5  
Donna has 29 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Donna's qualities as told by our client reviews: well-prepared, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Seller review
Professional, Dedicated and Knowledgeable
6 days ago
Professional, Dedicated and Knowledgeable

Donna Caloia is amazing, knowledgeable, trustworthy and was always available to answer any of my questions and concerns. She sold my house in one day. She stepped in and handled all that needed to get done, especially when I was on vacation. You won’t go wrong with choosing Donna as your agent, she’ll go above and beyond for you. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!

Seller review
Donna is your go to realtor. She works hard, communicates and does exactly what she says.
about 2 months ago
Donna is your go to realtor. She works hard, communicates and does exactly what she says.

From the moment I met Donna and went over all she and Keller Williams would do to sell my home, I knew, she was the one for me. Donna went over her plan in detail along with her marketing strategy to get my home sold and for the best price possible. She was also very open to any of my suggestions, which made me feel like she really care about my opinion. If Donna said she was going to do something, she did it immediately. I thought I was organized, but she was always a step ahead of me. We had an open house just two days after my home was listed and got four offers. I had not sold or bought a home in 10 years so I needed plenty of help and guidance. She answered all my questions honestly and helped guide me to make this complicated transition a reality. Because I was selling and buying at the same time, Donna help me keep things in perspective and remember to think logically not just emotionally. She was also great at recommending a plumber, a roofer and even a moving company. I trust her judgment and she is the reason I got full asking price for my home and negotiated the condo I purchased. Donna and her team kept me up to date , gave me lists of things I needed to do and made the closing of both properties incredibly smooth and on schedule. The best part is, there were no surprises!!!!! Love Donna Caloia and her Keller Williams team!! Extremely satisfied customer.

Buyer review
Hard working, excellent communicator and always has your best interest at heart.
about 2 months ago
Hard working, excellent communicator and always has your best interest at heart.

Donna helped negotiate the purchase of this beautiful condo. I knew the moment I saw it, that it was exactly what I wanted. Donna and her Keller Williams team helped me navigate the complexity of selling and purchasing a home. Donna helped me remember to think logically and not just emotionally. I could talk to her about all aspects of my purchase or concerns and she always answered me honestly. Donna and her team kept me up to date as we went a long and the closing was exactly as planned. I couldn’t be happier with Donna and her Keller Williams team. They are all truly the best at what they do!!! A big thank you to Donna for making this purchase a reality.

Seller review
Donna is an Angel
3 months ago
Donna is an Angel

It was a difficult time losing my father, then having to sell our family home. Donna was referred to me by someone at Christ Fellowship. Donna stepped in and too command of the whole situation. She listened to my concerns and fears. She addressed everything and made it all happen. I was able to get more for my home than I expected, and I believe it was all because of the diligence of Donna. There were a couple times I thought we were in trouble, but Donna came through like an angel and fixed everything. She even helped me move out the last few little things. She's a star!

Seller review
Highly recommend Donna!
5 months ago
Highly recommend Donna!

Donna spent time and gathered all the information about us, our community, and the surrounding area in order to market our home effectively. She was always available to answer questions and give us guidance. We appreciated her honesty and integrity. We would highly recommend her to anyone.

Seller review
Donna used a very professional approach from the first meeting. I was impressed with her explanation
8 months ago
Donna used a very professional approach from the first meeting. I was impressed with her explanation

The team sent regular summary reports, Donna was always present at showings with other realtors and that made me feel like someone (her) who really knew the property was there to give clarity for the Realtor and potential buyer. We took the property off market for awhile in order to complete the Re-Piping of the entire home. She had experience with the process and knew how long it would take for all the details.

Seller review
Donna did a great job!
8 months ago
Donna did a great job!

Donna did a great job helping me prep the house for sale and in determining price point. She was with me every step of the way!

Buyer review
Donna is exceptional - as a realtor and a person.
8 months ago
Donna is exceptional - as a realtor and a person.

I have worked with Donna for several years and she was tireless in showing me properties. She goes above and beyond to assist her clients and she certainly did with me.

Seller review
She is by far the best agent I know !!
8 months ago
She is by far the best agent I know !!

She goes beyond just selling your home ! She does everything , she is super efficient. Extremely caring. In constance communication with you. She is truly amazing! Truly knows her stuff. Phyllis Pribyl

Seller review
Highly recommended, best agent ever!
11 months ago
Highly recommended, best agent ever!

Donna was absolutely wonderful to work with and went above and beyond to get my house sold. Her level of experience and expertise in the industry was obvious from our first meeting. She put in an incredible amount of effort, worked tirelessly behind the scenes, and truly cared about making the sale happen as quickly and smoothly as possible. Her knowledge, dedication, and work ethic really stood out. Donna was always responsive, kept me informed throughout the process, and handled every detail with professionalism and confidence. Thanks to her hard work and persistence, my home sold quickly, and I couldn’t be happier with the outcome. I highly recommend Donna to anyone looking to sell their home. She is honest, committed, reliable, and someone you can truly trust to get the job done. I look forward to working with her again in the future when we decide to sell and buy again.

Buyer review
Exceptional Experience as First-Time Homebuyers
11 months ago
Exceptional Experience as First-Time Homebuyers

My husband and I had such a wonderful experience working with our realtor, Donna. As first-time homebuyers, the process felt overwhelming at times, but she made everything as easy and stress-free as possible. She was incredibly friendly, knowledgeable, and caring — always thorough, always patient, and never pushy. What stood out most was how she advocated for both sides with fairness and integrity. We felt supported every step of the way. We’re so grateful for her and would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Seller review
I highly recommend Donna
12 months ago
I highly recommend Donna

Donna will impress you with professionalism and knowledge of the housing market. She went above and beyond with her advice on how to prepare the property prior to the sale, in order to get the most money from my house. I felt very comfortable and supported throughout the process of her selling my property.

1 - 12 of 29
© 2026 RateMyAgent