Cathy's profile

Cathy's reviews

  5  
Cathy has 10 reviewsacross 6 different locations, showing 10.
over 3 years ago
Cathy is an awesome realtor

Cathy is an awesome realtor. She helped us sell our property. She is very professional and prompt. With her managing things we didn't have to worry about anything at all.

over 3 years ago
We absolutely loved working with Cathy! She sold our home and helped us buy our forever home

We absolutely loved working with Cathy! She sold our home and helped us buy our forever home. She is extremely knowledgeable, patient, friendly, very direct and straight to the point. Every time we called with a new request or concern she was on top of answering or at least finding the answer for us in a timely manner. She made closing a breeze and even went above and beyond with some requests that were beyond her control. She took charge and advocated for my husband and I to get it corrected. We will always highly recommend her for all of your home buying & selling needs. Thank you again Cathy!

almost 4 years ago
I owned my sister's home in Valrico, but live out of state

I owned my sister's home in Valrico, but live out of state. When my sister died unexpectedly, I needed someone to help me through the process of readying the home for sale and selling it without me needing to be on site. I turned to Cathy, and things could not have gone more smoothly. She helped me to understand the local housing market and to come up with a sale strategy and a price (that was much greater than I was expecting). She also helped to identify inspection services, painters, cleaners, donation services, junk haulers, landscapers, roofers, etc. to get the home in shape to sell. We finished getting the home ready on a Saturday, held an open house the next day, and were under contract the day after that for a price above the asking price. She then helped me weather the closing process, and four weeks later I received the funds. I recommend Cathy without reservation!

almost 4 years ago
Cathy is so honest with her clients! She asks all the right questions to really get to know you

Cathy is so honest with her clients! She asks all the right questions to really get to know you. She makes sure you get what you want. Always has as much time as you need and welcomes questions you may have.my entire family loves her as she makes it a family affair.Her honesty and commitment are truly outstanding. I trust her which is the most important factor.

about 4 years ago
Cathy was friendly and extremely professional in facilitating the purchase of our condo

Cathy was friendly and extremely professional in facilitating the purchase of our condo. She was very knowledgeable and guided us through every step of making an offer, purchasing and closing. We are from out of state and Cathy was one step ahead of us in scheduling contractors for estimates within our time frame. We are so grateful that we worked with Cathy and would not hesitate to recommend her as a real estate agent.

over 4 years ago
Cathy performs all of her real estate responsibilities perfectly and has been a life saver for me as

Cathy performs all of her real estate responsibilities perfectly and has been a life saver for me as a recent Florida resident. She was professional in all real estate functions, understanding to my wants and needs in a new home and her local knowledge of the area and any household services was outstanding. Cathy goes above and beyond for her clients. I would definitely recommend Cathy McCarthy to anyone looking for a new home!

over 4 years ago
Cathy was an excellent realtor

Cathy was an excellent realtor. She was very knowledgeable and friendly and helped me out as the seller in any questions I might of had. I would definitely recommend her and would use her in the future if need be.

over 4 years ago
Cathy was amazing to work with

Cathy was amazing to work with. Listed the home and within 24 hours had a bid. Very knowledgeable and helpful through all of this!! I was long distance and she was on top of everything.

over 4 years ago
It would be impossible to find a better realtor

It would be impossible to find a better realtor. Words cannot express Cathy’s talent but I’ll try. I think one of her best qualities, is her ability to match you to the inventory available. She knew my likes and needs and showed me a variety of homes that matched me. In this very difficult buyers market she was able to find me a home, help me make an offer that was accepted, find financing, find contractors for upgrades and all that within 6 weeks time! Talk about pulling rabbits out of hats! But honestly it wasn’t luck it was good ole-fashioned hard work, caring and expertise.

1 - 10 of 10
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent