Carol's profile

Carol's reviews

  5  
Carol has 14 reviewsacross 13 different locations, showing 12.
over 2 years ago
Amazing Experience

Working with Carol was the best! She made everything easy for us as first time homebuyers. Carol takes the time to research homes and comps, and walked us through every step of the home buying process along the way. We also had a blast looking at different homes with Carol. She has a great eye for all of the little details and had our best interest in mind throughout our search. We would recommend Carol to anyone looking for an agent!

over 2 years ago
Excellence

Carol was so helpful and knowledgable during the listing and sale of my mother’s home. Bringing years of experience to the process, her warm kindness and confidence helped create a sense of ease and trust. Carol went above and beyond as she helped us through every step. I would recommend her for your real estate needs!

over 2 years ago
Carol Shear - No one else will do.

I met Carol 8 years ago at an open house. After talking for a couple of hours I had her help us buy a new home. She has now sold 2 of our houses and helped us purchase 3, Carol was professional in every way. She guided us through the process. The homes she found for us were exactly what we were looking for. Carol became a friend, a confidant and a trusted advisor. She cared. We decided to build in a different city and Carol was with us every step of the way. Even now, 3 months after we moved in she is still helping us work through some problems caused by the builder. Do I recommend Carol? A resounding yes.

almost 3 years ago
We’ve got this!

Carol worked so hard for us, marketing our home using years of experience and providing advice and support along the way. She always kept us informed, which was greatly appreciated. Her significant experience really shined when negotiating a multiple offer scenario. And she does it all with great care and a sense of humor too!

almost 3 years ago
A great agent to work with

I moved from Toledo. I know Carol for last so many years. She had been my agent and helped me in at least 5 transactions. She is one of the best agent I have come across and has become a great friend. She is well organized, absolutely professional, and gets the job done. I will recommend her strongly anytime without any hesitation. Wishing her all the best.

about 3 years ago
Dynamic realtor

I had such a good experience with Carol Shear when she helped find me my home 8 years ago that I kept in touch with her knowing that when I retired I would move back to Cincy and would need her sell my house. Carol is awesome. She puts your needs first , she cares , she knows real estate and knows how to guide you thru the process. She even helped me clean my house , what realtor does that!! I knew I could trust Carol to sell my house . Trust is what made me choose Carol to begin with . I met her at an open house and after talking with her I asked her to help find me a home . We clicked , and I felt I could trust her to the job I needed her to do . Carol is one impressive realtor , if you need to sell or buy , put your trust in Carol , you won’t be disappointed .

about 3 years ago
Knowledgeable and Professional

Carol was up to date on the listings in the areas we were looking at. She is always professional and and gracious with us and other realtors when we run into them viewing a house. She makes house viewing fun, which isn't always easy to do. We are repeat customers and would use her again in a heart beat.

about 6 years ago
I like everything about Carol! Carol was there for us when we had no idea what we were doing

I like everything about Carol! Carol was there for us when we had no idea what we were doing. We approached her and said we needed to buy a house ASAP in a housing market where houses sell quickly. Well, we were in contract within two weeks! She worked extremely hard to be there for us whenever we needed her, even late at night. She gave us honest opinions about houses we looked at, was as responsive as one could be working as hard as she does, and always made us smile throughout the process. Thanks again, Carol!

about 6 years ago
Carol is an A+ realtor! I previously used her as a buyer, this time I was selling my home

Carol is an A+ realtor! I previously used her as a buyer, this time I was selling my home. As a first time seller I had lots of anxiety about various steps in the process. Carol explained the steps and possible scenarios in detail and made me feel more comfortable and also confident in the process overall. I will certainly hire Carol for any future buying/selling needs. She is wonderful!

over 6 years ago
I met Carol about 12 years ago she helped me find my first home (condo)

I met Carol about 12 years ago she helped me find my first home (condo). She is very professional and extremely helpful. Would highly recommend for all first time buyers and beyond or selling your home. She explained the process thoroughly and very detail oriented. I reached out to Carol again this year 2019 to help sell my condo. Again she walked me through the process and explained each documents to me step by step. She gave recommendations on what to do to get the house ready to sell. Carol listed my condo on Thursday afternoon of November 15, 2019. She had an open house on Saturday November 18 and Sunday November 19. On Sunday November 19th we had 4 offers with full asking price. With all that being said we closed on the condo on December 20th 2019. She is genuine and hardworking and I would truly recommend her to anyone. If I plan to sell my house I will be reaching out to her again. Thank you Carol and Kathryn!! Ed & Dao W.

over 6 years ago
We absolutely loved working with Carol! She quickly became like family to us

We absolutely loved working with Carol! She quickly became like family to us. She helped us find our first home with everything that we had asked for. Her enthusiasm for her career shines through her work and we will miss her. We will definitely recommend her to friends and family.

over 6 years ago
My husband and I first met Carol at an open house we were just browsing

My husband and I first met Carol at an open house we were just browsing. We immediately hit it off and knew we wanted to work with her in the sale of our home. From the get go, Carol has been responsive, flexible, and knowledgeable. She is honest and patient. We never felt pressure on our decisions. From selling to buying all within just 3 months!! I highly recommend!!

1 - 12 of 14
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent