Carissa Sutter

  •   5   (2 reviews)

About Carissa

Carissa is a Real Estate Agent at Red Door Real Estate Wny Llc. They have 2 verified reviews with an average rating of 5 stars. They currently have 10 active property listings and 12 sold property listings over the past 12 months worth $3,041,000.

Carissa's reviews

  5  
Carissa has 2 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 2.
Review Carissa
about 2 years ago
The BEST Realtor!

Stepping into the home buying process was stressful from the get go. We initially had another realtor to start who was nowhere near as helpful as Carissa and we are so happy that we were connected to her. Everyone made it seem like using a VA Loan would make our process 100x worse but Carissa came in and reassured us that with her own experience that we had nothing to worry about & she was 1,000% right! From start to finish, Carissa has gone above and beyond to help us find our perfect home. She has not only been professional and respectful but super realistic and catered to our wants and needs. She has always been available for every question, for every doubt, for every single step that didn’t make sense; no matter the time of day, she ALWAYS responded and made sure to get us the answers we needed. She completely shifted our perspective on having a realtor and just as we were at the peak of giving up, she came in at the perfect time and made the entire process feel so seamless. We definitely had obstacles but Carissa’s knowledge and expertise with everything from our loan type, to things we were looking for in a home made the obstacles feel so minuscule. She wasn’t just a realtor for us, she made us feel so comfortable and confident with everything. We have learned so much more about houses through Carissa and would use her a thousand times over. We are so thankful for Carissa and can’t recommend her enough! She completely exceeded our expectations and we will definitely be looking forward to having Carissa for future purchases. Thank you Carissa for helping us find our perfect home!

about 2 years ago
Superior Quality of Work

Carissa gave us superior quality of work. Her expertise and professionalism were what we consider exceptional. We were a challenge for any real estate agent because our plan was to sell our house in New York and move to California. Carissa never batted an eye giving us advice, helping us coordinate it all and basically helping us get through. Timing was a major issue with a move like this. Carissa stayed current on all that was happening with the sale of our house keeping us apprised at every turn. Even we when would frantically call Carissa with a question, she always had the answers to help us continue on. Her knowledge of the ever changing market was above reproach. We feel she helped us get top dollar for our home in New York so we could afford to make the move to California. It all worked out perfectly and we owe a lot to Carissa. Never meeting her before, we were so happy our instincts told us to hire her as our real estate agent! Thank you Carissa! Without question, we highly recommend Carissa to sell your home!

Carissa's properties

Carissa has 10 properties for sale and sold 12 properties in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

For Sale
$259,000
21 Alliger Drive
Tonawanda NY 14150
3
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Red Door Real Estate Wny Llc
SoldJun 5, 2026
$200,000
74 Waverly Street
Springville NY 14141
3
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of WNY Metro Roberts Realty and Red Door Real Estate Wny Llc
Pending
$299,900
65 Grayton Road
Tonawanda Town NY 14150
3
2
1
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Red Door Real Estate Wny Llc
Pending
$499,900
377 McKinley Parkway
Buffalo NY 14220
6
4
2
Multi-Family
Listing courtesy of Red Door Real Estate Wny Llc
Show all 22 properties
Email
© 2026 RateMyAgent