Crystal's profile

Crystal's reviews

  5  
Crystal has 40 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Crystal's qualities as told by our client reviews: supportive, pleasant, dedicated, responsive, local expert, clear communication.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
This was the second home we have purchased with Crystal.
almost 2 years ago
This was the second home we have purchased with Crystal.

We had been searching for a home for almost a year. Crystal was patient and professional. She always answered texts and phone calls right away. She showed us properties without delay. If you are looking for a real estate professional, I highly recommend working with her!

Buyer review
Easy to work with
almost 2 years ago
Easy to work with

Crystal was easy to work with. When a problem was afoot, she stepped in and went above and beyond the call! Scheduling was never an issue. She responded promptly to text message and kept us informed as progress was made.

Seller review
She is very good at her job.
about 2 years ago
She is very good at her job.

She took care of everything long distance for me,the price was right and sold quickly.I would reccomend her any day.

Seller review
She works very hard and is very competent
about 2 years ago
She works very hard and is very competent

Crystal Gay is a very motivated real estate agent. She helped me around all the corners of this sale. I would recommend her to be your agent. Always returns calls and messages and just a great person to deal with.

Seller review
Knowledgeable and Nice!
about 2 years ago
Knowledgeable and Nice!

Excellent communication, smart and savvy person with a kind demeanor to put us at ease, always felt Crystal was in our corner. Would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a great agent.

Seller review
Superb Negotiator
about 2 years ago
Superb Negotiator

Because I was not in Idaho, I really appreciated Crystal’s willingness to negotiate alternative options for the buyers’ requests. She communicated with us quickly and offered some needed help. I highly recommend Crystal!

Seller review
Top notch realtor
over 2 years ago
Top notch realtor

I highly recommend crystal for a realtor was very helpful and on point and helpful getting my home sold in a quick time and shes very quick to respond to messages or questions thank u crystal for everything

Buyer review
If you don’t use her your nuts
over 2 years ago
If you don’t use her your nuts

She had my best interest totally at the front. She is No bullshit straight shooting and not afraid to say “I don’t know but I will get the answer”

Seller review
Very knowledgeable!
almost 3 years ago
Very knowledgeable!

Great experience overall. Helpful and knowledgeable about the property we were interested in and ended up buying.

Seller review
So helpful
almost 3 years ago
So helpful

Crystal was so wonderful to work with. She is very knowledgeable about the market. Crystal is quick and efficient with communication, and went above and beyond many times, always keeping me in the loop on things. I would highly recommend Crystal to anyone who is looking for an agent!

Buyer review
Friendly, Informative and Professional
almost 3 years ago
Friendly, Informative and Professional

These are the three words we would use to describe Crystal! We walked into her office on Tuesday morning and she was SO friendly and willing to tell us all about Orofino. We felt welcomed to the community and informed about how houses and properties we were looking at. She then took us to some on Wednesday and by that afternoon we had made an offer and it was accepted!!! Her knowledge of the process and her professionalism is certainly unmatched in this business! If you are looking for a realtor, look no further!!! You just found one!

Buyer review
Beyond just an agent!
almost 3 years ago
Beyond just an agent!

Are you after an agent that will just assist in the buying/selling of a home or would you rather have an agent that actually pounds ground, puts in the footwork to make sure every aspect is as smooth as it can be? Crystal was a joy to work with, be around and went above an beyond any agent we've ever worked with and this is our 4th home purchase. Do yourself a favor and look no further. This woman is actually amazing!!

25 - 36 of 40
© 2026 RateMyAgent