Butch Metcalf

Butch Metcalf

Broker at CITISTAR REALTY
  •   5   (4 reviews)

About Butch

CitiStar Realty, a trusted and reputable real estate agency specializing in beach properties in Panama City Beach. With over 15 years of experience in the industry, we have successfully served countless buyers and sellers since our establishment in 2006. We believe we have a unique opportunity to help you maximize the value of your property in the current falling market. We understand that selling a property in such circumstances can be challenging, but rest assured, our team at CitiStar Realty is well-equipped to navigate these conditions and ensure a successful outcome for you. One of the key advantages of working with CitiStar Realty is our extensive online marketing strategy. We have invested heavily in creating a strong online presence, with over 100 web domains dedicated to showcasing our listings. This allows potential buyers to easily search for properties by complex, providing them with a seamless experience and increasing the visibility of your listing. Furthermore, we offer our buyers an instant email notification system, ensuring that they are notified of new properties that match their criteria the moment they hit the market. This proactive approach has proven to be highly effective in attracting motivated buyers, even in a falling market. At CitiStar Realty, our motto is "If it is right for the customer, the rest takes care of itself." We firmly believe in providing exceptional service and value to our clients. As part of our commitment to you, we are pleased to offer FREE property valuations, allowing you to gain a comprehensive understanding of your property's current market value. Additionally, we can provide you with free referrals to top agents in any town in America, should you require assistance beyond our local expertise. I understand that the current market conditions may be causing concern, particularly if you are experiencing losses on a daily basis. However, I assure you that our team at CitiStar Realty is dedicated to helping you navigate these challenges and achieve the best possible outcome for your property sale. Always call or text to (850) 319-6324. Butch Metcalf, Broker / Owner

Butch's reviews

  5  
Butch has 4 reviewsacross 2 different locations, showing 4.
Review Butch
about 2 years ago
Good Agent to work with always

Just hard to say in words how the past years I have dealing with you has you have a great friend and agent I never had a concern that you were always looking out for me to get the best deals If I ever need you I know that you are always there for me and my interest Thanks David

over 2 years ago
Highly recommend!

Butch Metcalf was with me every step of the way during my building process. It was nearly a two year process for my new construction home and I couldn’t have asked for a better agent.

over 2 years ago
The Best Realtor, bar none, I've worked with in my 44 years of buying and selling real estate.

I can’t speak highly enough of Butch Metcalf, my real estate agent. His professionalism, knowledge, honesty, integrity and work ethic are all I could ask for from an agent. His due diligence in finding a buyer and selling my Condominium is very much appreciated. Butch knows more about the PCB real estate market than any other agent I've worked with in the past. I have the utmost respect for him as a real estate professional and value his opinion regarding the fluctuating real estate market in the panhandle. When it comes to listing, buying or selling real estate in Panama City Beach, Florida, I always recommend Butch Metcalf of CitiStar Realty.

almost 3 years ago
Experienced and trustworthy

It was a pleasure working with Butch to sell my condo! His marketing techniques are above and beyond what I was expecting. He followed up with me on every showing with feedback and also gave me a rundown on market conditions regularly. I highly recommend Butch for any real estate transaction.

Butch's properties

Butch has 8 properties for sale and sold 1 property in the last 12 months, showing 4, sorted by most recent activity

SoldMay 13, 2026
$425,000
5214 Trelawney Ave
Lower Grand Lagoon FL 32408
4
2
2
Single-Family
Listing courtesy of Coastal Choice Realty LLC and CitiStar Realty
For Sale
$525,000
1405/6201 Thomas Drive
Lower Grand Lagoon FL 32408
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of CitiStar Realty
For Sale
$769,000
3 Townhomes/1608 Annabellas Way
Upper Grand Lagoon FL 32407
9
9
4
Duplex
Listing courtesy of CitiStar Realty
For Sale
$500,000
B309/8200 Surf Drive
Lower Grand Lagoon FL 32408
2
2
Condo
Listing courtesy of CitiStar Realty
Show all 9 properties
EmailSMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent