Carly's profile

Carly's reviews

  5  
Carly has 10 reviewsacross 5 different locations, showing 10.
Map view
Buyer review
Above and Beyond
6 months ago
Above and Beyond

Carly’s knowledge of the area and benefits of west coast south Florida living definitely exceeded our expectations. She is a hands on gem of a realtor . Her super power is helping create a smooth transition for both the buyer and the seller. I highly recommend her !

Seller review
A review of my real estate agent
10 months ago
A review of my real estate agent

Carly was very professional, efficient, polite and always got back to me very quickly with any question I had. I would recommend her highly for anyone looking to buy or sell their property.

Seller review
Carly is amazing
11 months ago
Carly is amazing

She is very detailed oriented & goes above & beyond. The best!

Buyer review
Carly: Our Magician
11 months ago
Carly: Our Magician

It’s a crazy story but true! We came to Naples for a two day visit and left with a new home. Carly met us in her office and provided us with a detailed understanding of Naples and the type of homes in our budget. She showed us four communities and was very conscious of our needs. Once home in Atlanta, she sent videos to help us make our decision. We could not have navigated this long-distance process without her keen eye and attention to detail. She was a constant go between with our builder and ourselves. When we were in the final stages of negotiating our deal, she represented us and somehow always got us what we wanted. She was always so quick to get us an answer whatever our request! My wife and I called her our magician! We are very thankful to have worked with Carly and now, settling in after our first visit just two months ago, are very pleased with our decision. Thank you Carly for working so hard to get us to paradise so quickly!

Buyer review
I Highly recommend working with Carly Mansell for all your real estate needs!!
about 1 year ago
I Highly recommend working with Carly Mansell for all your real estate needs!!

Carly was truly wonderful from the start, went above and beyond and is still helping me sort through some minor issues with the HOA and warranty company any question or problem carly was there to help resolve.Carly is also very professional and very well dressed with an amazing personality.I will definitely refer people looking to buy or sell in the Naples area to her.

Seller review
Above and beyond the call of duty!!
about 1 year ago
Above and beyond the call of duty!!

There are not enough words to describe how great the effort that Carly gave in trying to complete the selling of my home. Due to many problems caused by the buyer, Carly constantly had to change closing dates and worked very hard to finalize the sale. Previous to selling my house, Carly did her very best to find my daughter a rental in Naples. I have dealt with Realtors in the past but none could compare to her efforts. She would be an asset to anyone she works. We wish her the absolute best for her upcoming wedding in October.

Seller review
Best realtor in SW FL
about 1 year ago
Best realtor in SW FL

Carly helped us purchase our home and place it on the market years later. Carly is absolutely wonderful and goes above and beyond.

Buyer review
Very knowledgeable with the existing market, and our area.
about 1 year ago
Very knowledgeable with the existing market, and our area.

Great to work with both buying and selling. She was in contact with us daily updating the market and our properties. A delight to work with. Ms. Mansell is a true value to the real estate profession.

Buyer review
Above and beyond with customer service
about 1 year ago
Above and beyond with customer service

Carly was very helpful and extremely knowledgeable about the housing market. She went above and beyond with getting my house ready to sell and it sold in a timely matter. She is very easy to work with, and made the moving and selling a lot less stressful. I will definitely hire her again and recommend her to anyone looking for a real estate agent.

Buyer review
Carly was a rockstar in her approach with my wife and I as we looked for the perfect home in Naples,
about 3 years ago
Carly was a rockstar in her approach with my wife and I as we looked for the perfect home in Naples,

Carly was a rockstar in her approach with my wife and I as we looked for the perfect home in Naples, FL. To make matters more difficult, we were looking for a second home so we were not always available to physically be at an open houses, but Carly completely understood what we wanted and was able to let us know if various options met our expectations. Needless to say, we found our perfect home and couldn't be happier. Do not hesitate to reach out to Carly!

1 - 10 of 10
© 2026 RateMyAgent