Caitlin's profile

Caitlin's reviews

  5  
Caitlin has 13 reviewsacross 11 different locations, showing 12.
Seller review
Great experience
10 months ago
Great experience

Caitlin was very helpful. She was receptive to all communication. She didn't seem to mind when we were constantly texting her. Very communicative of every showing either by her or another agent. We were well pleased with our experience.

Seller review
Selling parent’s home.
10 months ago
Selling parent’s home.

Caitlin was very kind, knowledgeable and professional. She was always pleasant and informed us things we might want to complete before the house was listed . Also she was very prompt to contact us about the results of the showings and inform us of upcoming showings. I would highly recommend her to be your agent.

Seller review
Wonderful selling experience with a very knowledgeable agent!
over 1 year ago
Wonderful selling experience with a very knowledgeable agent!

Caitlin made my entire home selling process as least stressful for me as possible. From the initial meeting to advising and guidance on what items needed repaired before placing house on market. Caitlin had buyers lined up as soon as listing hit and within 48 hrs had 2 or 3 offers. Once offer was accepted Caitlin contined to help with woth all necessary paperwork, township inspections etc. This was my first time selling a home and I will say because if Caitlin the only stress I had was the actual packing an moving which she even offered assistance with that. I could not recommend Caitlin more to anyone wanting to buy or sell their property! Caitlin will guide you the entire way!

Seller review
Great Agent for Buying or Selling Your Home!!
over 1 year ago
Great Agent for Buying or Selling Your Home!!

I first worked with Caitlin in 2018 when I purchased my home. She walked me through all the paperwork, made sure I was kept informed and provided top notch service throughout the buying process. In 2024 I decided to sell that house and called Caitlin to help. She toured the house with me to look at all the updates and changes I had made to ensure we priced it correctly. We decided on a price and listed it on 10/26. Less than a month later it was sold! Caitlin again kept me informed of the progress and was always available for questions. Highly recommended!!

Seller review
Caitlin was terrific from start to finish and even after our house sold
almost 4 years ago
Caitlin was terrific from start to finish and even after our house sold

Caitlin was terrific from start to finish and even after our house sold, checking in to see how we were settling in at our new place out of state. She was very efficient. Our house sold in 4 days and that is largely due to her recommendations and wonderful listing. She was on top of every step with the sale of our home. She made the entire process so simple. She is very knowledgeable not just about Jefferson Hills but the entire South Hills area. There are not enough stars to give her nor enough thanks for making a huge relocation so easy. I would highly recommend her to sell or buy a home with.

Buyer review
5 stars all the way around
almost 4 years ago
5 stars all the way around

5 stars all the way around. A year ago Caitlin helped my mother in law sell her house and she was so easy to work with and attentive to details that when we decided to relocate back to Pittsburgh from Virginia, I reached out immediately. Despite being 8 hours away, she would research any house we wanted and was able to do video tours as soon as they were available. Once we sold our house we were in a suuuuper tight window to find a house. In between 5 showings, she was able to add one more that came back onto the market a few MINUTES earlier- and that was the one. The whole process was painless. E-sign was super convenient. We always knew where we were in the process. And now only a month later, we are in the new house. Please give her a try, you won’t regret it.

Buyer review
Caitlin was phenomenal and so patient
about 4 years ago
Caitlin was phenomenal and so patient

Caitlin was phenomenal and so patient. She communicated with us so well and we never were unaware of anything transpiring with our transaction. She put us in touch with some really wonderful people and closing day was exactly 30 days from when we viewed the house and made an offer. I highly recommend Caitlin for any of your home buying or selling needs. Excellent experience!

Buyer review
Caitlin was great to work with
over 4 years ago
Caitlin was great to work with

Caitlin was great to work with. She was present during all inspections and even helped clean the home before closing. She was always available to help us or answer questions. Caitlin is very involved and knowledgeable about home buying. I'm glad she helped us find our new home!

Seller review
Caitlin was great to work with throughout the entire journey
about 5 years ago
Caitlin was great to work with throughout the entire journey

Caitlin was great to work with throughout the entire journey. She helped us close the sale far above what other agents wanted to list the property at. She was super responsive to every question we asked.

Buyer review
Caitlin is very knowledgeable, friendly and professional
over 5 years ago
Caitlin is very knowledgeable, friendly and professional

Caitlin is very knowledgeable, friendly and professional. She listens and takes your lead unlike a salesperson. That was the main reason I returned to her service from another realtor. Never made us feel like we were wasting her time. I would highly recommend her and Costa Realty.

1 - 12 of 13
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent