Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  5  
Colleen has 19 reviewsacross 10 different locations, showing 12.
about 2 months ago
Excellent communicator

We had a great experience working with Colleen. She was always available, flexible with our schedule, and went above and beyond to show us homes in multiple neighborhoods. Her responsiveness and dedication made the entire process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend!

2 months ago
Proactive guidance, attentive, and a pleasure to work with

Colleen was an absolute dream to work with! She was honest and transparent about every property, never hesitated to get hands-on inspecting crawl spaces and other structural details. She offered multiple options that perfectly suited our needs, eagerly took us to new developments, and gathered all the details about each house more than we could ask for. Truly a go-getter who went above and beyond, she was professional, thorough, and genuinely kind!

5 months ago
Fast & thorough!

We decided to simultaneously sell our home and our property, and purchase a new home. With Colleen‘s guidance, we were able to make a successful offer on our new home, and we had a full asking price offer on our current home within 48 hours. My husband was overseas during the sale of our home, and there were some hiccups along the way. Colleen basically held my hand, and made what could’ve been a bad situation work out in the end. I will forever be grateful for her. Colleen is knowledgeable, determined and willing to fight for her clients. We now have a forever agent & also a forever friend.

5 months ago
Outstanding Realtor

I have know Colleen for some time and she is wonderful. She took ownership of the process, was extremely detail oriented, and then followed up with every step following closing. I cannot recommend her strongly enough. She knows the market extremely well. Thoroughly recommend her.

6 months ago
Colleen was randomly paired with us by Zillow and we truly couldn't have gotten paired with anyone b

Colleen was randomly paired with us by Zillow and we truly couldn't have gotten paired with anyone better. We made a spontaneous decision to purchase our new home and sell our current home at the same time, and she represented us on both transactions. We accepted an offer on our home 48 hours after it was listed!! She held my hand through this entire process - and advocated for us every step of the way. We had some hang-ups with our sale that could have entirely derailed my moving process but she saved the day by negotiating buyer possession of my new house & also staying on top of my buyers' team so that we could close before I needed to close on my purchase. My husband was overseas for most of our process and she definitely made me feel like I wasn't doing it alone - right down to being at the closing table with me. We couldn't recommend her enough & would absolutely work with her again!

7 months ago
Outstanding Realtor & Service Provided

From day one Colleen Schreiber gave me the service and attention I was looking for in a realtor. I have purchased many homes and rental properties in my life and Colleen is at the top of my list when it is time to buy again. My lender was slow on getting some documents over for the closing, Colleen stepped in and made the bump in the road a smooth one. Five Star Service. Five Star Attitude and Five Star Knowledge is what you get from Colleen Schreiber.

7 months ago
She’s the best!

Highly knowledgeable realtor who listened and found us the right house.

7 months ago
Colleenn Schreiber - Pinehurst

Colleen was professional, knowledgeable and extremely dedicated to helping us reach our goals. She is genuine and honest at all times. A true 5-star real-estate asset to the Pinehurst Community!!!! Thank you Colleen!

7 months ago
Colleen went above and beyond our expectations

Colleen went above and beyond our expectations. She is unbelievable at navigating any, and all situations. She had our home under contract within 24 hours. Such a pleasure to work with.

10 months ago
It was a pleasure working with Colleen as we went about the process of finding our new home

It was a pleasure working with Colleen as we went about the process of finding our new home. She’s very professional and personable. She’s highly knowledgeable in all aspects of the real estate market in the Pinehurst/Southern Pines area. She asked the right questions which helped her focus and zero in on properties that clearly fit our needs. She is familiar with contractors and tradesmen in the area making it easy for us to identify the correct people to perform the work needed to customize our home.

1 - 12 of 19
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent