Colleen's profile

Colleen's reviews

  4.6  
Colleen has 33 reviewsacross 16 different locations, showing 12.
over 3 years ago
"Colleen's depth of experience in the Pequannock real estate market combined with her reputation for

"Colleen's depth of experience in the Pequannock real estate market combined with her reputation for professionalism and speaking honestly/plainly with her clients were very important to us. We were also impressed by her responsiveness and market knowledge. She facilitated the process at every step and communicated clearly to us in terms of any expectations or timelines. Colleen was invaluable at every stage of the sale - from the pre-listing consult, to the market research to set the listing price, to the open house, the follow-up showings, the contract negotiations, and the closing. She was accessible and available to us from start to finish with knowledge and professionalism that were absolutely critical to the smoothness of our home sale."

over 3 years ago
"Colleen was very profession in her presentation

"Colleen was very profession in her presentation. I knew immediately that she had the experience and expertise to make the right decision about our home. She had researched the comps in my area and presented me with all the information along with her recommendations. She was ahead of all issues that arose with the sale and was ready with how best to respond to them. She worked hand in had with all people we hired during the process of selling, keeping everyone informed, answering questions and moving things along when ever, and however, she could. I could not recommend her more highly."

over 3 years ago
"I would recommend Colleen A

"I would recommend Colleen A. McMahon to anyone who needs to sell their home. I think they will be quite satisfied. Colleen was very professional and always available to answer our questions. She priced our house fairly and gave us advice on how to make things work for the sale."

over 3 years ago
"Colleen McMahon worked hard on selling our property

"Colleen McMahon worked hard on selling our property. Her knowledge of the town and paitence prevailed. Today's Market isn't alway easy without some bumps and Colleen helped to get us thru."

almost 4 years ago
Colleen helped us navigate this tough market

Colleen helped us navigate this tough market. She understood what we were looking for and was patient and persistent until we found our dream home. Her local knowledge is invaluable. It was a pleasure to work with her through every step of this process!

almost 4 years ago
I felt Colleen went above and beyond

I felt Colleen went above and beyond. She was on top of everything and helped us first time home buyers every step of the way! She is kind, trustworthy, and answered every question we had - and we had a lot! I would recommend her to anyone and everyone, hands down.

almost 4 years ago
Colleen McMahon was extremely helpful and patient

Colleen McMahon was extremely helpful and patient. This was my first time selling a house, so I had many questions. She answered them all professionally and completely. She made the whole process easy. I would recommend Colleen to all my friends and family.

over 4 years ago
Because of a previous selling experience, I knew Colleen was the best possible choice to market my h

Because of a previous selling experience, I knew Colleen was the best possible choice to market my home. She is the ultimate professional. She is also the Energizer bunny! Colleen took care of everything. I had very little to do except prepare for my move and she even helped with that. I have used Colleen before and have recommended to my friends and colleagues. They have also used her. I couldn't be happier with the performance of Colleen A, McMahon.

over 4 years ago
Colleen came to the house and sat with my mother for a long time to insure she was comfortable and r

Colleen came to the house and sat with my mother for a long time to insure she was comfortable and ready to move ahead. She allowed my mom to talk about her memories of living in town which also made my mother feel at ease. She provided good info on the sale tactic and expectations along with input on how to prep the house for showing. Sold it over-asking in no time. All around good job from start to finish.

1 - 12 of 33
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent