Carla Casey

Carla Casey

NAR: SL342786
  •   5   (10 reviews)

About Carla

It is my goal to make the home buying and selling process as seamless as possible every step of the way. I love helping my clients find the perfect home to make their most treasure memories!

Carla's reviews

  5  
Carla has 10 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 6.
Review Carla
almost 2 years ago
Best agent we've ever had, and we've had a few!

We recently sold 3 properties, and had multiple real estate agents, some okay, some terrible, some so bad we fired them. We thought they were all like that; used car salesmen with houses. Carla was completely the opposite. She showed us several homes making herself available on weekends when we could get away from work. She was always available by phone or text. Her advice was priceless. She had insight to the seller and the market which she honestly shared with us. She is smart, market savvy and was genuinely interested in finding us our new 'home,' which she did. She has a great sense of humor and put up with our ignorant questions and our jokes. We wanted to adopt her. I couldn't recommend her more highly. 5 stars isn't enough.

almost 3 years ago
Carla Casey is Amazing

Carla Casey was everything we were looking for in a realtor – hard working, a good listener, thorough, knowledgeable, and available. As a resident of Riverview, she is knowledgeable of the area and surrounding areas and is up to date on the new subdivisions being built. She listened to what we were looking for and understood our needs as a family. She scouted out neighborhoods and houses for us. She lined up viewings, took note of what we liked and didn’t like, and then tweaked the search. She was available throughout the process of finding and buying the house AND still answered our calls after we bought our house. Whenever we reached out, she made us feel important and that we could ask any question. Her advice was sound and realistic which helped us make smart decisions. When we had hiccups with the closing of the other house, she worked with the other less experienced realtor and made it happened. She knows what she is doing and gets the job done. With her help we did find a house, but more than that, we found our home. She is a gem to work with because she makes connections with her clients. I wholeheartedly recommend Carla Casey.

over 3 years ago
Professional, proactive and responsive

I sold one home and purchased another with Carla's help. From our initial conversation, she was professional, thorough and on top of everything. She made a complicated situation easier by anticipating and heading of problems, communicating clearly, and working around holidays, scheduling conflicts and other obstacles. Carla knows the local market well and took the time to learn about what I wanted to accomplish. Highly recommend!

over 3 years ago
Smooth home sale thanks to Carla Casey

When we decided to sell our house, we were in the process of building a new home in another town 6 hours away, as well as trying to find a rental there and plan a long-distance move. In addition, we had a newborn and a toddler, so it was a lot to balance. Carla was truly exceptional and from the moment I met her I knew I wanted to work with her. She was so professional, organized, and she helped us work through all the details to sell our home smoothly. Carla truly knows the market and made great recommendations for us. She had multiple offers for us within 2 days of listing and was able to negotiate amazing terms for a quick close. Her kindness and professionalism didn’t end there; she also helped us with coordinating final clean-up after our movers came and some last-minute furniture donations. She really is the best and I highly recommend her to anyone who wants to work with a true professional for their real estate needs.

about 4 years ago
Amazing Service and Professionalism

Carla was incredibly professional and responsive in our quest to sell our first home. As first time home owners and subsequently first time home sellers, she aptly guided us throughout the process and made the contracting and closing stages as seamless as possible. I would highly recommend Carla for anyone looking to buy or sell a home in the Tampa Bay area!

about 4 years ago
Best of the best in Tampa Bay!

I can’t say enough nice things about Carla and the home buying experience she delivered on for me and my family. Carla quickly identified a home in a neighborhood we had been eyeing for some time. We had to move quick in this competitive market. Carla went right to work positioning us for the best opportunity to get this home. There were multiple offers and several negotiations. With Carla’s invaluable market knowledge and effective ability to communicate our desire to own this home on our behalf, we got our dream home. I wouldn’t recommend anyone else if you are looking for a seamless process and someone that will give you the best opportunity to get the house of your dreams in this market.

Show all 10 reviews

Carla's properties

Carla has 1 property for sale and sold 1 property in the last 12 months, showing 2, sorted by most recent activity

SoldFeb 24, 2026
$345,000
517 Royal Ridge Street
Brandon FL 33594
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS SUBURBAN TAMPA and SMITH & ASSOCIATES REAL ESTATE
Pending
$462,000
2412 Durant Road
Valrico FL 33596
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of KELLER WILLIAMS SUBURBAN TAMPA
Show all 2 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent