Cary's profile

Cary's reviews

  5  
Cary has 11 reviewsacross 4 different locations, showing 11.
almost 2 years ago
Cary Stewart-you want her in your corner

Cary Stewart was knowledgeable, patient and the consummate professional in guiding us through our house buying experience. She was attentive, she listened and she had our best interests at heart. Above all she is kind and caring which for me are crucial qualities in a real estate agent.

over 2 years ago
Beyond her job performance

Market knowledge proved to be excellent, though market had turned sour, she stuck to her selling price and we succeeded in getting our price. She was helpful in more than one way; maintained open house every weekend, many times helped in preparing for view, was easy to communicate and finally she has best professional profile. I feel so lucky to have her as my agent.

almost 3 years ago
Excellent!

Cary helped up sell some property in Florida that my husband’s father had purchased many years ago. After both parents passed away, we had to figure out how to deal with getting it ready to sell. We are in Indiana, so logistically, not an easy task for us. Cary helped us with the deed, finding us a lawyer, and literally just helping us with every task we needed to get this lot sold! Thank you, Cary! Could not have done it without your help!

almost 3 years ago
Simply the Best!

Cary knows Heritage Landing and Punta Gorda. She knew what the market was, what price to list at and what price to counter at after we got an offer. She kept us updated on the process every step of the way. She is extremely helpful in finding resources for everything from free boxes to dealing with the title company and everything in-between. She is so kind and pleasant to deal with, Cary makes a stressful experience easy. Ultimately, she sold our home quickly and for a price we were very happy with!

almost 3 years ago
Very very comfortable and professional experience!!

We met Cary a few years ago when we first started coming to the Burnt Store area. We were out exploring and stopped at an open house that Cary was hosting. She was so friendly and gave us so much useful information about the area. Before we left we had her contact information and her husband’s information and he became the person who helped look after our boat! Over the years Cary has kept a watch for something she thought we would like. We had looked with her at places we had found recently. Then when we asked about another house she offered to put together a list of different places she thought we would like. She was right - we actually liked them all! She showed us a range of sizes and layouts. We chose one she had actually wanted us to see a few months before but we didn’t look at that time. Thank goodness it was still available! Between circumstances and Cary’s amazing help we were in the house 3 weeks after signing the contract. In nearly 40 years of marriage we had only moved once and that was across our small town! Cary had lots of connections and resources that made the move and set up from another state as easy as possible!! She has continued to check on us and offer suggestions for contractors and such. EXP, Cary’s company, was wonderful in helping to set up utilities and such. We can’t imagine this transition going any more smoothly! We would DEFINITELY recommend Cary and use her again ourselves! Thank you Cary for navigating us into this next phase of life!! John and Kathy Wright

almost 3 years ago
Outstanding agent!

Cary Stewart goes above and beyond with her knowledge of the property and surrounding area. She’s so kind and thoughtful. Cary reviewed the home inspection and helped negotiate things that needed to be fixed. Excellent communication through entire process and always made us feel comfortable with an out of state purchase. Highly recommend Cary.

about 3 years ago
Exceeded our expectations

Cary is always professional, caring and wanting the best for her clients. She stays in touch with updates throughout the process

over 3 years ago
Excellent customer service

Cary has excellent knowledge of our market. She communicates and keeps everything moving. I would recommend Cary to anybody looking for a house in southwest Florida.

over 3 years ago
Outstanding experience!

Overall experience was outstanding! Carey is extremely knowledgeable and was very helpful throughout our home search. She provided valuable feedback along the way to assist us in making an educated decision when purchasing our home. Carey communicated with us regularly providing us with ongoing information and was always available to answer questions and provide us with the referrals we needed. Her Knowledge of the market, effective communication and outstanding professionalism is unmatched by any other. I highly recommend Carey, you will not be disappointed!

over 3 years ago
Our experience

We had the pleasure of working with Cary Stewart on the purchase of our home in Heritage Landing. She was very helpful, professional and knowledgeable about the community and the Punta Gorda area. Cary helped us throughout the entire process, provided us with good advice on mortgage resources, as well as, home inspectors and people to help with the little repairs our property needed. We found the entire process to be very easy and would recommend Cary to our friends.

over 3 years ago
Sale of a home in Punta Gorda in Florida

It was an absolute pleasure working with Cary! The process was seamless from beginning to end. Throughout the process, Cary was kind, patient, knowledgeable and professional! A pleasant and successful experience.

1 - 11 of 11
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent