Carie's profile

Carie's reviews

  5  
Carie has 16 reviewsacross 7 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Buyer review
Carie is a professional and personable real estate agent who works hard to earn her commission.
23 days ago
Carie is a professional and personable real estate agent who works hard to earn her commission.

We had a great experience working with Carie in recent our home search. Starting with the initial meeting, she took the time to understand what we were looking for and helped us find a beautiful home in a wonderful neighborhood close to our daughter and her family. She exceeded our expectations. Carie handled every detail with care and professionalism, making the complicated process of buying a home feel smooth and well-organized. She was consistently responsive. She answered all of our questions quickly and clearly, which made us feel supported at every step. One of the things we appreciated most was her network of trusted service providers. Her recommendations were excellent and helped us transition into our new home without the hassle of finding reliable help on our own. Overall, Carie made the entire experience significantly less stressful and far more enjoyable than we expected. We are truly grateful for her guidance and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, attentive, and dependable real estate agent.

Buyer review
Excellent communicator, solved all issues that came up, attentive to our needs
23 days ago
Excellent communicator, solved all issues that came up, attentive to our needs

Carie is an outstanding realtor! She came highly recommended by our daughter and we are so glad we chose her to find our new home. Carie asked many questions to know how to help us and answered all of our many questions. She was patient, kind, knowledgeable and confident. She was helpful in addressing a few issues we encountered during the process of buying our home. We highly recommend Carie and would absolutely use her again!

Seller review
Amazing real estate professional
6 months ago
Amazing real estate professional

We met Carie when she helped us find our home of the last 9 years. When we decided to downsize, we called Carie again. She was instrumental in helping recommend a number of touch ups to the house that helped us ultimately get well above ask. We could always count on Carie for finding resources we needed in the sell/move, being responsive, professional, and caring.

Seller review
Carie is the Best.
7 months ago
Carie is the Best.

Carie is terrific, she knows the market and is a true professional. I trust her completely and strongly recommend her to others.

Seller review
Carie is extremely knowledgeable, communicated well, and overall was wonderful to work with.
7 months ago
Carie is extremely knowledgeable, communicated well, and overall was wonderful to work with.

Carie sold our house premarket. She was able to negotiate terms so that we could stay in our home for six months until we moved out of town. She actually represented a number of homes in the area at the same time and was able to sell two of them premarket. Carie understands her market well. She is easy to work with. We were very pleased with the final outcome and sale of the house. I would highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

Buyer review
Carie is amazing
about 2 years ago
Carie is amazing

Carie is amazing. I have worked with other realtors in the past to buy a house and to sell. Carie is by far the best! She was able to quickly understand my needs in a house and she helped to negotiate an amazing offer. She is also just a great honest person to be around!

Seller review
Selling our property in Hilliard, Ohio was no easy task, but Carie Igel was nothing short of...
almost 3 years ago
Selling our property in Hilliard, Ohio was no easy task, but Carie Igel was nothing short of...

Selling our property in Hilliard, Ohio was no easy task, but Carie Igel was nothing short of exceptional. Her in-depth market knowledge, negotiation prowess, and unwavering dedication ensured our home found the right buyers, even under challenging conditions. Throughout the process, Carie's professionalism and genuine care stood out, making every step smoother for us. Highly recommend Carie and Cutler Real Estate for any real estate needs.

1 - 12 of 16
© 2026 RateMyAgent