Casey's profile

Casey's reviews

  5  
Casey has 9 reviewsacross 3 different locations, showing 9.
over 3 years ago
"Casey did a wonderful job of negotiating and handling our sale

"Casey did a wonderful job of negotiating and handling our sale. She made a otherwise difficult process smooth and worry free. We would definitely use again. Caseys knowledge of the island was very helpful. She did a great job of guiding us on all of the decisions that had to be made during the process"

over 3 years ago
"It was great to work with Casey Stearns because of her knowledge of Pine Island and that is importa

"It was great to work with Casey Stearns because of her knowledge of Pine Island and that is important when buying in an area like that. She was very responsive and quick to answer any questions we had. I would highly recommend Casey if you are thinking of buying on Pine Island and to be honest I would recommend her for any real estate endeavors you may have. It shows that Casey truly enjoys her profession."

over 4 years ago
"We recently sold our vacation home on Pine Island in Florida, and Casey Stearns was our agent

"We recently sold our vacation home on Pine Island in Florida, and Casey Stearns was our agent. I believe we saw her name on a "for sale" sign in our neighborhood, and I contacted her. We met with her a few months before we decided to sell. She was very knowledgeable and helpful in explaining the market to us so that we felt confident that we would have a successful sale. We met again with Casey before we decided to sell. Once the decision was made, Casey was there with the right information and advice every step of the way. What might have been a stressful experience turned out to be a very comfortable one. If we ever have the need for a real estate agent in Southwest Florida again, we would love to work with her."

over 4 years ago
"Working with someone who was knowledgeable about the area and market while also being trustworthy a

"Working with someone who was knowledgeable about the area and market while also being trustworthy and dependable were paramount for us when choosing an agent. We had high expectations going in and Casey Stearns exceeded those. Casey was amazing to work with. We have bought and sold a number of houses and this was by far the smoothest transaction we have had. Casey is incredibly knowledgeable and prepares her clients for what to expect at every stage of the process. She is a proactive communicator who goes above and beyond to close the deal. We highly recommend Casey Stearns and look forward to working with her again."

about 5 years ago
"This home had been our homestead for 38 years and Casey was very sensitive to the sentiments in our

"This home had been our homestead for 38 years and Casey was very sensitive to the sentiments in our hearts and how difficult it was to make this transition. Her attention to detail is so impressive! She was with the photographer and home inspector to ensure they were doing their part correctly. More importantly she stayed in close contact with the buyers agent in Colorado and kept us up to date on the sale of that home as well. Casey made every minute of this process enjoyable! She is the realtor that every seller should have the pleasure of working with. She makes it happen from contract to closing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Job well done! Everything went so perfectly. Loved the online advertising and photography used. Very professional and always communicating!!"

over 5 years ago
"Casey put her heart and soul in this sale and closing, with her positive attitude we both knew we w

"Casey put her heart and soul in this sale and closing, with her positive attitude we both knew we were waiting for that special buyer and she knew from her first meeting with them. Casey was on top of every aspect during entire procedure to be sure all went smooth with both buyer and seller. Her determination and relentless hard work is what made this sale happen and she has developed a sixth sense on marketing unusual and unique properties, I see her excelling in this area in her career."

over 5 years ago
"I hired Casey, not the broker, she knows the product and does it full time

"I hired Casey, not the broker, she knows the product and does it full time. This was a tough contract that she negotiated while on a holiday. She’s good! A pro in less than a year...she will own that island I only deal with agents that work full time, and when I hire them they better represent me and not the buyer. Casey Stearns is a pro that does both!"

1 - 9 of 9
© 2026 RateMyAgent