Natalie's profile

Natalie's reviews

  5  
Natalie has 141 reviewsacross 40 different locations, showing 12.
Map view
Natalie's qualities as told by our client reviews: empathetic, dedicated, friendly, well-prepared, responsive, clear communication, local expert.
Was this helpful?
Buyer review
Super helpful realtor for first time buyers
9 days ago
Super helpful realtor for first time buyers

Natalie is extremely nice and helpful! Especially for first time buyers, it's very nice having someone who knows exactly what to ask about and what to look for even viewing houses. She's also very communicative throughout the whole process, including checking up after the sale to see how things are going. Strongly recommend!

Buyer review
Finding our forever home!
9 days ago
Finding our forever home!

We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor than Natalie for buying our first home in Utah! From start to finish, she made the entire process feel smooth, stress-free, and exciting. Natalie was always quick to answer questions, incredibly knowledgeable, and truly had our best interests in mind every step of the way. We always felt supported and never pressured, which made such a huge difference during such a big life milestone. Thanks to Natalie, we officially get to call Utah our forever home, and we’re so grateful for all her hard work and guidance. Highly recommend her !!!

Seller review
Natalie maintained the highest standards of professionalism. She was a JOY to work with!
24 days ago
Natalie maintained the highest standards of professionalism. She was a JOY to work with!

We had an outstanding experience with Natalie, who truly exceeded our expectations throughout the entire home selling process. We always felt well-informed and supported, whether it was through detailed emails, quick phone calls, or timely text updates. She listened carefully to our needs and preferences, making us feel heard and understood every step of the way. We are incredibly grateful for the support and expertise Natalie provided. We wholeheartedly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home—you will be in excellent hands!

Seller review
Results Driven - You want Natalie on your side
26 days ago
Results Driven - You want Natalie on your side

Selling a home can feel stressful but Natalie made the entire experience smooth, efficient, and enjoyable. From day one, she brought a level of professionalism, honesty, and work ethic that immediately set her apart. Natalie is incredibly knowledgeable about the market and strategic in her approach. She guided us through pricing, positioning, and negotiations with confidence and clarity, always keeping our best interests front and center. What stood out most was her transparency. She was upfront, realistic, and never overpromised, which built a lot of trust throughout the process. We felt like partners in the process, while still being provided a tailored and unique approach to confidently sell our home. The results speak for themselves: even in this uncertain market we were offered listing price in roughly half the average time on market. She was extremely responsive and detail-oriented. She listened to every concern we held and responded with grace and a realistic approach to next steps along the way. Her ability to manage the entire process, from listing to closing, gave us total peace of mind. If you're looking for a realtor who is not only professional, hardworking, and honest, but also genuinely cares about her clients and delivers results, Natalie is the one you want in your corner. I would absolutely recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home.

Buyer review
If buying or selling a Home, you want Natalie on your team!
about 1 month ago
If buying or selling a Home, you want Natalie on your team!

Two years ago, we reached out to Natalie when we needed to downsize and sell our home of 20 years. Naturally, when we found ourselves amidst another unforeseen life change and needed to purchase another home, we turned to Natalie once more. She didn't hesitate to "jump" right in and guide us in finding another beautiful home. Six weeks later, we have the keys and are ready to settle in to our "forever" house :) In other words, when the going got a little rough, Natalie did not bail, but took the helm, provided the life jackets and helped sail us into yet another home. Thank-you Natalie! You are a life-saver!

Seller review
Wonderful experience
2 months ago
Wonderful experience

Natalie was amazing: she handled every detail with such skill. Any problems or worries were quickly taken care of and sorted out successfully. She sold our house fast without any fuss or hassle. I would definitely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.

Buyer review
Amazing Agent
2 months ago
Amazing Agent

Natalie was exceptional; she managed every detail with great skill. Any issues or concerns were promptly addressed and resolved successfully. She located the perfect house for us within our specified timeline. I would recommend her to anyone who is buying or selling a home.

Seller review
Natalie made the home selling process enjoyable from start to finish
2 months ago
Natalie made the home selling process enjoyable from start to finish

Selling a home in a tough market can be incredibly stressful, but working with Natalie made all the difference. From day one, she was honest, strategic, and completely committed to getting our home sold despite the challenges. she guided us through pricing, staging, and marketing with a clear plan, kept us informed every step of the way, and never lost momentum or confidence. What really stood out was her persistence and professionalism, she truly went above and beyond to make sure our home got the attention it deserved. Thanks to her hard work and expertise, we were able to successfully sell our home when it felt almost impossible. We’re incredibly grateful and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a dedicated and trustworthy realtor

Seller review
Hands on and deeply cares about the customer experience!
3 months ago
Hands on and deeply cares about the customer experience!

Natalie is wonderful both as a real estate agent and a person! In every measurable category I can think of she went above and beyond to make us feel informed, respected, and heard. I truly believe she cares about us as people as opposed to just a business transaction. This was especially important because it was our first ever home sale. She met us where we were at, all while being honest and up front. This is exactly what you need when someone is selling your home! Natalie's communication, follow up, and follow through is second to none. If you have the opportunity to work with her you are going to get an experience that feels very customized to you. If you have the opportunity to work with Natalie you should take it!

Buyer review
Natalie Treated Us Like Family During Our Relocation
4 months ago
Natalie Treated Us Like Family During Our Relocation

We truly cannot say enough good things about Natalie. Moving from Ohio to Tooele, Utah on a short timeline (less than 45 days) felt overwhelming from the start. We were trying to prepare our home back in Ohio for sale while also needing to find the right home in Utah from out of state — and Natalie made the entire process feel manageable and even reassuring. From the very beginning, Natalie was not only extremely knowledgeable and professional, but also genuinely kind and caring. She wasn’t just doing a job, she truly cared about us and what was best for our family. That genuineness is rare, and it meant everything during such a stressful transition. Since we were still in Ohio for all of the process, Natalie went above and beyond to be our eyes and ears in Utah. She found us the perfect home in Tooele, completed the walkthrough, and made thoughtful recommendations, all while keeping us informed every step of the way. We always felt confident that she had our best interests at heart. Natalie was always responsive, patient with our questions, and incredibly supportive throughout the entire journey. Her warmth, honesty, and attention to detail gave us peace of mind when we needed it most. We are so grateful for Natalie’s dedication and the care she showed us throughout this experience. If you are looking for a Realtor who is truly genuine, hardworking, and will treat you like family — especially during a relocation — we cannot recommend Natalie enough. We love our new home and feel so lucky to have had her by our side.

Seller review
Exceptional Realtor with Deep Market Knowledge and Outstanding Communication
4 months ago
Exceptional Realtor with Deep Market Knowledge and Outstanding Communication

Summary of Your Experience Natalie made the selling process smooth, strategic, and stress-free from start to finish. Your Review Working with Natalie Pate-Wagner as the seller of 11139 South 1330 East was an excellent experience. From our first conversation, it was clear that Natalie has a deep understanding of the local market and a strong grasp of pricing strategy. She provided clear guidance on how to position the home, what mattered most to buyers, and how to maximize value. Natalie’s communication was outstanding throughout the entire process. She was always responsive, proactive, and transparent, keeping us informed at every step and explaining options clearly so we could make confident decisions. There were no surprises—just consistent follow-through and professionalism. She handled negotiations with confidence and skill, advocated strongly on our behalf, and managed every detail with care. Natalie is organized, knowledgeable, and genuinely invested in her clients’ success. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking to sell or buy a home.

1 - 12 of 141
SMS
© 2026 RateMyAgent