Craig's profile

Craig's reviews

  5  
Craig has 11 reviewsacross 8 different locations, showing 11.
Map view
Craig's qualities as told by our client reviews: clear communication, supportive, patient, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Craig goes above and beyond in every way
3 months ago
Craig goes above and beyond in every way

5 stars are not enough to describe one of the best experiences we had working with our agent Craig. The professionalism, attention and care Craig and his team offers to help you find your home is priceless!, we were blessed having him help us through this challenging experience on finding the right home for us. What truly set him apart was how personal and caring he was throughout our entire journey. He took time to understand what we were looking for, listened and answered all our questions with patience and we never felt rushed or pressured. His knowledge of the market is amazing and he went above and beyond to help us find the perfect home. We love his personality, attention and ideas which makes it even better when seeing homes along his side. So, if you are looking for an agent who is not only professional and skilled but also kind, attentive and truly invested in your happiness, I wholeheartedly recommend him. We are so grateful for his hard work and dedication helping us buy our beautiful home. Thank you Craig Eicher and the entire Toomey team. We love our home! The Moura Family.

Seller review
Sold at our first open house!
6 months ago
Sold at our first open house!

Craig helped me prepare my house to list and then went to work marketing it, ensuring that anyone interested in a home in my neighborhood would see it on every public-facing website. The result? Despite a solid buyers market and several similarly priced homes nearby, 20 people attended our first open house and three of them bid my asking price! Craig then helped navigate the inspection and appraisal processes. I have bought and sold many properties over the years and have worked with many real estate agents. None of them can hold a candle to Craig and the entire Chris Toomey team at Keller Williams.

Seller review
Great experience
about 1 year ago
Great experience

Craig, Chris and the whole team did a great job selling our house very quickly in a saturated market. Highly recommend them

Buyer review
Great Effort
over 1 year ago
Great Effort

Craig did a great job in walking me through the process. Being in Iowa, it took some extra steps to buy and help with the closing. He was always available to do things that I couldn't do.

Seller review
Yes it sold!
over 1 year ago
Yes it sold!

Craig and the entire Toomey Group were great in helping me navigate through a very stressful sale of my home. Craig was there every step of the way reassuring me everything would work out, and it did. I’m grateful for all the help and support I received . Thank you!

Seller review
Outstanding
about 2 years ago
Outstanding

Craig Eicher was patient and kind during the process and was very determined to make sure I was informed regarding all of my options as a seller. I would not hesitate to use the Toomey Group again for my real estate transactions. Thank you for your knowledge and professionalism.

Buyer review
Above and Beyond
over 2 years ago
Above and Beyond

We were coming from up north and didn't really know the local area very well. We met our agent Craig Eicher at a random open house we were going to. He was extremely knowledgeable, and we could see he had a level of professionalism that led us to choose him as our main agent. We never felt any pressure to buy and Craig and the team at Toomey were very supportive over months of us looking at different places. The entire team is very responsive and super helpful. We received A++ service and they even helped to align us with everything we would need for the closing as well as suggestions for future needs for the house. The Owner Chris Toomey was very helpful and supportive as well as Maria Romero in the office who helped manage the closing and really knows all the details of closing procedures and documents and answered all of our questions. The vast knowledge of this team and their experience really is outstanding! I can without hesitation, highly recommend everyone from the team. 🏆🏆🏆🏆🏆

Seller review
A stress less Experience
over 2 years ago
A stress less Experience

Working with Craig made it so easy to sale our house in a tough market. The Toomey Group got what I wanted for my childhood home and held my hand through the emotion of selling my home. I highly reccomend them as a real estate company that takes care of everything for you. Craig Eicher is amazing communicating and working your deal.

Seller review
Top-notch Real Estate Professionals
over 2 years ago
Top-notch Real Estate Professionals

First off, I live in NCarolina and sold a property in Jupiter, FL. From the start of signing with The Toomey Group at Keller Williams Realty; I knew this Team was my real estate firm (can, I say "Excellent!!"). They provided an in depth analysis of the market area and recent comps; and explained everything so well without strong sales tactics or intimidation (which is important to me). I did not want a Real Estate Firm that came across like a used car salesman. They were professional and organized with great communications throughout the process. Additionally, they provided superb attention to detail and was always willing to go the extra mile (and they literally did more than once) until the final transaction was complete. My agent was Craig Eicher and he is so awesome to work with especially for my 'high strung' personality type (he is very professional and calming; with top-notch integrity). Yes, there were other awesome Team members behind the scenes assisting with the sale of the condo and I'm so grateful for them too. If ever in the market again, Chris Toomey and Team at Keller William Realty will have my business again and again. Highly recommend!!!

Buyer review
Very helpful
about 3 years ago
Very helpful

Craig listened well to what I “discovered” over the proceeds of looking for a home. He was patient and always in my corner. He offered helpful observations along the way.

Seller review
Amazing Service
about 3 years ago
Amazing Service

Craig was great about finding exactly what we were looking for! His patience was exceptional and his commitment was impressive! Highly recommend contacting him when selling your property or finding a new one!

1 - 11 of 11
© 2026 RateMyAgent